- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The article proposes a diffusion based attack image method, which has significantly improved performance compared to previous methods.
Critical strengths
The article differs from previous pixel-based attack methods by focusing on the cross-attention module in the diffusion model to weaken the detector's semantic relevance.
Critical weaknesses
Suggest further polishing or adjusting the writing style of the paper, focusing on the specific tasks of the article, without describing the background too much. It is recommended to start the article by stating whether the research focuses on attack methods or methods to solve attacks, in order to avoid ambiguity.
The author's insights are mentioned multiple times in the article, but the specific insights lack theoretical or experimental support, as seen in line 046 of the main introduction. It is recommended to use PDF format for the images in the article, which makes it easier to zoom in and view details, especially for the attack images studied in the article. There is too little related work content.
Questions for authors
Suggest adding visual content to the experimental results section to showcase the specific attack effects. It is difficult to demonstrate from the ablation results that the AMEND design achieves the optimal balance between attack performance and naturalness.
Can you evaluate the results of object detection methods specifically designed to handle images under attack? It is difficult to fully demonstrate the attack effect of AMEND by only providing the results of general detectors after being attacked by AMEND.