acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SPDD: Guided Progressive Distillation for Fast and Safe Diffusion-Based Planning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Diffusion models have shown strong performance in trajectory planning, but their iterative denoising process introduces considerable inference latency, which limits their deployment in real-time and resource-constrained settings. In this work, we propose safe progressive diffusion distillation (SPDD), a framework for accelerating diffusion-based planning while preserving teacher consistency and trajectory safety. SPDD introduces a quadratic program-based guidance mechanism that integrates prescribed-time control Lyapunov function (CLF) and control barrier function (CBF) into the denoising process. The CLF guides the student denoising process toward the teacher output, whereas the CBF is prioritized to enforce the desired safety constraints. We theoretically characterize the consistency and safety properties of the guided denoising process. To mitigate discretization errors caused by aggressive step reduction, SPDD progressively reduces the sampling horizon during distillation. Experiments on multiple trajectory planning tasks demonstrate that SPDD achieves competitive inference efficiency while maintaining low teacher–student discrepancy and improved safety compared with existing diffusion-based planning baselines.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Safe motion planning, diffusion model, progressive distillation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_g8BpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1(−1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes SPDD to speed up diffusion-based trajectory planning whilst still ensuring safety and consistency with a pretrained teacher. The key contribution is a quadratic-program guidance scheme which combines prescribed time control Lyapunov functions (to encourage convergence to the teacher's output) with control barrier functions (to enforce the safety constraints). Safety is given priority via relaxation of the consistency constraint. The method gradually reduces the number of denoising steps to counteract the effects of discretisation and includes a full theoretical analysis of safety, consistency and the error introduced by the relaxation.

Validation includes the U-maze navigation (simulated), Hopper and Walker2d locomotion and robotic manipulation, with comparisons to SafeDiffuser, DDIM, progressive distillation and consistency distillation. The results show faster inference than the full teacher, generally lower final teacher-student error than the other acceleration methods and 100% observed safety in the ablations. Further experiments look at the complementary roles of the two guidance components and the benefit of a gradual step reduction. Task rewards are still below those of the full teacher and the theoretical guarantees are contingent on feasibility and discretisation assumptions. Real world deployment is of course for future work.

Critical strengths

SPDD combines progressive distillation with CLF-CBF guidance, treating safety as a hard constraint and allowing teacher consistency to relax when that becomes necessary. The analysis that goes with it characterises the consistency error introduced by that relaxation. That's important as it provides a principled way of prioritising safety when reproducing the teacher and when the need to satisfy the constraints becomes incompatible with that.

In the four simulated tasks CLF-only guidance generally maintains teacher fidelity at the expense of allowing safety violations, whilst CBF-only guidance achieves better safety at the cost of greater teacher-student errors. SPDD achieves both low final trajectory error and 100% observed safety (in the 160-step evaluations reported). The comparison serves to further underline the value of the combined approach over either guidance alone.

Critical weaknesses

The analysis is about continuous time dynamics and SPDD provides guidance at discrete denoising steps. Appendix B.4 does discuss constraint tightening which could in principle bridge the gap, but this would require valid bounds on the dynamics and guidance and the paper doesn't establish that such bounds are in fact obtained or that the tightening is actually carried out in the experiments. Progressive distillation on its own doesn't establish that constraints are satisfied at the final reduced sampling budget. That's a significant gap as guaranteed safety under acceleration is the key contribution of the paper.

Table 1 shows a significant degradation in reward relative to the teacher. SPDD performs better than simply reducing the number of SafeDiffuser steps, but the comparisons against the other acceleration methods in Table 2 don't include task reward. As a result you can't say that low teacher-student error and good safety metrics necessarily indicate a better trade-off between runtime, safety and actual planning performance. This in turn undermines the empirical backing for the paper's primary practical claim.

Questions for authors

Do the experiments implement the constraint tightening described in Appendix B.4? If so, how are the required bounds obtained and QP feasibility verified? If not, what guarantee applies to the final discrete sampler beyond the observed safety rates?

Reviewer_ggf4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a new distillation method considering safety constraints. The method solves a quadratic programming with CLF and CBF constraints to get the guided denoising steps, pulling student towards the teacher's output and satisfying the safety constraints within fewer diffusion steps. A progressive distillation framework is applied to limit the discretization error. Experiments on robotics simulation environments compare against state-of-art methods show the effectiveness.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem is interesting and the motivation is clear that we need to consider both safety and distillation
  2. The idea of using CLF-CBF constraints for safety and distillation is reasonable and the connection to the theory is interesting.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The whole algorithm framework is unclear to the reviewer. In the algorithm 1, it is not clear that how the method updates the student model. The solution to the QP is the denoising step rather than the parameters to my understanding. If the method use the standard Distillation training, then the student model is still hard to satisfy the constraints. If the method uses the CLF-CBF guided framework when deploying, do we still need teacher model to give the reference which introduces additional overhead?

  2. The strength of diffusion models lies in their ability to model distributions. However, the method uses the teacher model's output as a reference which could compromise this capability and harm the performance on multimodal distributions. Does the task itself have preference on deterministic actions?

  3. If CBF constraints are enforced, the diffusion sampling points might be out-of-distribution or unaware of the robotics dynamics, which could prevent the teacher model from generating valid actions, which would affect the effectiveness.

  4. For the closed-form solution, the author needs to clarify the scope of the closed-form based solution. When we apply the techniques in our real-world robotics, we may have a lot of constraints. To my understanding of the derivation in appendix B, it is specific to single constraint and if we apply it to multiple constraints, this will become hard to get a single solution to this.

Questions for authors
  1. Could you clarify the whole training and inference process for the method that help me understand how the constraints help the safety and distillation?
  2. Could you show some mode coverage metrics that help me understand whether this will harm the capability of distribution modeling?
  3. Could you check if the CBF will lead to out of distribution problem if we have other complex constraints?
  4. Could you clarify if we have multiple nonconvex safe constraints, do we still have the tractable closed-form solutions?
Reviewer_QhFFOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Safe Progressive Diffusion Distillation (SPDD), a diffusion distillation method that accelerates the sampling of diffusion-based trajectory plannners while maintaining safety constraints consistent with a teacher model. SPDD mainly relies on a quadratic-program guidance mechanism combined with a prescribed-time control Lyapunov function (CLF), which encourages convergence to the teacher’s output with a hard control barrier function (CBF) to prioritize safety. The authors combine this guidance mechanism with progressive distillation to reduce denoising steps. Experiments cover maze navigation, Hopper, Walker2d and robotic manipulation tasks, with comparisons against some diffusion planner baselines with reduced sampling steps.

Critical strengths

Accelerating diffusion planners while explicitly prioritizing safety is an important and relevant research problem. The motivation is clear and proposed method attempts tp provide an interpretable way to address this problem.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The V(x)V(x) function used in the CLF involves the teacher's terminal output x~(1)\tilde{x}(1). It's unclear how x~(1)\tilde{x}(1) is obtained during inference. If you have to run the teacher during inference, then distillation is pointless.
  2. The claim of acceleration without sacrificing task performance does not seem to hold. For example, Table 1 shows that Hopper and Walker2d rewards significantly drop at 160 sampling steps.
  3. The experiments only consider distillation methods with O(102)O(10^2) sampling steps, which still requires too many iterations and results in high latency, while recent diffusion distillation methods such as DMD2 and MeanFlow can do <10<10 steps without sacrificing the generation quality.
Questions for authors
  1. How do you obtain x~(1)\tilde{x}(1) for a new test condition during inference without running the teacher? If you have to run the teacher, did you count the teacher's computation in your reported latency for your method?
  2. Could the authors evaluate SPDD with few-step sampling setting (e.g., 1-step, 4-step, 8-step) and compare it with current baselines in the paper as well as more advanced diffusion distillation methods such as DMD2 or MeanFlow?
  3. The tasks considered in the experiments seem a bit toy. Could the authors evaluate SPDD on more realistic tasks such as trajectory planning for closed-loop autonomous driving? This is a common task considered by many diffusion planner research papers and will give a better sense of the performance-latency trade-off of SPDD.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.