acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SDTA-MDP: Symbolic Distributed Time Aggregation for Continuous Control

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Existing methods address continuous-state Markov decision processes (MDPs) with continuous actions, but balancing control performance, computational cost, and interpretability remains challenging. We propose Symbolic Distributed Time-Aggregated MDP solving (SDTA-MDP). Building on symbolic state partitioning, the framework combines time aggregation over semantic partitions with local control for finite and bounded continuous actions. The topology groups states by feasible program behavior and summarizes block interiors through absorption cost, duration, and successor probabilities. SDTA-MDP solves a frontier semi-Markov decision process with time aggregation and passes the resulting block actions to local controllers for action selection. We establish path signature preservation and bound the effect of absorption estimation error on the frontier Bellman update. Experiments show that SDTA-MDP achieves higher success rates and lower costs than the evaluated baselines on selected stochastic tasks. For environments supplying executable dynamics and branch predicates, the framework organizes continuous states into interpretable symbolic blocks and summarizes their temporal behavior for control.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
State abstraction, Symbolic execution, Model-based planning, Continuous control, Time aggregation, Semi-Markov decision processes

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_xbJdOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies continuous-state control when executable dynamics and symbolic path predicates are available. SDTA-MDP groups states by possible program paths, estimates stopped-excursion costs, durations, and successor probabilities, and solves a reference frontier SMDP. Its block actions guide a local controller with task-defined terminal heuristics; bounded continuous actions use representative actions and local candidate refinement. The analysis establishes path-signature preservation, conditional successor-support correctness, and sampling-error bounds for the reference model. Seven small stochastic tasks evaluate control quality, representation size, and computational cost.

Critical strengths

Combining semantic partitions with temporal summaries is a useful integration direction. The paper clearly distinguishes path preservation from value preservation and limits its theoretical claims accordingly. The evaluation includes matched seeds, uncertainty estimates, preparation costs, and a local-lookahead ablation; several tasks achieve good control with few symbolic blocks.

Critical weaknesses

The contribution of the frontier SMDP to the executed controller is insufficiently established. Section 2.3 explicitly passes only the block action, while finite-action local search enumerates all actions independently of that input (lines 309-311). Its terminal potential is also task-defined rather than the frontier value (lines 340-342). Table 11 removes local lookahead, but does not test whether the frontier solve improves the same local controller.

The planning comparison does not resolve this concern: MPC holds each candidate action constant for six steps, whereas SDTA-MDP searches future action choices with a terminal heuristic (Appendix D). A matched local-planning baseline would better establish the benefit of time aggregation. The small task suite and substantial preparation times also leave the practical advantage uncertain.

Novelty needs sharper positioning. SymPar, Section 4 already includes existential elimination of disturbance variables and intersection of overlapping path conditions. The related-work discussion also omits symbolic dynamic programming for continuous states and actions, particularly Zamani et al. (AAAI 2012). These connections do not establish duplication, but narrow what is new.

Questions for authors
  1. What dependence on the solved frontier policy remains in finite-action execution? Please compare against the same partition, path filtering, heuristic, and lookahead with the frontier solve removed. For continuous actions, how much do fixed or randomized incumbent anchors change actions and performance?
  2. Does the advantage persist against a planner using the same action candidates, terminal potential, safety handling, and noise approximation, while allowing future actions to vary? Please report preparation and online costs separately.
  3. Since the reference distributions need not match actual block-entry distributions, how sensitive are block actions and performance to their choice? A focused sensitivity check would help assess the temporal summaries without requiring a global optimality theorem.
  4. Please distinguish the new components from SymPar's stochastic projection and from prior symbolic dynamic programming, including Zamani et al. (2012). Is the main advance the integration with time aggregation and local control?
Reviewer_LcypOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SDTA-MDP, a framework that combines symbolic state partitioning, time aggregation, and local control for continuous-state MDPs. The method first partitions the state space based on feasible execution paths of the environment program. It then estimates absorption costs, holding times, and successor probabilities for each block-action pair, which are used to construct and solve a frontier SMDP. The resulting block-level actions guide a local lookahead controller for selecting the actual control inputs.

The authors provide theoretical results on path-signature preservation, successor support, and finite-sample estimation errors. Experiments on seven stochastic control tasks compare the proposed method with MPC, SymPar+Q, FineGridVI, TileQ, SMoSE, and SAC. The method achieves competitive performance on several tasks while using relatively compact symbolic partitions in most cases.

Critical strengths

I find the idea of combining symbolic state partitioning with time aggregation interesting. Using the program structure of an environment to guide state abstraction is a reasonable direction, especially for systems with explicit logical conditions or mode switches. The framework also brings together several techniques that are usually studied separately, and it could be useful for control problems where such semantic information is readily available.

The experimental evaluation is fairly extensive, covering both finite and continuous actions under stochastic execution. The authors compare against several relevant baselines and report not only control performance but also computational costs and partition sizes. Some results are encouraging, particularly on DoubleIntegrator. I also appreciate that the paper explicitly discusses several limitations of the proposed method.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is the justification for using program execution paths as the basis for state abstraction. The method assumes that symbolic path predicates are available, but I could not find a sufficiently clear explanation of how they are obtained for the benchmark tasks. Are these predicates extracted from the original environment programs, or are they manually designed based on system dynamics and task-specific knowledge? This distinction matters because the quality of the resulting partition may depend heavily on how the environment is implemented and what predicates are provided.

More importantly, I am not convinced that sharing the same path signature necessarily provides a meaningful abstraction for control. Two states may follow the same program branches while having very different costs, transition probabilities, or optimal actions. Proposition 1 guarantees preservation of path signatures, but this follows from the partition construction and does not establish that the resulting blocks preserve control-relevant information. The paper would be more convincing if it explained under what conditions such a partition is expected to work well. For instance, a program with few or no branches could produce a very coarse partition, whereas a program with many branches could lead to a large number of blocks. It is also unclear how sensitive the method is to different implementations of the same underlying dynamics. I think these issues are central to understanding the applicability of the approach.

I also have concerns about the actual role of the frontier SMDP in the final controller. The SMDP is constructed from absorption rollouts in which the intended action is held fixed until the trajectory leaves the current block or reaches the stopping horizon. In contrast, the local controller can change its action at every step based on the current state. As a result, the transition model optimized by the high-level planner may not accurately reflect the behavior of the final closed-loop controller. The paper does not sufficiently discuss this discrepancy.

Related to this, the interface between the two levels seems rather weak. The frontier solver provides a block-level action, but its value function is not directly used in local planning. For continuous actions, the selected action mainly serves as a reference for generating local candidates. For finite actions, the local controller considers all available actions regardless of the frontier action. Based on the formulation, it is not clear to me how the frontier SMDP actually affects the final policy in the finite-action case. This is particularly concerning since time aggregation is presented as one of the main contributions. The existing NoLook ablation shows that local lookahead is important, but it does not tell us how much is gained from solving the frontier SMDP.

I would therefore like to see a more direct evaluation of the proposed components. In particular, comparing different partitions while keeping the same controller, and removing the frontier SMDP while retaining local lookahead, would help clarify where the performance gains come from. The current baseline comparisons mostly evaluate complete controllers with different planning mechanisms, making it difficult to isolate the benefits of the proposed abstraction and time aggregation.

Finally, I found the presentation somewhat difficult to follow despite the overall structure being clear. The paper introduces several components and mathematical definitions, but there is no concrete example showing how they work together. I think a worked example using BrakingCar or DoubleIntegrator would be very helpful. Starting from the actual environment program and showing the extracted path predicates, symbolic blocks, absorption model, block-level action, and final local action would make the proposed method much easier to understand and reproduce.

Questions for authors
  1. How exactly are the symbolic path predicates obtained in the experiments? Are they automatically extracted from the environment code, or manually provided? Could the authors show the actual predicates and the resulting partition for one representative benchmark, ideally together with a complete example of the control pipeline?

  2. What makes path-signature equivalence a suitable criterion for control-oriented state abstraction? Is there any evidence that states within the same block have sufficiently similar control behavior? I would be interested in seeing a comparison with alternative partitions of similar size under the same SMDP solver and local controller.

  3. Could the authors clarify how the frontier SMDP influences action selection in the finite-action setting? From Equations (10)–(14), the local controller appears to enumerate all available actions without using the frontier values. Would removing the frontier SMDP change the resulting policy or its performance? A NoFrontier ablation would be particularly helpful here.

  4. Since the absorption model assumes a fixed action while the actual controller uses state-dependent local lookahead, how different are the predicted absorption statistics from those observed during closed-loop execution? In particular, have the authors compared the block transition probabilities and holding times under these two execution schemes?

Reviewer_2AcPOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Continuous control in MDPs is a challenging problem due to the size of the search space in which an agent must identify good actions. This paper introduces a symbolic method to aggregate state-actions for continuous control in MDPs. This method partitions state spaces such that blocks consist of actions with strong, temporal correlations (wrt., outcomes, observations, etc.) The paper tries to validate the proposed approach empirically by comparing its performance in several domains against other baseline methods.

Critical strengths

I believe the paper strongly motivates the reasoning behind the method introduced.

Critical weaknesses

I preface my criticisms with the fact that I am very unfamiliar with this line of work. While I am very familiar with work in search in MDPs and continuous control in RL, I have no experience with work in symbolic planning, etc.

That being said, my main concern with this paper is that I cannot assess its significance. Based off of the main results presented, I cannot pinpoint any apparent impact of the proposed algorithm nor can I glean any new insight into this problem domain. The paper touts two advantages for SDTA-MDP: i) performance, and ii) interpretibility.

The experiments do not support the claim that SDTA-MDP achieves higher success rates/lower costs than the other methods. In fact, the results show that there is no significant difference between the performance of SDTA and that of MPC or SAC. Table 6 in the appendix also shows that SDTA requires much more compute time than MPC. Additionally, there is no evidence that shows SDTA results in better interpretibility. Finally, the number of different components of the algorithm, it does not even seem easy to implement. With the paper as it is, I am unable identify the benefits of the proposed method over others.

Questions for authors

No questions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.