- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a new model using semantic prior to select brain function and structural connectivity subspaces for prediction of working memory. The semantic prior selected subspace features are further fused with data-driven FC/SC backbone features with trained weights parameters. The performance was evaluated in nested CV. And four different semantic priors are compared. Overall the novelty comes from semantic prior generation and testing the effectiveness of the semantic prior. That said, there exists some confusion and major concerns on the results interpretation.
Critical strengths
The novelty comes from semantic prior generation and testing the effectiveness of the semantic prior for brain connectivity subspace selection.
Critical weaknesses
The data-driven FC-SC backbone is not explained at all in the paper. Table 1 indicates data-driven FC-SC backbone model along has a r value 0.2430, While by adding semantic prior, the SPEF does not show significant improvement ( 0.2439). This is the main performance results, for which the explanation is missing. Figure 2 presents important regions but how to proof these regions are not influenced by data-driven backbone selection?
Questions for authors
Figure 2 presents important regions but how to proof these regions are not influenced by data-driven backbone selection? How to explain F3 random prior could have higher stability than matched prior for SC?