acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SelfEvoSkill: Paired Execution Audits for Skill Revision without External Outcome Supervision

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

10 views

Abstract

Agent skills provide LLM agents with reusable procedures, but a given skill may be incomplete, ineffective, or misleading for the current task. Existing methods for revising skills typically rely on external outcome supervision, such as task rewards, performance on a separate validation set, or feedback from deployment, to decide which updates to retain. However, this supervision may be costly or unavailable when adapting a skill to a new task. Using execution behavior as an alternative signal is challenging: a single run reflects the combined effects of the agent, task, and workspace, making the skill's contribution difficult to isolate. Comparing executions with and without the skill, while holding these factors fixed, provides evidence about how the skill changes behavior. We introduce SelfEvoSkill, which links these behavioral differences to relevant skill passages and iteratively revises and reevaluates those passages through subsequent executions. Checks derived once from the task's explicit requirements prevent revisions from violating task constraints. Across 89 containerized tasks in 8 professional domains, under the same best-of-two evaluation budget, SelfEvoSkill attains a 73.9% mean task reward, exceeding the no-skill condition by +33.0 percentage points and the benchmark's curated skill by +17.2 percentage points, while skill evolution receives neither task rewards nor benchmark verifier outputs. In controlled ablations, using two with-skill runs instead of a matched with/without-skill pair reduces mean reward by 4.6 percentage points, while limiting revision to one round reduces it by 9.0 points relative to repeated revision. Together, these results show that behavioral differences between matched executions can provide an effective signal for revising skills when outcome supervision is unavailable.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, agent skills, self-evolving agents, process supervision

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_9mmtOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces SelfEvoSkill, an iterative framework that revises LLM agent skills without external outcome supervision (such as task rewards or benchmark verifier feedback) by auditing behavioral differences between matched execution pairs.

Critical strengths
  1. Proposes an effective skill-revision framework that operates without external outcome supervision (such as task rewards or benchmark verifier feedback), solving the challenge of high-cost or missing evaluation signals.
  2. Outperforms no-skill (+33.0 pp) and curated-skill (+17.2 pp) baselines across 89 diverse tasks in 8 domains, with ablations confirming the necessity of paired references and multi-round iterative audits.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation is restricted to a single benchmark (SkillsBench, 89 tasks), leaving its generalizability to more diverse agent environments unverified.
  2. The method relies on benchmark-provided, human-curated skills as the initial baseline (S0S_0). In practice, high-quality expert-crafted skills are scarce and expensive to obtain, and these curated skills already provide strong structural priors. The framework does not evaluate starting from low-quality, noisy, or automatically synthesized skills, limiting its applicability in cold-start scenarios where human-curated skills are unavailable.
  3. The LLM testing in the method is very limited. It is suggested to test more different LLMs from different companies and test whether the skill can be effectively transferred to other agents or LLMs.
Questions for authors
  1. How does the method locate exactly which paragraph, or which part of the skill, is harmful? How do you guarantee the attribution is correct?
Reviewer_a1VTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SelfEvoSkill revises an existing skill for the current task without access to benchmark rewards, tests, or reference solutions. It compares executions with and without the skill, links differences to specific passages, and iterates under a fixed Refine or Repair mode. A verifier compiled from explicit task requirements checks candidate executions. On 89 SkillsBench tasks, mean best-of-two reward rises from 56.7% with curated skills to 73.9%. Ablations examine pairing, editing modes, repeated revision, and transfer across executors.

Critical strengths

1. The information boundary is clear and practical. Task requirements and workspace data can support checks even when hidden benchmark feedback is unavailable. Using paired traces to locate particular instructions gives the editor a concrete basis for deciding what to change and what to preserve.

2. The 17.2-point gain over curated skills is substantial, with improvements in seven of eight domains. The second evolution backbone and the mode/round ablations add useful evidence: full GLM reaches 73.0%, versus 62.9% for Refine-only, 67.0% for Repair-only, and 64.0% for a single round. Worked examples make the edits easy to understand.

Critical weaknesses

1. The evaluation is limited to one benchmark: 89 tasks from a fixed SkillsBench snapshot. The eight domains and additional executor models provide useful diversity, but they do not test the method in an independent benchmark with different execution and checking requirements. This matters because revision depends on observable artifacts and task-derived checks. I would like to see whether the gains hold in another task suite under the same restriction on external feedback.

2. The added value over simpler skill-editing workflows is still unclear. SkillRevise already revises skills from traces, and the March 2026 skill-creator already includes paired evaluation and model-drafted checks. A simpler editor using the same allowed inputs and checks is missing. Matching two final evaluations also leaves adaptation costs unmatched: each evolution run can use five execution pairs plus auditing and editing. Without actual calls, tokens, and time, I can't tell what the full workflow adds at the same total budget.

3. The pairing ablation is hard to connect to the full method. Section 4.3 reports 64.0% for paired runs and 59.4% for two with-skill runs, whereas full GLM reaches 73.0%. The differing settings are not explained. The existing comparison supports pairing in the tested setting; changing only the pairing in the full configuration would test its contribution more directly. Run-level results and paired uncertainty would also help judge the smaller component gains.

4. The acceptance gate needs better validation. Appendix A checks that the compiled verifier rejects an empty output and returns structured reports, but these checks do not establish that it correctly implements the task requirements. A small independent audit of accepted and rejected candidates would help. The data-to-d3 record also adds a reminder in round 5, although Algorithm 1 allows edits only before that round, leaving unclear whether the final edit was executed and checked.

Questions for authors

1. Do the gains hold on an independent task suite with different execution and checking requirements, while keeping benchmark rewards, tests, and reference solutions unavailable during revision? Which parts of the method transfer unchanged?

2. How does a simpler trace-based editor compare using the same initial skill, allowed feedback, task-derived checks, and total execution/token budget? Please report actual adaptation costs and specify the skill-creator version used for the related-work comparison.

3. Which round count and editing policy produced 64.0%/59.4%? What happens when only the pairing changes in the full 73.0% configuration? Please report individual run scores and uncertainty for the pairing and Repair gains.

4. Could you independently audit a sample of the compiled checks and their accept/reject decisions? Please also reconcile the round-5 edit in data-to-d3 with Algorithm 1 and confirm whether the final 50-line skill was executed after that edit.

Reviewer_1koHOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose SelfEvoSkill, which is a framework designed to revise agent skills without relying on any external outcome supervision like task rewards or oracle feedback. The main contribution is the paired execution audit mechanism. By comparing the execution trajectory of an agent equipped with a skill against the same agent operating without the skill, the framework successfully isolates the actual behavioral impact of the instructions. To ensure safety and constraint satisfaction, the framework utilizes a Task Compiled Verifier that is strictly constructed from explicit task requirements rather than ground truth answers.

Critical strengths
  • Innovative Alternative to Reward Signals: The idea of using the behavioral delta between paired executions is highly creative and logically sound. It beautifully addresses the core challenge of isolating skill influence from the base capability of the language model in unsupervised environments.

  • Robust Empirical Evidence: Reaching a high success rate on a complex benchmark without any external verification is a very strong result. It proves that autonomous skill refinement is practically viable for open ended tasks.

Critical weaknesses
  • The novelty of paired trajectory auditing is overstated. Previous papers already compares matched executions with and without a skill and attributes trajectory differences to skill induced behavior. Anthropic’s skill creator also supports comparisons between skill and no skill executions. SelfEvoSkill makes a meaningful extension by converting such evidence into passage level iterative revision without external outcome feedback, but the paired comparison itself is not new.

  • The source of the empirical gain is not sufficiently isolated. There is no baseline that performs iterative task grounded skill revision using the same Task Compiled Verifier, execution budget, and editing model, but without paired trajectories. Consequently, the experiments show that the full system works and that pairing improves one alternative by 4.6 points, but they do not establish how much of the much larger improvement over curated skills is specifically caused by paired auditing.

  • A secondary concern is computational efficiency. Each evolution run may contain up to five paired audits, and the paper reports the better of two full runs. Average iteration count, token consumption, monetary cost, and the distribution across independent runs are needed to assess whether the approach is practically competitive.

Questions for authors
  • How exactly does the PACE evaluation module behave when the baseline execution produces completely empty outputs or immediate errors? Does it risk hallucinating false behavioral differences?

  • Could you kindly provide a detailed estimation of the total token consumption and API cost required to fully evolve a skill under the five iteration limit?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.