- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
I am not familiar with this area and cannot assess the submission as a specialist. As I understand it, the paper explains one recorded action of a memory policy by changing one declared input: the current observation, the past followed by a memory replay, or the legal actions. It does not propose a new explanation method. The checks agree with the formulas. Recovery is complete against a matched clean record and much weaker against retrieved records. The trained tasks are a short symbol sequence and a three-step recall exercise.
Critical strengths
The contribution is a procedure that explains one recorded action by changing one declared input, and by replaying memory when the past changes. It reports both full recovery against a matched clean record and much weaker recovery against retrieved records.
Critical weaknesses
The evaluation is limited to a symbolic sequence and a three-step memory task. I do not see what this procedure contributes to current robot reinforcement learning or large-model reinforcement learning. A single-factor replacement is also difficult to interpret: if the alternative input would have produced the same action in that situation, the action probability need not change, and the factor appears irrelevant.
Questions for authors
I am not familiar with this area and cannot assess the submission as a specialist.