- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PiERN, which integrates frozen high-precision scientific computation experts, a Text-to-Computation module, and a token-level Token Router into a single language reasoning chain. The experts are first trained on numerical data, Text2Comp learns to map natural-language tasks to expert inputs, and the Router selects either the LLM or a specific expert at each decision point. Expert outputs are written back into the context, after which language reasoning continues. The authors evaluate the method on five downsampled PDEBench tasks and a synthetic battery management task, reporting Text2Comp RMSE on unseen templates, 100% Router accuracy on predefined decision points, PDE RMSE, latency and energy comparisons with MAF, and retention of MMLU/GLUE performance. PiERN-BMS further demonstrates multi-expert composition by first estimating SoH and then using language reasoning to trigger arbitrage computation. The architectural interface is interesting, but the evidence mainly comes from manually constructed templates and downsampled/synthetic data. Evidence for real-world OOD generalization, fair comparisons with strong baselines, total system cost, and the definition of high precision remains insufficient.
Critical strengths
- A unified modular architecture. Token-level routing feeds outputs from specialized numerical experts back into the language model within the same CoT. The interface is clear, interpretable, and easy to modify, and is more compact than explicit multi-agent communication at every step.
- Systematic prototype evaluation across tasks. The experiments cover five PDE tasks and a multi-expert battery workflow, reporting error, latency, tokens, energy consumption, and retention of language capabilities. This provides a reusable experimental framework for future research.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient evidence of generalization and high precision. The unseen split consists of only 20% of the templates within manually constructed template families, and the Router's 100% accuracy comes from predefined decision points. PiERN has higher RMSE than the downsampled experts on all five tasks, so these results do not establish high precision or semantic routing capabilities on real scientific tasks.
- Lack of transparency in baselines and system costs. All fine-tuned models produce invalid outputs, with insufficient reproduction details, and the total parameters/FLOPs of the multi-expert system are not clearly accounted for. The MAF energy/latency comparison lacks a measurement protocol and variance estimates, leaving it unclear whether the efficiency gains can be attributed to the architecture itself.
- Insufficient novelty. The proposed method integrates high-precision scientific computation experts, a Text-to-Computation module, and a token-level Token Router into a single language reasoning chain, but these all appear to be common approaches. The authors need to clarify the specific novelty relative to existing methods. Integrating high-precision computation experts does not seem to be a particularly effective way to address numerical computation problems; tool integration, such as Python tools, is often a better solution.
Questions for authors
Please focus on the following: (i) Does each expert have its own Text2Comp/Router, and how do total parameters, GPU memory, and FLOPs scale with the number of experts? (ii) Why are all SFT PDE outputs invalid, and can reproducible results be provided under the same output interface and budget?
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing PiERN's unified modular architecture and its potential for coordinating multiple scientific computation experts. We clarify the architectural contributions and experimental evidence below.
Regarding generalization and numerical accuracy, PiERN integrates existing scientific computation capabilities into LLM reasoning through semantic-to-numerical alignment and token-level expert routing. Text2Comp maps language-conditioned requests into expert-compatible numerical inputs, while the Token Router dynamically monitors the token generation process and determines whether to continue language generation or invoke a computation expert based on the current contextual representation. Importantly, routing decisions are made dynamically during inference rather than being restricted to manually specified invocation positions or fixed task-specific rules. The reported 100% Router accuracy evaluates its classification performance on the constructed token-level evaluation samples. Our held-out-template evaluation further demonstrates generalization across unseen language templates within the evaluated operation families. We will clarify the scope of these evaluations in the revised manuscript. Regarding numerical accuracy, PiERN is designed to make existing expert capabilities accessible through language-conditioned inputs, rather than to improve an expert that already receives exact numerical inputs. The additional end-to-end error reflects the effect of semantic-to-numerical alignment, which is further quantified in our existing Diffusion-Sorption component evaluation.
Regarding system scalability, our five-task deployment uses one shared response LLM and one shared Token Router, while each task has its own Text2Comp module and numerical expert. The resident parameter count is therefore P_total = P_LLM + P_Router + Σ_k(P_Text2Comp,k + P_Expert,k). With nominal 0.8B backbones, the shared LLM and Router contribute 1.6B parameters, while the five independent Text2Comp modules contribute approximately 4.0B, resulting in approximately 5.6B backbone parameters before adding numerical experts and task-specific heads. This modular design allows additional computation experts to be incorporated without replicating the entire language model and Router. We will distinguish resident parameters from per-request active computation and provide the corresponding resource accounting. For SFT baselines, "Invalid" denotes outputs that cannot be parsed into a non-empty numerical sequence with the required number of elements, rather than outputs with large numerical errors. This highlights the difficulty of directly generating high-dimensional structured numerical outputs through autoregressive language generation, motivating PiERN's separation of language reasoning from numerical computation.
Regarding methodological novelty and the comparison with Python tools, PiERN is not intended to replace general-purpose programming tools or develop a numerical expert that surpasses existing solvers. Its contribution is a unified architectural mechanism for integrating heterogeneous computation experts, including pretrained neural models and conventional non-neural numerical solvers, into LLM reasoning. Our evaluation already includes a Programmatic baseline based on LLM-generated Python code execution (Appendix C, Table 4 and Figure 9). For Qwen3.5-0.8B, PiERN achieves inference latencies of 0.62–0.77 s across the five PDE tasks, compared with 19.99–52.83 s for Programmatic, corresponding to approximately 32–71× lower latency. GPU energy consumption is also reduced by approximately 22–69× across these tasks. These results demonstrate the practical efficiency advantages of PiERN's integrated computation-reasoning architecture over the evaluated Python code execution workflow. Importantly, PiERN combines Text2Comp-based numerical input construction, token-level computational routing, and the integration of expert outputs into the ongoing language context. Furthermore, PiERN-BMS demonstrates compositional computation-reasoning: the LLM first receives battery health estimation results, reasons over the intermediate state, and subsequently invokes another expert for profit computation. This illustrates how heterogeneous computational capabilities can be coordinated within a single reasoning process rather than treated as isolated tool calls.
Finally, regarding the reproducibility of SFT baselines, we will explicitly document the output parsing criteria and evaluation procedure, distinguishing structural generation failures from numerical inaccuracies. We will provide representative saved outputs and corresponding reproduction details where available.
We thank the reviewer again for these constructive comments. We believe these clarifications better demonstrate PiERN's contribution as a unified architecture for integrating heterogeneous scientific computation capabilities into LLM reasoning.