- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces piecewise information limited (PIL) mechanims, which limit the amount of information a model retains from each datapoint in its training data. This includes differentially private mechanisms and some deterministic algorithms. The paper suggests this framework as a copyright protection standard. It allows the quanitification at a granular level, to what degree the prompt increases the risk of a generative model regurgitating a copyrighted work. The paper also proposes an auditing procedure for memorization testing.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a novel protection framework beyond differential privacy (DP) which includes both DP and non-DP mechanisms.
- The framework does not require training examples to be independent. This is useful for real-world datasets, where the same information may appear in multiple examples through duplication, paraphrasing, or other correlations.
- The paper also proposes an auditing procedure based on extracting training data from models.
Critical weaknesses
- The framework is significantly more complex than DP, and Theorem 1 contains quantities that might not available or that are difficult to compute or estimate in practice such as the conditional reconstruction entropy.
- Lemma 1 connects -DP to -PIL; however, the privacy bound is only valid under a specific adjacency relation. It can be inferred from Definition 2 that the adjacency is replace-one or substitute but this needs to be made more clear. Otherwise, the bound would be different under add/remove.
- The advantages for using this framework over DP are not clear enough from the empirical compairson. Although the paper proves that PIL is a broader class of mechanisms than DP, this alone does not show that PIL offers a better protection/privacy-utility trade-off in practice.
- As section 5 already acknowledges, it is still unclear how to leverage non-DP PIL mechanism in the training of large models beyond basic applications such as hyperparameter tuning.
Questions for authors
- What are the practical advantages of PIL over DP? DP has a realtively clearer definition, interpretation, many mechanisms to choose from, and widely available software implementions. Could the authors provide a concrete example where PIL offers a meaningful advantage over DP, particularly in terms of the protection-utility trade-off?
- Could the authors confirm that the adjacency used throughout is the substitute adjacency, and that using add/remove would change some results?
2 comments
Thank you for your detailed response and clarifications. I appreciate the additional explanation of the theoretical advantages of PIL and the clarification regarding the adjacency relation.
However, I remain unconvinced about the practical advantages of PIL over DP, particularly in the context of training generative models, which is a central motivation of the paper.
While the authors demonstrate that PIL is a strictly more general framework than DP, this theoretical generality does not necessarily translate into improved protection-utility trade-offs. In particular, the proposed approach still relies on DP mechanisms for model training, while the applicability of non-DP PIL mechanisms to large-scale model training remains an open problem, as acknowledged by the authors. Furthermore, the experiments evaluate the extraction procedure rather than empirically validating the PIL framework or its practical advantages over DP.
Demonstrating a non-DP PIL mechanism that achieves a better protection-utility trade-off than a comparable DP mechanism would be a substantial finding and would significantly strengthen the manuscript.
For these reasons, while I appreciate the authors' clarifications, I will maintain my original score of 2.
Response
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our work. We address your comments below and are happy to clarify further.
Estimating reconstruction entropy terms of Theorem 1/Reconstruction entropy is not measurable in practice. We agree, and moreover, as we discuss in the paper, the functional reconstruction entropy may change based on the adversary. This is why it is important that implementing PIL algorithms requires no knowledge of this quantity; PIL algorithms are defined only in terms of max information capacity. As with previous frameworks for reconstruction protection, we characterize the level of protection in terms of how much reconstruction risk increases with access to the model, rather than attempting to guarantee absolute bounds.
More complex than DP. While understanding the protection guarantees of our framework does require some work, we emphasize that a key feature of our framework is that PIL algorithms are conceptually easy to implement. They can be implemented by composing DP and conditionally bounded description length mechanisms. The former is well understood, and the latter class is relatively simple (i.e. one just needs to know the size of the range of the mechanism after fixing some number of inputs).
Further, we are providing protection guarantees that are more general and adaptive than are traditionally provided with DP, and so the complexity of phrasing these guarantees cannot be directly compared to DP interpretations that operate in simpler settings, such as occurs with i.i.d. data.
What are the advantages of PIL over DP? A key motivation of our framework is that DP is fundamentally an overly strong notion for controlling reconstruction risk. By comparison, PIL has two key benefits. First, the max-information framework used by PIL more directly relates to the increase in reconstruction risk. It does not require defining problematic/ambigous terms such as "membership'', which are not fundamentally relevant to the reconstruction problem. For similar reasons, this also allows us to reason about correlated data entries, which are often ignored in works based on DP. Second, PIL allows for a strictly larger class of mechanisms than DP, via (potentially noiseless) bounded description length mechanisms. A clear instance of how this improves utility is the result for exact histograms we present in Appendix D.2. Such exact release is not possible under DP. Additionally, a practical advantage is that PIL allows model trainers to ensure formal protection guarantees without substantially changing hyperparameter tuning procedures. By contrast, existing DP training procedures often ``cheat'' by ignoring hyperparameter tuning due to the problems that arise from adding noise to this process.
Techniques that allow formal protection guarantees while preserving functional generative models is an important open problem, but it is also one shared by all existing formal reconstruction/copyright protection frameworks we are aware of. We believe the preexisting body of work devoted primarily to understanding how to think about and protect against reconstruction and copyright infringement demonstrate that there is substantial interest in foundational work on this topic, even it does not immediately lead to practical algorithms.
DP adjacency notion. You are correct, the stated results use replace-one adjacency. We have made a note of this in the revision. We note that (ϵ,δ)-DP under add/remove implies (2ϵ,(1+eϵ)δ)-DP under the replace-one relation.