- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The method combines several candidate tissue masks for whole slide images on a grid. It separates pixels into unclear regions, then uses a VLM agent to decide between tissue and background for the larger unclear areas. Smaller or over-budget regions are classified using a mean-vote threshold. The approach is evaluated on several datasets and compared to seven threshold-based and learned detectors.
Critical strengths
- tissue detection is relevant and often breaks downstream things. There is not much focus on this right now since reviewers think this is solved but it is not, espeically not across stains
- some good results on public datasets, especially in the low tail on TWI
- some reasonable QC, the per-region decision log could be useful
- a small dataset of manual masks made public
Critical weaknesses
- what are the candidate detectors?
- using a VLM as judge for segmentation masks has been tried, see SegAE (Chen et al. ISBI 2026, doi:10.1109/ISBI61048.2026.11515717, Jain et al., MICCAI 2026 Workshops, LNCS 17251; arXiv:2606.16658), perhaps worth having a look.
- what about STAPLE (TMI 2004;23(7):903-21) label fusion, doing agent off would give majority vote fusion? how much gain comes from the agent?
- HEST seems circular since this comes from HEST's own tissue detectior. check if these cohorts link back to references made by models
- if you review KPMP and find wrong labels, why not doing the same with your method. how does label noise compare?
- any info on agent noise? how would that look like if you re-run in a couple of times?
- how much is this if I run this through claude's API?
- do you also test the non-H&E or IHC slides in TWI?
- I'd also suggest to test the concept with a couple of available open-weight models.
Questions for authors
- Which candidate detectors does the approach use, and what settings are applied to them?
- How does the method compare to other work that uses a VLM to judge or create segmentation masks, such as SegAE (Chen et al. ISBI 2026) and Jain et al. (MICCAI 2026 Workshops, LNCS 17251; arXiv:2606.16658)?
- How much improvement is due to the agent? What results do you see if the agent is turned off, using mean-vote fusion over all regions, or when using STAPLE (TMI 2004;23(7):903-21)?
- Are any of the candidate detectors based on HEST's tissue model or related to it?
- How consistent are the agent's decisions? If you run the same slides multiple times, how does the Dice score change?
- What is the cost of running the method through the API per slide, in terms of tokens, time, and money?
- How does the method perform on TWI slides that are not H&E or IHC?
- Does FOCAL still work when using open-weight VLMs?