- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper reviews multimodal affective representation learning from the perspectives of emotion theories, modality-specific information, representation learning methods, and downstream applications. It categorizes existing methods into five families and introduces six properties for assessing affective representations. The survey discusses representative corpora, evaluation practices, and challenges related to robustness and generalization.
Critical strengths
- The review considers different emotion theories, input modalities, learning paradigms, and downstream applications.
Critical weaknesses
- Previous reviews (see Journals Q1'25-26) already cover emotion theories, multimodal representations, fusion, alignment, disentanglement, evaluation, and generalization. The Introduction does not provide a substantive comparison establishing what new scientific knowledge this survey contributes beyond these studies.
- The five families in Section 5 and Tables 1 and 3 describe established methodological categories. Their boundaries are not clearly defined. For example, contrastive alignment, dynamic fusion, and robust learning can coexist within the same architecture. The paper provides no systematic classification criteria or analysis of overlapping methods. Consequently, the taxonomy offers limited methodological insight beyond existing classifications.
- The title suggests a technical progression from feature disentanglement to semantic alignment. However, the paper does not establish this progression through a chronological analysis, methodological dependencies, or comparative evidence. Sections 3-5 describe existing methods as parallel categories rather than demonstrating a meaningful technical evolution.
- The Introduction identifies six affective representation metrics, including cross-modal comparability, complementarity, redundancy control, disentanglement, robustness, and sensitivity to dynamics. However, these properties lack operational definitions, measurement procedures, and validation criteria. The paper therefore does not establish a reproducible framework for evaluating representation quality.
- Tables 4-7 evaluate only four dimensions despite the six metrics introduced in the paper. Redundancy control and sensitivity to dynamics are omitted. Moreover, the qualitative assignments are largely identical across different application settings. The criteria for distinguishing dominant and auxiliary roles are not provided. These tables do not substantiate the claimed application-specific analysis.
- Section 2 and Appendix A report 260 retrieved records and 146 final references. However, the complete database-specific search queries, search dates, exclusion records, and screening decisions are unavailable. The authors also report supplementary retrieval using ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini without specifying the retrieval or verification procedures. The reported selection process cannot be independently reproduced.
- Section 6.5 is presented as an analysis of experimental findings but contains no systematic quantitative comparison of methods. It provides neither comparable benchmark results nor evidence linking specific representation properties to observed performance. Consequently, the paper does not demonstrate that its framework produces additional empirical insights beyond conventional task-level evaluations.
- The review includes several text-only datasets for affective reasoning and emotional support without clearly separating unimodal findings from evidence about multimodal representations. Conversely, eye tracking is presented as a relevant modality in Section 4 but is not represented in the dataset comparison in Table 8.
- Table 8 reports heterogeneous dataset statistics and annotation schemes without standardized information on experimental protocols, data partitions, or evaluation comparability. Section 6 emphasizes cross-task generalization but does not systematically distinguish cross-dataset, cross-domain, cross-lingual, and missing-modality evaluations. As a result, the survey provides limited guidance for determining which published results are directly comparable.
Questions for authors
- What specific scientific conclusions distinguish the proposed framework from the closest previously published surveys?
- What objective criteria determine the assignment of existing methods to the five proposed methodological families?
- What evidence establishes the claimed technical progression from feature disentanglement to semantic alignment?
- How can the six proposed representation properties be measured quantitatively?
- What criteria were used to assign dominant and auxiliary roles in Tables 4-7?
- Can the authors provide the complete database-specific search protocol and screening records supporting the selection of 146 references (see PRISMA)?
- What comparative evidence demonstrates that the proposed representation-centered framework provides additional insights beyond existing task-level evaluations?
The authors did not submit a rebuttal to address my comments or respond my questions. Therefore, I am changing my overall rating to 1.