- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Existing one-sample Root-cause discovery(RCD) method typically assume a linear structural equation model(SEM) and may therefore fail to adequately account for nonlinear or interaction effects of observed common causes on the variables. To address this issue, the authors propose CSP-RCD, a two-stage procedure that first transforms the variables by estimating the conditional mean from observational data to remove common-cause contributions from both observational and interventional samples, and then applies existing RCD methods to the transformed variables. Under the stated assumptions, the authors show that the population-level transformation preserves both the causal coefficient matrix and the sparse intervention vector of the original SEM, providing a theoretical basis for applying downstream RCD methods to the transformed data.
Critical strengths
S1. The method handles nonlinear common-cause effects without estimating or . Because , removing the propagated common-cause contribution only requires regressing on , rather than separately estimating the structural coefficient matrix and the nonlinear function . The resulting two-step procedure applies existing one-sample RCD methods to the transformed data, so it extends their scope without designing a new root-cause scoring algorithm, and it preserves their property of not requiring the causal graph. The flexibility to choose the regression model for the conditional mean is also practical.
S2. The proposed transformation is theoretically justified and linked to the estimation procedure. The authors not only show that removing the conditional mean preserves and , but also characterize additive transformations satisfying this property up to a constant difference. This helps explain why this specific transformation is appropriate and why other simple corrections fall short.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The stability regarding conditional mean estimation errors and practical application guidelines are not sufficiently clear. While the structure-preservation results hold for population-level transformations using the true conditional mean, the practical CSP-RCD relies on the estimated conditional mean. Consequently, if the regression is inaccurate especially around the common-cause values of single-intervention samples, the adjustment process may actually worsen root-cause estimation. This sensitivity is evident in Table 2. For instance, in Test13 under high-traffic conditions, the cause ranking is 12th on the raw data, 7th using the Random Forest-based transformation, and 19th using the GAM-based transformation.
Questions for authors
Q1. How were the nuisance learners and their hyperparameters (especially the random forest on PetShop) selected, and was this done using only observational data, without access to the true root causes? Were the transformed observational samples computed with in-sample or cross-fitted predictions? Finally, was cross-validated error useful for identifying cases where the transformation worsens the rank (e.g., GAM in Table 2(a), Test11–13)
Q2. In choice of in PetShop, how is the non-descendant assumption justified at the level of the measured latency variables, given that an incident could affect these services through shared load or retries? Are there incidents whose true root cause lies in the selected , and if so, how were they handled in the evaluation?
Dear Reviewer Jn81,
Thank you again for taking the time to review our paper.
We understand your major concern regarding novelty, as we also considered the connection to standard residualization when studying this problem. In our response, we explained why its familiar form still requires careful study for the task we consider and how our contributions go beyond simply applying residualization.
As the author–reviewer discussion period is nearing its end, we would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know whether our response addresses your concern or whether you still have any questions. We would be happy to provide further clarification or answer any follow-up questions before the discussion closes on November 18.
Thank you again for your feedback, time, and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors