- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper claims a novel continual learning framework for open-world object detection by decoupling preogressive knowledge formation from selective represenation adaptation. Initial experiments on multiple benchmarks supports the efficacy of the proposed framework.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
The serious issue lies in the presentation of the methodology. In particular, while various modules and function are introduced in the framework, there are no any description and justificaiton for them. For example, how to project the feature into spatial and frequency response spaces? how can spatial and frequency features be directly sumed considering that they are from two different two different spaces? what is adaptive Fourier-domain refinement? how to get E^s and E^f in Eq (1)? why keep smoothness and sparsity for E (Eq 2)? what are teh symboles appearing in Eq (3)? what is LIF-style temporal state? What is relationship between Eq (3) and E*{i,t} in Eq (2)? what is the temporal state v_t in Eq (4)? how to integrate to get S{i,t}? what is phi_N in Eq (5)? what are "latent representation pathways"? what inputs are associated with "consecutive predictions"? what is g_N in Eq (8)? what is h_{i,t} for in Eq (9)? what are the structure of the mentioned mappings/functions?
Considering the very ambgious description of the methodology, the validity of experimental results are hard to evaluate. In addition, the sensitivity study of various hyper-parameteres are not valid, considering that only about three different values were set to each hyper-parameters with clear performance variations.
Questions for authors
Please well describe and justify the role, meaning, and structure of each module and function appearing the proposed framework.