- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces EBOND, a large-scale quantum-chemistry dataset for electron-guided molecular fragmentation. The authors run DFT calculations on 452,775 molecules sampled from USPTO, derive atom-level and bond-level electronic response descriptors (condensed dual descriptor, bond dual descriptor, Parr functions), and map them to bond-level fragmentation scores. Validation shows the resulting fragmentation covers 81.1% of recorded synthetic disconnections on USPTO-50K, recovers 73.4% of sites missed by both BRICS and RECAP, and is evaluated on two downstream tasks: single-step retrosynthesis pretraining and fragment-based molecular optimization (DRD4).
Critical strengths
1. The dataset itself is a substantial, reusable contribution.
Three-state DFT on 452,775 molecules at ~1.26M CPU core-hours is beyond what most labs can compute, and the atom/bond-level electronic descriptors are a genuinely new resource for molecular learning.
2. Complementarity to rule-based fragmentation is convincingly demonstrated.
EBOND recovers 73.4% of disconnection sites missed by both BRICS and RECAP (vs 51.0% for a size-matched random baseline), and combined coverage reaches 96.1%. This is strong evidence that electronic information carries signal beyond local structural patterns.
Critical weaknesses
1. Evidence that electron-guided fragmentation improves molecular learning is insufficient.
(i) Table 5 uses single-step retrosynthesis to show that EBOND fragmentation outperforms other fragmentation schemes, but the None baseline already reaches 48.59% Top-1 while EBOND only raises it to 51.65%, and all fragmentation variants cluster within a narrow band. Moreover, only BRICS is compared among the fragmentation methods, the runs are single, so it is unclear whether the margins are more than chance variation; a harder and more discriminative task is needed to establish the advantage. (ii) The optimization study gives a larger gap, but it also covers a single case (one target, DRD4) and compares only BRICS, so the evidence remains insufficient.
2. No comparison with learned fragmentation methods. The baselines are only random, BRICS and RECAP, all rule-based or heuristic. Section 2.1 acknowledges recent data-driven fragmentation and substructure-learning methods, but none are evaluated. So it is unclear whether the electronic signal offers an advantage over learning disconnections directly from data.
3. Fragmentation depends on a single global threshold.
All boundaries come from one threshold, τ = 0.25, applied to molecule-wise z-scored descriptors and combined by union across the three scores. Sensitivity to τ is discussed only in Appendix E.2, with no analysis in the main text, and it is not shown whether one value holds across molecules of different size and across chemical space. Since τ directly controls how many bonds are cut per molecule, and that count is fixed to match EBOND in the random baseline, the reported gains may partly reflect this choice rather than the electronic signal itself.
Questions for authors
-
Are the Table 5 improvements statistically significant across random seeds? Please report standard deviations for all fragmentation variants.
-
Can you evaluate under a harder, more discriminative task (e.g. a subset without high-frequency reaction templates, multi-step retrosynthesis, or low-data fine-tuning) to demonstrate the advantage of EBOND fragmentation ?
-
What is the sensitivity to the threshold τ = 0.25? How do RDC, the number of fragments, and the downstream metrics change as τ varies from 0.1 to 0.5?
-
Can you add a comparison against at least one learned fragmentation baseline?
-
In 5.2 both methods receive the same 5,120 generation attempts, but the fragment vocabularies differ in size (26,168 EBOND fragments vs 14,930 BRICS). Since the vocabulary is the search space, a larger pool alone could improve the hit rate under a fixed attempt budget. Can you repeat the comparison with matched vocabulary sizes, or report search diversity statistics, so the gap is attributable to fragment quality rather than pool size?
Dear Reviewer 3RcY,
We have addressed your concerns in our rebuttal and would appreciate your feedback on our responses. Please let us know if any points require further clarification.
Best regards,
The Authors