- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TAD-UP for multivariate time series anomaly detection involving both continuous and discrete variables. The model uses two branches: a continuous branch parameterized by gated temporal convolutional networks within a neural ODE, and a discrete branch incorporating a state-dependent jump process. Cross-branch gates capture dependencies between variable types. Gaussian densities and categorical probabilities are combined to construct the training objective and anomaly scores.
Critical strengths
Continuous measurements and categorical states have different semantics and output spaces. Using separate embeddings, dynamics branches, and decoders while exchanging information through gates provides a plausible way to capture these differences and their dependencies. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of TAD-UP.
Critical weaknesses
-
The technical contribution appears incremental. TAD-UP primarily combines established components: neural ODEs, neural jump SDEs, and gated TCNs. In particular, learning continuous flows together with state-dependent jumps has already been explored by Jia and Benson (2019).
-
The Poisson jump assumption is insufficiently justified. The specific waiting-time assumptions of the Poisson jump process may not reflect the actual timing of observed events.
Questions for authors
-
Could you add an ablation study that replaces the jump SDE with an ordinary ODE while keeping everything else unchanged? This would show whether the jump mechanism itself improves performance.
-
Could you explain why TAD-UP achieves inference latency comparable to the baselines despite the additional cost of numerically solving its continuous and jump dynamics? Please specify the solver, step size, and number of function evaluations.
-
Equations (9) and (11) omit the exponent on under the square root.