- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses shortcut learning caused by coarse segmentation annotations in medical imaging. The authors formulate segmentation refinement as a machine unlearning problem and propose a certified pixel-level unlearning framework with theoretical guarantees on spurious information reduction. They further develop a one-shot certified unlearning algorithm to correct pretrained segmentation models without full retraining. Experiments on ISIC melanoma and SIIM-ACR pneumothorax datasets show competitive shortcut robustness and favorable trade-offs among segmentation accuracy, annotation cost, and computational efficiency. The overall idea is insteresting.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses shortcut learning caused by coarse segmentation annotations, a practically relevant challenge in medical imaging and formulate segmentation refinement as machine unlearning is interesting and provides a new direction for mitigating shortcut learning.
- The paper introduces an information-theoretic objective and derives theoretical guarantees connecting certified unlearning to shortcut reduction.
Critical weaknesses
- Definition 2.1 guarantees indistinguishability from a retrained model, while Definition 2.2 compares predictions directly with fine masks. The connection between these guarantees is insufficiently justified, the authors should clarify it.
- Removing incorrect foreground constraints is not necessarily equivalent to relabeling those pixels as background under standard segmentation losses.
Questions for authors
- How does the standard certified unlearning guarantee in Definition 2.1 imply Definition 2.2, given that the former compares against a retrained model while the latter compares against fine segmentation masks?
- How is removing incorrect foreground constraints equivalent to relabeling those pixels as background? Does this equivalence hold under standard segmentation losses?
- How do the class-conditional prediction bounds in Equations (5)–(6) guarantee a reduction in spurious mutual information, which depends on the joint distribution of predictions, pathology, and artifacts?
- Given the relatively low Dice scores and high variance in some configurations, can the authors provide stronger segmentation baselines, additional statistical analyses, and evaluations with larger models?