acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TED-ITS: Tail-Enhanced Conditional Diffusion Fine-tuning for Label-Free Industrial Time-Series Generation

Abstract

Diffusion models have achieved strong performance in time-series forecasting, missing-value imputation, and generation. However, real-world industrial time series often exhibit long-tailed distributions, where abundant normal samples dominate rare fault patterns and degrade the modeling of minority faults. Although class-conditional diffusion models alleviate this issue through semantic class guidance, two challenges remain. First, rare fault samples provide insufficient supervision for learning class-specific denoising dynamics, while increasing diffusion noise progressively obscures fault-specific characteristics. Second, class-conditional diffusion relies on explicit labels, which are generally unavailable from historical or incomplete observations in forecasting and imputation, leading to a mismatch between training and inference. To address these challenges, we propose TED-ITS, a tail-enhanced fine-tuning framework built upon a pretrained class-conditional diffusion model. TED-ITS introduces Noise-Adaptive Target Reconstruction (NATR), which adaptively constructs tail-class reconstruction targets according to noise-aware trajectory similarity and class frequency to strengthen minority fault supervision. It further incorporates Balanced-Condition Regularization (BCR), which samples auxiliary labels from a balanced distribution and enforces time- and frequency-domain consistency across different class conditions, thereby reducing reliance on explicit labels. Extensive experiments on multiple industrial benchmarks demonstrate that TED-ITS improves minority fault modeling and consistently achieves superior performance on downstream forecasting and imputation tasks compared with existing methods.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
Industrial Time-Series Generation, Long-Tailed Generation, Diffusion Model.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_JfUxOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TED-ITS, a fine-tuning framework for long tailed industrial time series generation based on a pretrained class-conditional diffusion model. The Noise-Adaptive Target Reconstruction (NATR) probabilistically replaces the original reconstruction target with a candidate trajectory to increase supervision from minority fault samples. Moreover, the Balanced-Condition Regularization (BCR) samples auxiliary class labels uniformly and encourages predictions conditioned on the original and auxiliary labels to remain consistent in both the time and frequency domains. Experiments on fou datasets demonstrates that TED-ITS achieves superior performance compared with existing methods.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper considers a practically relevant problem called imbalanced industrial fault data and improves the generation of minority operating states.

  2. The author explicitly discuss limitations of their theoretical results. In particular, the theoretical section acknowledges that geometric compatibility does not imply fault semantic equivalence and that reconstruction target redistribution does not guarantee improved unconditional minority generation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The core training mechanism is conceptually inconsistent and may actively corrupt class semantics. NATR keeps the original class condition yiy_i while sometimes replacing target with a sample drawn from another less frequent class yziy_{z_i}. This is not merely data augmentation and it introduces contradictory conditional supervision, as there is nothing to guarantee that the classes are semantically compatible. More seriously, the theoretical analysis states that the induced reconstruction bias is not guaranteed to be small. Crucially, the experiments do not evaluate whether class semantics survive the training protocol. There is no per-class generation fidelity or analysis of whether distinct fault classes collapse toward each other.

  2. The claims of label free and long tail are not convincingly supported by the evaluation. The motivation is substantially overstated as TED-ITS is not label free during training. The baseline comparison is also problematic. The baseline results in Table 1 are taken from DLTTS, rather than rerunning the competing methods under the same environment and protocol. It results in unfair comparison.

Questions for authors
  1. How do the authors justify training with the original condition yiy_i when NATR replaces the reconstruction target with a trajectory from a potentially different class yjy_j? Why does it not corrupt the class conditional mapping?

  2. Can the authors provide per-class semantic fidelity experiments? For example, train an independent fault classifier on real data and evaluate whether samples generated under each condition remain identifiable as that fault type after fine-tuning.

  3. What does label free contribute beyond ordinary classifier-free diffusion?

  4. How are unconditional samples evaluated against real tail sequences? As without reporting tail prevalence and recall, a method could simply obtain high scores simply by changing how frequently tail samples are generated.

  5. Why are the baseline results copied from DLTTS rather than rerun under the same protocol? I do not consider it is sufficient to establish a fair comparison.

  6. Could the authors provide more comparisons with recent related methods such as [1][2][3]? The baseline comparison appears somewhat outdated and do not necessarily demonstrate competitiveness against the current methods. The downstream evaluation compare only against Diffusion-TS is also insufficient.

[1] Fide: Frequency-inflated conditional diffusion model for extreme-aware time series generation.

[2] Population aware diffusion for time series generation.

[3] DiM-TS: Bridge the Gap Between Selective State Space Models and Time Series for Generative Modeling.

Reviewer_GMQbOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TED-ITS, a tail-enhanced diffusion fine-tuning framework for long-tailed industrial time-series generation without requiring class labels at inference. It introduces two components: Noise-Adaptive Target Reconstruction (NATR), which transfers reconstruction targets toward minority-class trajectories based on noise-aware similarity and class-frequency constraints, and Balanced-Condition Regularization (BCR), which encourages consistency across different class conditions to reduce label dependence. The authors evaluate TED-ITS on five industrial time-series datasets using Predictive Score (PS), Discriminative Score (DS), and downstream forecasting and imputation MSE. The results show improvements over generative baselines in most settings, supported by ablation studies and theoretical analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses the challenge of modeling rare fault patterns in long-tailed industrial time series, which is practically important given the scarcity of fault observations. The attempt to leverage class supervision during training while avoiding the need for ground-truth class labels at inference is potentially useful, particularly for industrial settings where future operating states are unknown.

  2. The proposed Noise-Adaptive Target Reconstruction (NATR) goes beyond conventional class reweighting or resampling by modifying reconstruction targets according to noise-dependent trajectory compatibility and class-frequency constraints. This provides an interesting perspective on transferring supervision toward minority classes in diffusion models. The accompanying theoretical analysis and component ablations offer some preliminary support for the proposed design.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Misalignment between the research motivation, task objective, and experimental validation.

The paper motivates label-free generation largely through downstream forecasting and imputation, where ground-truth operating-state labels are unavailable at inference time. If enabling or improving these downstream tasks is a central motivation for the proposed generative framework, the experimental evaluation should provide convincing evidence that the method offers meaningful benefits for forecasting and imputation. However, the downstream evaluation is very limited: the paper only compares TED-ITS against Diffusion-TS on two datasets, without including strong task-specific baselines or separately assessing performance on minority fault intervals. Consequently, the current results are insufficient to establish whether the proposed approach offers substantial practical advantages for the downstream applications used to motivate it.

Alternatively, if the primary objective is to improve time-series generation itself, independently of its downstream applications, the intended generative objective remains unclear. In particular, it is not specified whether label-free generation is expected to preserve the original long-tailed data distribution or intentionally increase the generation probability of minority fault patterns. These objectives have different implications and require different evaluation criteria. Although the paper reports Predictive Score (PS) and Discriminative Score (DS) against real tail-class references, these metrics do not directly establish the fidelity, diversity, or coverage of the generated minority fault patterns. Moreover, systematic comparisons with label-aware long-tailed generative methods under matched supervision settings are lacking, making it difficult to assess the specific benefits and trade-offs of removing class conditions at inference.

Overall, the experimental evaluation does not adequately support either interpretation of the paper's central objective. If the contribution is primarily motivated by forecasting and imputation, its downstream utility remains insufficiently validated. If the contribution is primarily about label-free minority-fault generation, the target distribution and the evidence supporting successful minority-fault modeling remain insufficiently established. This ambiguity significantly weakens the empirical justification for the proposed framework.

  1. Insufficient justification and validation of the proposed mechanisms.

The effectiveness of both NATR and Balanced-Condition Regularization (BCR) raises important questions. NATR allows reconstruction targets to be transferred across classes while retaining the original class condition. Although this may increase minority-class supervision, it can also introduce inconsistencies between the conditioning labels and reconstruction targets, potentially compromising class-specific modeling. The current theoretical analysis and ablations do not sufficiently establish that the resulting improvements arise from meaningful tail-pattern transfer rather than more general changes to the training distribution.

More importantly, BCR enforces consistency between predictions under different explicit class conditions, whereas label-free inference is performed using a null condition enabled by classifier-free training. The paper does not adequately explain or directly demonstrate why consistency across explicit class labels should improve the null-condition generation branch. Therefore, the contribution of BCR to the claimed label-free capability remains insufficiently established.

Questions for authors

Q1. Clarification of the task objective and motivation. What is the intended target distribution of the proposed label-free generator? Is TED-ITS expected to preserve the original long-tailed data distribution, or to increase the generation probability of minority fault patterns? These objectives imply different criteria for successful generation. Furthermore, if the primary motivation is to improve forecasting and imputation, what is the specific advantage of the proposed generative formulation over directly optimizing these tasks without target-state labels?

Q2. Validity of the generation evaluation. The paper evaluates label-free generation using PS and DS against real tail-class references. How are generated samples selected or matched to these references without class labels? Does the evaluation involve any label-dependent filtering or post-processing? More importantly, what evidence demonstrates that the improvements in PS and DS correspond to better minority-fault fidelity and coverage, rather than improvements in general temporal characteristics?

Q3. Sufficiency of downstream validation. Given that forecasting and imputation are central to the motivation, why are the downstream experiments limited to comparisons with Diffusion-TS on two datasets? Can the authors provide evidence that TED-ITS offers meaningful advantages over task-specific baselines, particularly on minority fault intervals? Such evidence would substantially strengthen the claimed practical value of the proposed framework.

Q4. Justification of the proposed mechanisms. NATR transfers reconstruction targets across classes while retaining the original class condition. How do the authors ensure that this does not compromise class-specific semantics? Additionally, BCR enforces consistency between predictions under different explicit class conditions, whereas inference uses a null condition. What evidence establishes that this regularization specifically improves null-condition generation rather than merely acting as a general regularizer? Clarifying these mechanisms is important for assessing the actual contribution of NATR and BCR.

Reviewer_aj1SOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes TED-ITS, a fine-tuning framework for industrial time-series generation under class imbalance,. It introduces two components: Noise-Adaptive Target Reconstruction and Balanced-Condition Regularization. The evaluation covers generation on four datasets and downstream imputation and forecasting on two datasets. The paper reports competitive predictive and discriminative scores, component ablations, and theoretical analysis of target allocation and reconstruction bias.

Critical strengths

Rare faults are difficult to model, and their labels are generally unavailable when predicting or imputing future observations. Improving minority-pattern learning under this constraint is a worthwhile goal.

Critical weaknesses
  1. I find the methodological novelty limited. The approach appears to combine familiar strategies: increasing supervision from rare classes, encouraging consistency across class conditions, and dropping labels during training to support inference without labels. More specifically, NATR closely similiar to Oriented Calibration and BCR follows the cross-condition regularization used in CBDM. Comparisons with these prior methods and their combination, using the same backbone and training budget, are needed to make the contribution convincing.
  2. The experiments do not explain why NATR improves performance. NATR makes rare fault trajectories appear more often as reconstruction targets. Simply oversampling fault examples would also increase their contribution to training. Does the improvement come from this particular pairing, or simply from using fault targets more often? The current ablation and comparison do not separate these explanations.
Questions for authors

What does NATR gain over directly oversampling fault examples? Please compare the two. This would help determine whether the benefit comes from increased fault supervision or from NATR’s input–target pairing. Could you also compare against a suitable augmentation method that constructs additional fault examples?

Why is BCR needed beyond training without class conditions or using label dropout? Label dropout already enables inference without labels. Could you compare the full method with an unconditional model using NATR, and with a conditional model using NATR and label dropout but no BCR, under matched training settings?

What is the additional contribution over OC’s H2T variant and CBDM? Please identify the substantive differences and provide matched comparisons with these methods and their combination.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.