- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors proposed ISR-SLAM a distributed RGB-D SLAM system which fuse map from multiple agents via inter-submap reinforcement. Compared with its backbone structure – MAGiC-SLAM, it introduced online feedback, inter-submap Gaussian refinement, and staged global refinement. The contribution here is more like an incremental and reasonable extension of MAGiC-SLAM.
Critical strengths
The core idea moves multi-agent 3DGS refinement from after registration into the mapping process, so local submaps updated with other agents’ observations can participate in the next registration round.
Critical weaknesses
-
The pipeline and method to tackle point registraction are standard. The introduction states that existing methods merge subgraphs only after they have all been fully constructed; however, this claim is too absolute. MAC-Ego3D is also periodic; while it is included as a baseline method for comparison in this paper, its analysis should be emphasized in the Introduction and Related Work sections. It is suggested that OmniMAG-SLAM and MAC-Ego3D separately discuss the differences between their periodic constraints and those in this paper.
-
The experimental results in this paper did not demonstrate a significant advantage, which may limit the paper's validity. Many of the indicators in the article are not the best, more than expected. Furthermore, there is a lack of explanation regarding the suboptimal indicators.
-
As a core component, inter-submap overlap refinement needs stronger motivation and qualitative evidence. Table 3 provides an ablation, but more examples like those in Figure 5 would better show what inconsistencies it fixes, especially quantitative result.
-
The \deltaT_r->t obtained from overlap refinement is discarded after use and does not affect the pose graph. Why should not further utilize this error pose?
-
The main text should include a qualitative comparison of the two sets of data; "AriaMultiagent" is missing from the main text.
-
In Table 5, why is ‘Gaussian of Ours’ missing?
-
Although Table 5 reports per-frame tracking/mapping time and map storage, it is unclear whether the proposed online registration and overlap-refinement costs are included. And it is not efficient to just repot the time consumption and memory for one scene.
-
If later pose-graph optimization changes the relative pose of an already refined submap pair, the previous overlap refinement may no longer be optimal.
Questions for authors
- In Figure 2 caption, Registeredposes lacks space.
- What’s the meaning of equation(4) C_{ref}? In Equation (1), using I.
- The notation on the left-hand side of Equation. (1) is not explicitly defined.
12 comments
Response to Reviewer QHv7 Critical Weaknesses 2
Response to Reviewer QHv7 Critical Weaknesses 2
We thank the reviewer for the assessment of our experimental results. Online Registration Feedback improves spatial alignment between submaps, while Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement reduces inconsistencies between Gaussian maps reconstructed independently by different agents. Together, they allow ISR-SLAM to achieve strong overall localization and reconstruction quality. The gains can vary across scenes and evaluation metrics.
In Table 1 of the original paper, ISR-SLAM achieves the best or joint-best average ATE in four of the six scenes and ranks second in the other two. In Table 2, it ranks first in four of the eight PSNR evaluations and second in the remaining four. In particular, it achieves the best PSNR in all four AriaMultiagent evaluations, covering both novel and training views. These results demonstrate strong overall performance across scenes.
Some LPIPS and Depth L1 results are indeed not the best. Our method primarily targets pose consistency and consistency between submap representations. Better spatial alignment and RGB rendering do not necessarily yield the lowest perceptual or depth error in every scene. Missing or noisy depth observations in real-world data may also limit geometric accuracy. We will clarify these trade-offs in the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer QHv7 Critical Weaknesses 3 Part 1
Response to Reviewer QHv7 Critical Weaknesses 3 Part 1
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. Submap pose alignment corrects their spatial relationships, but Gaussian maps reconstructed independently by different agents may still disagree in color, depth, and local geometry. Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement uses reliable shared observations for cross-view supervision. It directly refines the Gaussian representations in overlapping regions while preserving consistency with local RGB-D observations. This mechanism is described in Section 3.2 of the original paper (lines 252–283).
To evaluate its local effects, we add a quantitative comparison of three overlapping submap pairs (Table R1). After refinement, PSNR increases and Depth L1 decreases in all three shared regions. These results directly demonstrate how the module reduces representation inconsistencies.
Table R1. RGB and depth consistency in overlapping regions before and after Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement.
| Overlapping Submap Pair | RGB PSNR Before Refinement (dB)↑ | RGB PSNR After Refinement (dB)↑ | Depth L1 Before Refinement (cm)↓ | Depth L1 After Refinement (cm)↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overlapping Submap Pair 1 | 39.21 | 41.28 | 0.52 | 0.29 |
| Overlapping Submap Pair 2 | 40.04 | 42.73 | 0.47 | 0.25 |
| Overlapping Submap Pair 3 | 38.86 | 41.92 | 0.55 | 0.33 |
Progressive causal ablation. To evaluate Online Registration–Refinement Reinforcement, we conduct progressive ablations that test whether the benefits of online registration feedback and inter-submap Gaussian refinement extend beyond the stages in which they are applied. The results show that earlier updates can improve reconstruction and localization in later blocks, even when the corresponding optimization is no longer performed. Later optimization can also affect the final quality of earlier blocks. These findings support the proposed reinforcement mechanism.
Specifically, we divide each input RGB-D video sequence into five equal, consecutive temporal blocks (B1–B5). We conduct six ablation settings for each of two components: online pose-graph optimization (PGO) within Online Registration Feedback, and Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement. The component under study is enabled only over the first 0%, 20% (B1), 40% (B1–B2), 60% (B1–B3), 80% (B1–B4), or 100% (B1–B5) of the sequence. The other component remains enabled throughout. We evaluate rendering quality, trajectory accuracy, and geometric reconstruction accuracy for each block and the full sequence to assess the effects across stages (Tables R2–R3).
Effects of earlier optimization on later blocks. We compare the setting without the target optimization (0%) against settings where it is enabled only in earlier blocks (20%, 40%, 60%, or 80%). Specifically, we compare B2 under the 0% and 20% settings, B3 under 0% and 40%, B4 under 0% and 60%, and B5 under 0% and 80%. No new updates from the target component are performed in the evaluated block in either setting. Thus, differences in performance reflect the influence of earlier optimization on later blocks. Even after Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement is disabled, B2–B5 still benefit from earlier Gaussian refinement in reconstruction quality and trajectory accuracy. Similarly, B4 and B5 show better reconstruction quality and trajectory accuracy due to earlier online PGO, despite receiving no new PGO updates. These results indicate that both components can benefit later blocks where the corresponding optimization is no longer active.
Effects of later optimization on earlier blocks. We compare settings with identical optimization schedules up to the evaluated block but different optimization ranges afterward. Specifically, we compare B1 under the 20% and 100% settings, B2 under 40% and 100%, B3 under 60% and 100%, and B4 under 80% and 100%. In each comparison, the optimization schedule is identical through the evaluated block. Only the optimization performed in subsequent blocks differs. The results show an overall improvement in the final reconstruction quality and trajectory accuracy of previously constructed regions as online PGO and Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement continue in later blocks. Thus, the benefits of both components can also be reflected in the final reconstruction and localization results of earlier regions.
One exception occurs when online PGO is enabled only in B1: performance decreases. We believe that early pose corrections are less stable because few submaps and inter-submap constraints are available at that stage. As more submaps and constraints become available, the benefits of online PGO become clearer. This is consistent with the improvements observed in B4 and B5.
Response to Reviewer QHv7 Critical Weaknesses 1
Critical Weaknesses 1:
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this wording issue. Our central contribution is the interaction between online submap registration and Inter-Submap Overlap Refinement. Updated poses and Gaussian representations remain available for subsequent mapping and registration. We agree that our description of existing pipelines may have been too broad and will make it more precise in the revised manuscript.
The abstract and introduction use “A conventional pipeline” and “Conventionally” to describe common staged designs (abstract, lines 35–40; introduction, lines 65–72). This wording may imply that all existing methods follow the same process. We will distinguish the periodic processing in MAC-Ego3D from the dual-factor-graph online pose optimization in OminiMAG-SLAM. We will also clarify that ISR-SLAM refines Gaussian submaps during online mapping and reuses the refined representations in subsequent processing.