- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper extends WSAG-PLSP for weakly supervised affordance grounding with three components: Action-Aware Exocentric Pooling (AAEP), reliability-calibrated pseudo-label refinement, and Peak-Anchored Support Expansion (PASE). The method aims to improve spatial precision in exocentric transfer, pseudo-label supervision, and final prediction, and reports improved results on the Seen and Unseen splits of AGD20K.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a reasonable limitation of existing weakly supervised affordance grounding methods: object-level exocentric cues may be too coarse when different actions correspond to different functional regions of the same object. The proposed three-stage spatial refinement framework is conceptually coherent. The method achieves strong quantitative results on AGD20K, improving over the reported WSAG-PLSP results on both Seen and Unseen splits.
Critical weaknesses
-
The current ablations are not sufficient to tell where the improvement actually comes from. Since the method is built directly on WSAG-PLSP, I would expect a controlled baseline using the authors' own code and training setup with all three new components removed. Instead, Table 2 only removes one component at a time, while the WSAG-PLSP numbers in Table 1 are copied from the original paper. AAEP is also not cleanly ablated: it adds both action-conditioned pooling and VLPart/SAM-based spatial supervision, so removing AAEP removes both at once. I think the paper needs at least a same-setting WSAG-PLSP baseline, an action-aware pooling variant without the extra pseudo-mask supervision, and a variant with the pseudo-mask supervision but without action-aware pooling. Otherwise, it is hard to know which part is actually responsible for the reported gain.
-
The pseudo-label refinement contains many handcrafted choices, but these choices are not really validated. The method manually assigns different actions to spatial templates, such as upper regions for support actions, object edges for grasping, and ends/edges for tool-use actions. Its reliability score is then mainly determined by the area of the refined mask. These rules may work on AGD20K, but the current experiments do not show whether they are necessary or robust. I would like to see at least a refinement variant without the handcrafted action prior, a comparison between fixed fusion and the proposed reliability-based fusion, and sensitivity results for the main coverage/reliability thresholds. Without these experiments, it is difficult to tell whether the improvement comes from the proposed refinement idea or from dataset-specific tuning.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide a controlled WSAG-PLSP baseline under exactly the same implementation and training setup, with AAEP, label refinement, and PASE all disabled?
Can the authors disentangle action-conditioned pooling from the additional VLPart/SAM pseudo-mask supervision in AAEP, e.g., by evaluating each component independently?
How were the handcrafted spatial templates and thresholds selected, and how sensitive are the results to these choices?