acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Language Operators for Grounded Reward Interfaces

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Reward machines expose temporal reward structure to reinforcement learning (RL), but they are usually finite-state, grounded by hand in symbolic propositions, and learned or constructed one task at a time. These assumptions become restrictive when reward-relevant behavior requires memory beyond finite state, when symbolic task progress must be connected to continuous observations, or when an agent must solve a family of related task specifications rather than a single fixed task. We propose language operators: operators that learn maps from formal task specifications to grounded reward interfaces for RL. Given a specification, the interface predicts valid next events, task completion, and grounded targets from a trajectory prefix and the current observation. We learn these interfaces jointly across related tasks using supervision from formal monitors, and then keep the operator fixed during policy learning. The same parameters define reward-interface behavior for new specifications, allowing task descriptions to change without learning a separate reward model. We instantiate this framework with recurrent and memory-augmented models and evaluate it on BabyAI, WaterWorld, and controlled counting and nesting tasks. Across controlled counting and nesting tasks, WaterWorld, and BabyAI, we compare language operators with learned task-conditioned machines, exact symbolic references with learned grounding, and task-conditioned or recurrent RL baselines. Controlled numerical experiments further demonstrate generalization to task parameters beyond the training range, showing how shared reward-interface learning can support both new task compositions and longer executions.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Formal Language, Reinforcement Learning, Language Operator

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_8iUGOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses the limitations of reward machines, focusing on cross-task transfer and learning reward-machine components (the transition operator and the labelling/grounding function that maps an observation to an event in the reward machine) from task specifications. The paper proposes "language operators", a learned operator that maps a task specification to a "grounded reward interface"; the operator is trained on a family of task specifications and their corresponding reward interfaces, and the paper shows that the operator can be applied to map a new task specification to a reward interface.

Critical strengths
  • The paper's claims and contributions are clear to some extent.
  • The experimental results on the benchmarks support the claim.
Critical weaknesses
  • The paper is not clear; the preliminaries and the method sections contain many undefined terms, such as: prefix-validity, shaping potential, formal monitor, mission identity, and scene-dependent grounding.
  • Even the mathematically defined terms contain undefined terms: What are the target candidates T(o)\mathcal{T}(o), and what do they represent?
  • The paper should be self-contained; it does not contain any reinforcement learning background in the preliminaries section.
  • The method section lacks sufficient detail to provide me with an understanding of the method, and it also contains undefined terms such as valid next events, task completion, grounded targets, and Executable formal monitors. The appendix is not useful either and provides little detail on how the method is actually implemented.
  • The experiments focus on the superiority of the method in comparison to the baselines, but offer little analysis or an ablation study on what components are important for the method to work effectively. The presentation of the results seems somewhat redundant by writing the exact numbers presented in the learning curves.
  • No explanation or definition of what semantic correctness is (line 241) and semantic reference (lines 80 and 243).
  • Baselines are not clear: what is the context in context-only PPO, and how is it being represented? How is the task represented in task-conditioned PPO?
Questions for authors
  • I wrote my questions in the Weaknesses section.
  • Could the authors provide the paper's code? For further inspection.
  • How can I know the implementation details of the method? If I want to code up the method, will the paper provide sufficient detail for this?
Reviewer_GSFVOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Motivated by the limitation of common reward-machine workflows, in which reward machines and their symbolic grounding need to be supplied for each new task, the paper introduces language operators: mappings from task specifications to grounded reward interfaces that encode task-progress information. These mappings are learned in a domain-specific manner and subsequently used for policy training. The approach is evaluated in three domains.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a genuine limitation of existing approaches: reward machines typically need to be constructed for individual tasks, while the grounding function that maps observations to abstract symbolic propositions is often unavailable a priori in practical settings.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The method is insufficiently described, and its conceptual contribution is unclear. Sections 3 and 4 are difficult to follow, and key definitions and notation are either unclear or deferred to the appendix. For example, PrefCxPref_{C_x} is only explained in the appendix, and the notation Δ\Delta is not defined clearly in the main text. What exactly constitutes a task specification, and how is it represented? The definition of I^θ,x\hat{\mathcal I}_{\theta,x} also appears circular rather than providing a constructive definition of the proposed interface.

  2. The generality and novelty of the approach are questionable. According to Eq. 2, the learning objective is defined in a domain-specific manner. This raises doubts about whether language operators constitute a sufficiently general-purpose method.

  3. The interface between the language operator and policy learning is unclear. The paper does not adequately explain how the predicted interface quantities are used to train the policy. The role of the “teacher” is also unclear: what information does it provide, at which stage, and what information remains available during policy learning and evaluation?

  4. The empirical evaluation does not establish a clear claim. The roles of “context-only PPO” and “direct task-conditioned PPO” are insufficiently explained. What information do these baselines receive, and how are their task inputs related to the formal task specifications? In particular, the relationship between formal task specifications and reward machines—which is central to the paper's motivation—is never made sufficiently clear. Consequently, it is difficult to understand what the baselines control for and what the experimental results actually demonstrate.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the precise relationship between a formal task specification, a reward machine, and the grounded reward interface produced by a language operator?

  2. Could the authors clarify the complete training and inference pipeline, including the teacher's role, the information available at each stage, and how the language operator's outputs are used as policy inputs and rewards?

  3. Given the domain-specific objectives in Eq. 2 and the different implementations across the three domains, what aspect of the method is general-purpose, and what distinguishes it from domain-specific task-conditioned models for predicting task progress and grounded targets?

Reviewer_oh22OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper learns shared mappings from task specifications, histories, and observations to grounded reward interfaces. The interfaces predict task progress, completion, and targets, and are frozen during subsequent PPO training. Experiments cover BabyAI, WaterWorld, and Counter/Dyck tasks. The main results demonstrate that structured interfaces can help policy learning. However, the independent benefit of shared operator learning remains difficult to separate from supervision, memory structure, and target context.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper separates semantic prediction accuracy from native control performance.

  2. Context-only and exact-semantic references are useful comparison arms.

  3. In BabyAI, LO-guided completion reaches 86.55%, compared with 57.20% for direct PPO.

  4. The main text explicitly distinguishes different types of reuse and acknowledges differences in supervision and implementation.

  5. The appendix provides additional protocols, replication details, interaction accounting, and component results, strengthening transparency and reproducibility.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The central shared-versus-task-specific motivation is not directly tested. The paper motivates a reusable operator as an alternative to constructing separate task interfaces. However, the main experiments do not compare shared and task-specific learned interfaces under matched supervision and capacity. Improvements over direct PPO establish interface utility, but do not isolate the advantage of sharing the learned mapping across specifications.

  2. The numerical generalization comparison changes multiple factors. The main text states that Counter/Dyck use learned local control with exact generic memory and arithmetic, while the learned-machine comparator differs in capacity and supervision. Thus, the large accuracy gap in Table 1 demonstrates the effectiveness of the implemented system, but cannot establish an architecture-only or learning-mechanism advantage.

  3. Reward-guidance benefits should be distinguished from context benefits. In BabyAI, LO-guided and context-only completion are 86.55% and 84.33%; in the earlier WaterWorld cohort, they are 99.48% and 98.96% (Table 2). Much of the gain over direct PPO may therefore arise from the structured interface context. The newer WaterWorld cohort shows a larger guidance benefit, but the paper correctly identifies it as a different experimental protocol.

  4. The demonstrated generalization scope is narrower than the overall framing may suggest. WaterWorld uses fixed task size and can expose the policy to all 70 balanced orders during training. Native Dyck uses one interface fit and two policy seeds, with predominantly single-color histories. These are useful demonstrations, but provide limited evidence for broad structural generalization or native mixed-color stack reasoning.

Questions for authors
  1. How does a shared operator compare with task-specific interfaces under matched labels, capacity, and training budgets?

  2. Does the numerical advantage persist when the comparison model receives equivalent memory operations and local supervision?

  3. Can the authors test native mixed-color tasks that require LIFO memory, using multiple independently fitted interfaces?

  4. What practical advantage does learned semantic execution offer over exact monitoring with learned grounding in the evaluated regime?

  5. Can the main claims more clearly distinguish interface-context benefits, additional reward-guidance benefits, and cross-specification reuse?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.