- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DynaBeam models vegetation as connected Euler–Bernoulli beam structures, builds reference modes from geometry, and then estimates spectral scaling, a shared damping ratio, and density-normalized external forces from observed motion. Its key design is to separate the structure-determined modal space from the observation-determined dynamics parameters, avoiding repeated forward simulations during identification and enabling modes that are not sufficiently excited in the input to respond to new external forces. The paper evaluates parameter estimation, resimulation, and new external force prediction using synthetic FEM data, and demonstrates a qualitative interactive application with models reconstructed from real videos.
Critical strengths
-
The beam-based representation is well suited to branching vegetation and makes physical parameter recovery much more efficient by avoiding repeated forward simulations. The reported recovery time of around 2 seconds per tree is a meaningful practical improvement.
-
The generalization experiments under unseen forces are convincing. By deriving vibration modes from geometry rather than observed motion, DynaBeam can reproduce responses involving previously unexcited modes. The results against FEM ground truth show a substantial improvement over the motion-based baseline.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution of motion-based material estimation is not sufficiently isolated. The five tree species have relatively similar baseline stiffness-to-density ratios, but the paper does not include a simple constant-material baseline. It is therefore unclear how much of the parameter recovery accuracy comes from observed motion rather than the material prior.
-
The validation of recovered physical parameters is incomplete. The paper does not directly report damping or force estimation errors. Moreover, Section 3.5 and Appendix D.6 appear to use different force formulations for re-simulation. If the recovered modal residuals are used directly, accurate training reconstruction provides limited independent evidence of physical parameter accuracy.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors report the ground-truth distribution of stiffness-to-density ratios across the 72 trees and compare against a constant-material baseline using the same beam model, both for parameter recovery and novel-force simulation?
-
Does the reconstruction experiment in Table 1 use the spatially constrained force projected onto the modal basis, or the directly recovered modal forces? Are the held-out joints excluded from all parameter estimation steps?
-
Could the authors report the estimation errors for damping and external forces? In particular, how accurately can the recovered model predict free-decay motion when the external force is set to zero?
5 comments
W2/Q2: Direct validation of force recovery and re-simulation
Summary. We directly evaluate damping and force recovery over 72 trees, obtaining median relative errors of 2.0% and 8.5%, respectively, without ground-truth amplitude calibration. Unlike the baselines, which receive ground-truth force information for re-simulation, DynaBeam estimates the force amplitude and damping from observed motion. Table 1 uses a spatially constrained, mass-proportional force along X with a prescribed pulse profile; only its amplitude is unknown and recovered by least squares, while force-direction recovery is demonstrated separately (JdPW, W2). Held-out joints are excluded from all estimation steps and used only for evaluation, with their static geometry retained for beam construction.
Direct errors. Over 72 trees, the median relative damping error is 2.0% and the median relative force-amplitude error is 8.5%, with no ground-truth amplitude calibration.
Which force drives re-simulation. Force recovery has two steps (App. D.4). First, the modal force needed to explain the fitted motion, is computed as an intermediate quantity. Second, a physical force is fitted to it, with minimizing For the Table 1 experiments, forward simulation is driven by , the projection of this constrained physical force. Since the force profile is known, the entire re-simulated trajectory must emerge from the recovered , , and the single unknown amplitude. In App. D.6, we now explicitly distinguish this projection from the intermediate modal force.
Force formulation. The general formulation (App. D.4) supports combinations of spatial force patterns with time-varying coefficients, recovered through least squares. When no low-dimensional force prior is available, as for unknown forces on real plants, we instead use unconstrained, time-varying modal forces, recovered directly from the observed modal coordinates. This alternative is used for the real plants and the continuous-excitation case study (JdPW, W1). This distinction between the two formulations is now explicitly described in Sec. 3.4 and App. D.4.
Held-out joints. The 80/20 split is applied before any estimation. Only training joints are used for spectral analysis and material recovery, modal-coordinate fitting, damping and force-amplitude estimation. Held-out trajectories are used exclusively for evaluation. Thus, the held-out metrics measure generalization to unseen joints under the observed excitation; prediction over time is evaluated in Q3, and prediction under novel forces in Table 2.
Q3: Free decay with zero external force
Summary. After the pulse, the force is set to exactly zero in both the FEM reference and our simulation, so the free decay is predicted from the recovered stiffness and damping alone. DynaBeam's held-out free-decay error is 7.6× lower than VoMP's and 33× lower than PhysFlow's, and nearly identical on training and held-out joints. Only the oracle PhysFlow†, which is given the ground-truth density, force and damping, is lower.
| Method | Trees | Mean training Rel-L2 ↓ | Mean held-out Rel-L2 ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| DynaBeam | 72 | 0.525 | 0.540 |
| VoMP | 72 | 3.85 | 4.10 |
| PhysFlow | 45 | 17.4 | 17.9 |
| PhysFlow† (oracle) | 45 | 0.124 | 0.126 |
Errors are higher than over the full trajectory for every method. During decay the displacement amplitude shrinks, so small frequency mismatches accumulate into phase differences that relative error penalizes heavily.
W1/Q1: Motion-based material recovery vs. a constant-material prior
We thank the reviewer for the precise questions. Each is answered below with a new experiment or a direct clarification.
Summary. DynaBeam recovers material properties directly from observed motion and generalizes across substantial material variations and novel force directions, as demonstrated by three additional experiments. We drew materials from real wood species so that VoMP is evaluated in its intended regime. On this narrow range (1.32×), a constant based on the nominal species mean achieves lower ALDE (0.046) than DynaBeam (0.152). However, this constant becomes substantially less accurate as the material range expands, while DynaBeam maintains accurate material recovery and predicts novel-force motion more reliably. These experiments demonstrate the advantages of motion-based recovery beyond the original benchmark.
Ground-truth distribution. Across the 72 trees, E/ρ ranges from 7.13×106 to 9.42×106 m²/s². The five-species constant is their nominal mean, 8.531×106 m²/s².
1. Generalization to a novel force direction on the original 72 trees. All methods use the same beam model with ground-truth damping and force amplitude, so only E/ρ differs. The trees are driven along +Z, whereas training used +X, and no method is fitted to these trajectories.
DynaBeam achieves lower error than the five-species constant on 56/72 trees. ALDE measures agreement with the FEM's average material, while the beam model needs the effective E/ρ that reproduces the dynamics in its reduced representation. DynaBeam recovers the latter from motion, which explains its better dynamic predictions even when its ALDE is higher.
2. Material scaling (360 cases). We scaled E by α∈{0.25,0.5,1,2,4} on all 72 geometries, widening the tested E/ρ range by approximately 21×; the scaling factor is never given to the method. We compare DynaBeam against a fixed five-species prior E/ρ=8.531×106, using the same constant across all geometries and scales, without access to the ground-truth material values. The median within-tree log-log slope between recovered and true E/ρ is 0.997, indicating that DynaBeam closely tracks the imposed material changes. Across all 360 cases, DynaBeam achieves a median ALDE of 0.0745 (mean 0.096), compared with 0.3345 (mean 0.371) for the fixed prior, outperforming it in 304/360 cases.
Under the novel +Z force, DynaBeam achieves a median held-out Rel-L2 of 0.268 [0.161, 0.417], compared with 0.913 [0.786, 1.801] for the fixed prior, outperforming it in 347/360 cases. Its median cosine similarity is 0.970 (vs. 0.652), and its dominant-frequency error is only 1.9% (vs. 43.2%).
3. Six additional wood species (120 cases). We assigned balsam poplar, water tupelo, Port-Orford cedar, noble fir, black spruce and coast Douglas-fir to 20 existing geometries, following App. F, and regenerated the FEM ground truth. The nominal E/ρ range becomes 6.60–14.71×10⁶ m²/s².
DynaBeam beats the eleven-species constant in 116/120 cases and on all 20 geometries (paired mean difference −0.083, 95% CI [−0.089, −0.077], resampling geometries). Its error barely changes from the original materials to the new ones on the same geometries (mean ALDE 0.070 → 0.067), while the five-species constant's error grows 4.1× (0.043 → 0.175). The recovered values also preserve material differences: log-log slope 0.965, within-tree Spearman correlation at least 0.94, and a high-to-low ratio of 2.04 versus 2.07 in the ground truth.
Scope. This experiment isolates material-magnitude variation across species while keeping the spatial noise pattern fixed within each geometry.