- The reliability of region-level supervision and the localization reward is insufficiently established.
A central motivation of R2F is to improve fine-grained forensic perception through region-grounded reasoning. However, the training pipeline handles locally manipulated and fully AI-generated images differently. For locally manipulated images, bounding boxes can be derived from existing localization annotations, whereas fully generated images without ground-truth boxes rely on teacher-generated suspicious regions.
For these samples, the paper describes filtering based primarily on answer correctness and output format, but does not clearly establish the reliability of the generated bounding boxes. More importantly, PA-RLVR defines its localization reward using IoU against ground-truth boxes, yet it remains unclear how this reward is computed for samples without reliable localization annotations.
This distinction is important because teacher-selected suspicious regions are not necessarily equivalent to objectively verified forgery regions. Without further clarification or validation, it is difficult to determine whether the model learns reliable forensic grounding or primarily reproduces teacher-generated region descriptions.
- The experimental comparisons and task-specific validation do not fully support the breadth of the claims.
The paper presents R2F as a unified multi-domain forensic MLLM, but the baseline comparisons are somewhat inconsistent across evaluations. Table 1 primarily compares against general-purpose and forensic MLLMs, whereas Table 2 evaluates the four OpenMMSec domains against conventional vision-based detectors without including existing unified forensic MLLMs. This makes it difficult to assess the relative advantages of R2F under a consistent multi-domain MLLM evaluation setting.
Furthermore, although fine-grained localization is central to the motivation, most main experiments and component-wise ablations focus on image-level detection accuracy. Localization results are mainly reported in the appendix, without sufficiently isolating the contributions of the proposed distillation and reinforcement learning strategies to localization quality.
The methodological novelty is also somewhat incremental, as tool-use distillation and structured loss weighting have established precedents, while TS-IS primarily modifies the importance sampling granularity of existing policy optimization methods. Stronger localization-oriented validation would help substantiate the significance of this adaptation.
As the rebuttal discussion period is approaching its deadline, we wanted to gently follow up to ensure our previous response has addressed all of your questions and concerns.
In our rebuttal, we provided the corrected Table 4 metrics, the detailed Table 10 evaluation protocol, the complete PA-RLVR policy objective and reward rules, and the component-wise localization IoU ablations under identical data budgets. Notably, regarding the shared questions on component-wise localization gains and the PA-RLVR formulation, Reviewer fvC3 confirmed that our additional experiments and clarifications have substantially addressed their concerns, and Reviewer Yp1W also expressed recognition of our PA-RLVR design and analyses.
We would greatly appreciate any feedback you might have before the discussion window closes, and we remain happy to provide any further clarifications if needed. If our responses have resolved your concerns, we would be very grateful if you could kindly reconsider your final rating.
Thank you very much for your time and thoughtful review!