acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

QPrune: Quantum-Inspired Visual Token Pruning via Mixed-State Reduction on LVLMs

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) process a large number of visual tokens, resulting in substantial inference overhead, which has motivated extensive research on visual token pruning. Existing methods commonly identify visual tokens based on attention scores, visual saliency, feature similarity, or cross-modal relevance. However, identifying informative visual tokens requires accounting for the interactions between visual and textual tokens, which together form a complex information state. Quantum information theory offers an alternative perspective for analyzing such a complex information state. In this work, we propose QPrune, a quantum-inspired visual token pruning method centered on mixed-state representation. QPrune represents the visual token set as a mixed state, where each visual token is represented as a pure state with an associated probability under the current image-text pair. Based on the mixed state, state-aware token pruning considers both token relevance and state overlap with the retained tokens to reduce redundancy. State-preserving token refinement further supplements local visual information that is insufficiently represented after pruning. Extensive experiments demonstrate that QPrune effectively reduces the number of visual tokens while maintaining strong task performance across different pruning ratios.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LVLMs, Token Pruning, Quantum-Inspired

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_BVc2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes QPrune, a quantum-inspired visual token pruning method for multimodal large language models , aiming to reduce the number of visual tokens during the decoding stage while preserving the model’s multimodal understanding ability as much as possible. The method consists of three core modules: Mixed-State Representation, which measures the contribution of visual tokens through quantum-inspired state representations (the authors claim it is based on image-text pairs); State-Aware Token Pruning, which combines token contributions and inter-token overlap to balance information retention and redundancy control; and State-Preserving Token Refinement, which supplements local details potentially missed during the main pruning stage. The authors achieve good results on multiple datasets based on the LLaVA-1.5-7B and LLaVA-NeXT-7B architectures.

Critical strengths

S1. The method is logically sound. QPrune considers the relevance between visual tokens and question text, token contributions, and inter-token information overlap. It also uses a refinement stage to recover omitted local details.

S2. The experiments show good compression and performance retention. The authors achieve good results across multiple datasets on LLaVA-1.5-7B and LLaVA-NeXT-7B, particularly maintaining relatively high performance under high compression ratios with LLaVA-NeXT-7B.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The unique contribution of the quantum-inspired representation is unclear.

The method represents visual tokens as states, constructs mixed states using probability weights, and measures token contributions based on relationships between states. However, the actual computation combines weights from text-visual semantic responses and visual attention, then selects tokens based on the resulting token probabilities and inter-token similarities. The authors should clarify its advantages over conventional similarity-based token selection (e.g., weighted similarity with greedy redundancy reduction). If the final computation is essentially equivalent to conventional similarity or its squared transformation, the quantum-inspired formulation may not constitute a sufficiently strong methodological contribution.

W2. Key algorithmic steps are unclear.

For example, Section 3.2 describes dynamic Residual Score updates without providing the update formula. Similarly, Section 3.1 and Appendix A.2 do not specify the exact form of the entropy-to-budget mapping function (\gamma(H(p))). These missing details affect Token Selection, Budget Allocation, and reproducibility. The authors should provide the update rules, budget mapping function, and relevant hyperparameters. I suggest including pseudocode to describe the method precisely.

W3. The benefits of adaptive budget allocation are limited, and evidence of stability is insufficient.

In the ablation study (Table 7), adaptive budget allocation achieves an average score of 55.34, compared with 55.10 for a fixed 20% refinement budget, a difference of only 0.24. This result is insufficient to demonstrate a stable and significant advantage of the adaptive strategy. The authors should further evaluate it under different compression ratios and model settings.

W4. Comparison with strong baselines is insufficient.

The evaluation could be strengthened by including stronger baselines, such as ApET (CVPR 2026), AgilePruner (ICLR 2026), and TransPrune (CVPR 2026), as well as additional datasets such as MME, VizWiz, AI2D and SEED.

W5. Cross-architecture generalization is insufficiently validated.

QPrune is evaluated only on LLaVA-1.5-7B and LLaVA-NeXT-7B, both from the LLaVA family. Moreover, its reliance on Global Visual Token Attention raises questions about its applicability to different vision encoders (Qwen-VL/InternVL).

Questions for authors

Q1. Practical Contribution of the Quantum-Inspired Representation

What are the unique advantages of the Quantum-inspired Mixed-state Representation over conventional normalized features and cosine similarity? Would replacing it with conventional similarity computation affect token selection or model performance?

Q2. Is Question–Image Token Similarity Sufficient to Guide Pruning?

Does the text–vision relevance score reliably identify the visual evidence needed to answer a question, particularly for complex relationships, attribute binding, counting, OCR, and multi-step reasoning?

Q3. Mathematical Definitions of Key Algorithms

The Residual Score update formula in Section 3.2 and the budget mapping function in Section 3.1 are not clearly specified. Could the authors provide their explicit mathematical definitions and parameter settings?

Q4. Effectiveness of Adaptive Budget Allocation

How stable are the performance gains of adaptive budget allocation across different token retention ratios compared with fixed budget allocation? Additional experimental results would help validate its effectiveness.

Q5. Comparison with Stronger Baselines and More Datasets

The evaluation would benefit from comparisons with recent token pruning methods, such as ApET, AgilePruner, and TransPrune, under the same token budgets and experimental settings.

Q6. Cross-Architecture Generalization

Does the Vision Encoder Attention-based probability estimation generalize to different vision encoders? Validation on non-LLaVA architectures, such as Qwen-VL or InternVL, would help establish the method's generalizability.

Reviewer_TgeLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This manuscript proposes QPrune, a training-free visual token pruning method motivated by mixed-state representations in quantum information theory. It combines text-conditioned and visual importance scores, selects tokens using probability-weighted state overlaps, and adds locally distinctive tokens through a refinement stage. The reported results on LLaVA-1.5-7B and LLaVA-NeXT-7B are promising, particularly under aggressive pruning. However, the specific limitation of existing methods and the motivation for mixed-state modeling are not clearly established. The connection between the quantum formulation and the implemented algorithm, the completeness of the algorithmic description, and the contribution beyond conventional relevance-and-diversity-based selection also remain concerns.

Critical strengths

(1) The method addresses a practically relevant problem and reports strong performance under aggressive token reduction. On LLaVA-1.5-7B, it retains 97.29% of the full model's average benchmark-wise performance with 64 out of 576 visual tokens. (2) Experiments cover multiple benchmarks and two model configurations. The component ablations provide useful evidence for combining visual and textual cues and updating selection scores iteratively.

Critical weaknesses

(1) The specific research problem and the motivation for mixed-state modeling are not sufficiently clear. The manuscript emphasizes that token importance depends on image-text interactions and the already retained tokens, but existing relevance- and diversity-based methods also address these considerations. It does not clearly identify a specific limitation of these methods or provide targeted evidence showing how mixed-state representation overcomes it. Representing normalized features as pure states and assigning mixture weights does not by itself establish an advantage over conventional formulations. The authors should clarify which modeling capability or algorithmic insight is gained from the quantum-information perspective, rather than only showing that it can describe the pruning problem.

(2) The connection between the claimed Born-rule probabilities and their actual computation is not adequately justified. Equations (2)-(3) define probabilities as squared overlaps with reference states. However, Appendix A.1 states that these reference states are not explicitly constructed; the implemented probabilities instead come from softmax-normalized semantic-response scores and visual attention. No derivation or consistency analysis establishes that these distributions can be induced by the stated reference states. Moreover, for generally nonorthogonal token states, individual squared overlaps do not automatically form a normalized distribution over tokens. The weighted density matrix in Eq. (28) is a valid construction, but this alone does not justify the preceding Born-rule interpretation. The manuscript should distinguish the heuristic importance weights from measurement probabilities and justify the correspondence claimed in Eqs. (2)-(3).

(3) The state-preservation interpretation and the actual selection procedure are insufficiently specified. Sections 3.2-3.3 repeatedly state that residual scores are updated to remove information already represented by selected tokens, but neither an explicit update equation nor complete pseudocode is provided in the supplied manuscript, including its appendix. It is therefore difficult to determine what quantity the residual measures or how it relates to preserving the original mixed state. No state-reconstruction objective or approximation-error analysis establishes this connection. In addition, the entropy of the mixture weights in Eq. (5) is not generally the entropy of the density matrix when token states overlap. The budget-allocation function and the rationale linking this entropy to the need for local refinement require clearer specification and validation.

Questions for authors

same as weaknesses

Reviewer_NhFROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the inference cost of multimodal large language models, which process a large number of visual tokens, by proposing a training-free visual token pruning method called QPrune. The authors argue that a token's value depends both on its relevance to the current image–text pair and on its overlap with tokens already retained, and they use a quantum-inspired mixed-state formulation to model this. Each visual token is treated as a pure state with an associated probability, which combines a text-conditioned relevance score with an image-side importance score from the vision encoder. Based on this representation, a state-aware pruning stage selects tokens greedily by relevance while discounting overlap with the retained set, and a state-preserving refinement stage adds tokens that carry remaining information and distinctive local detail. The budget split between the two stages is set adaptively from the entropy of the token probabilities. Experiments on LLaVA-1.5-7B and LLaVA-NeXT-7B across eight benchmarks show that QPrune outperforms FastV, SparseVLM, SparseVLM+, VisionZip and DART, with the largest gains under aggressive pruning, e.g., retaining 97.29% of full-model performance with 11.1% of the visual tokens on LLaVA-1.5-7B. The paper also reports efficiency measurements, ablations of each component and qualitative visualizations.

Critical strengths
  1. Strong results under aggressive pruning, without training. At K=32K=32 on LLaVA-1.5-7B, QPrune reaches 62.25 average and 93.41% relative performance, compared with 57.04 for the best baseline, DART (Table 1). On LLaVA-NeXT-7B with 160 tokens it keeps 88.96%, compared with 81.50% for VisionZip (Table 2). The method is training-free and plug-and-play, so if these gains hold, it is practically useful.

  2. Reasonable design with per-component ablations. Combining token relevance, redundancy with the retained set, and local detail is sensible. Each part has an ablation: probability sources (Table 4), selection strategy (Table 5), refinement strategy (Table 6) and budget allocation (Table 7).

Critical weaknesses
  1. The quantum framing adds little, and the core algorithm is under-specified.

    • Appendix A.1 states that the reference states are "represented implicitly" and never instantiated. ptxtp_{txt} is a softmax over normalized text-similarity scores, and pvisp_{vis} is the CLS attention from the vision encoder (Eq. 19–21). The mixed-state language therefore relabels existing relevance scores.
    • The relation matrix Rij=pipj ∣⟨ψi∣ψj⟩∣2R_{ij} = \sqrt{p_i p_j}\,|\langle\psi_i|\psi_j\rangle|^2 with greedy residual selection closely resembles quality–diversity kernels in determinantal point processes, which the paper cites (Kulesza & Taskar, 2012). Yet there is no comparison with DPP-based selection or with DivPrune, which is also cited.
  2. The efficiency and ablation results raise doubts about the evaluation.

    • QPrune and VisionZip use the same number of tokens, the same FLOPs (0.831 T) and the same KV cache (32.00 MB). Yet QPrune's prefill is 34.33 vs. 70.86 ms, and its decode is 23.97 vs. 83.60 ms/token. QPrune's decode is also about 3.4x faster than the full model, while VisionZip with 64 tokens decodes slower than the full model. These differences can't come from the token count, which suggests the measurement setups differ.
    • In Table 7, no refinement (55.02) is only 0.32 below full QPrune (55.34). The larger gaps in Table 6 come from comparing with random or partial refinement, not with no refinement.
    • Tables 4–5 use K=128K=128 numbers and Tables 6–7 use K=64K=64, each on different benchmark subsets, and the text doesn't say this.
    • Comparisons cover only the LLaVA family. Several cited methods (DivPrune, VisPruner, PyramidDrop, PruMerge) are not compared.
Questions for authors
  1. What exactly are gvg_v and gtg_t, and how are the text "semantic units" extracted? Do they require an external model? Is that cost included in Table 3?
  2. What is the exact residual-score update in Sec. 3.2? How does the selection differ from greedy DPP MAP inference with kernel RR, and how does QPrune compare with DivPrune or a DPP baseline?
  3. In Table 3, QPrune and VisionZip have identical token counts, FLOPs and KV cache, yet very different prefill and decode latencies, and QPrune decodes about 3.4x faster than the full model. What explains this, and were all methods measured with the same implementation and attention kernels?
  4. What is the form of γ(⋅)\gamma(\cdot), and how were β0\beta_0, τr\tau_r, τs\tau_s and the neighborhood size chosen? Were they tuned on the evaluation benchmarks?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.