- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work presents MELD, a weakly supervised approach for whole-slide image classification using attention, morphology tokens, and class-specific diagnostic evidence. The authors evaluated the method on four datasets using two feature encoders. MELD achieved the highest Macro-F1 in six of eight settings. Additional experiments examined tumor localization, morphological consistency, prediction faithfulness, and image compression.
Critical strengths
- The work addresses an important limitation of attention-based methods by examining which morphological patterns support or oppose a diagnosis.
- The mathematical formulation allows individual tile contributions to be connected directly to the classification score. The deletion experiments provide further support for this connection.
- The authors compared the method with 14 baselines using five training seeds. Component ablations and paired bootstrap comparisons strengthen the evaluation.
- The pathologist-reviewed examples and compression results demonstrate potential applications of the learned morphology representation.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty should be explained more clearly in relation to existing prototype-based and interpretable MIL methods. Since the shared reference term cancels when comparing class scores, the additional role of PMI beyond prototype classification needs clarification.
- The evidence maps used for localization exclude attention weights, whereas the exact prediction contributions include them. Therefore, a region highlighted in the evidence map may have limited influence on the final prediction. The paper should distinguish these two interpretations more clearly.
- Different thresholding procedures were used for MELD and the localization baselines. This may affect the comparison. Results using validation-selected thresholds or matched sensitivity would provide stronger evidence of improved localization.
- The morphological assessment is mainly qualitative. Although the examples show recognizable tissue patterns, quantitative consistency, agreement between pathologists, and stability across training seeds were not reported.
- Some experimental details require clarification, particularly the bootstrap sampling unit and the downstream classifier training procedure used for compression.
Questions for authors
-
What does the PMI formulation contribute beyond the empirical prototype classifier, particularly for prediction and interpretation? - How do the attention-weighted tile contributions compare with the attention-decoupled evidence maps for localization?
- Do the localization improvements remain when thresholds are selected using the same validation procedure for all methods?
- Was the pathologist assessment blinded, and how consistently were the sampled tiles assigned the same morphological interpretation?
- Were patients or individual slides resampled for the bootstrap analysis? Was DSMIL retrained for each compression setting?
Yes, PMI can be extend to the prediction task.
Regarding the thresholds for PMI and attention, the two measures have fundamentally different properties. Attention weights are non-negative and normalized to sum to one, whereas PMI can take both positive and negative values. A positive PMI indicates that a token provides supporting evidence for the class prediction, while a negative PMI indicates evidence against it. Therefore, zero serves as a natural and interpretable threshold for PMI, unlike attention weights.