- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates whether large language models can abstract latent relational structures from natural language descriptions and transfer such structural knowledge to contexts with different surface forms. The authors introduce an evaluation framework that converts various abstract structures into natural language scenarios and asks models to identify the candidate whose structure matches that of a reference context. The experiments examine model performance across different structure types, levels of domain congruency, and structure sizes, comparing both model families and model scales. The results suggest that recent strong models are generally robust in transferring structures across domains, whereas smaller models rely more on surface semantics or local relational cues. The paper also includes generation validation and human auditing to improve task reliability and reproducibility.
Critical strengths
-
The research question is clear and meaningful, systematically examining structural knowledge transfer as a cognitive capability.
-
The evaluation framework is well designed, allowing controlled analysis across structure types, relational domains, and task sizes.
-
The experiments are broad in coverage, and the task-generation process, human validation, and released materials support good reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
- The tasks are mainly constructed and validated using a generative model; despite human spot checks, potential linguistic biases or implicit shortcuts may still exist, limiting ecological validity.
- The evaluation relies on multiple-choice questions and overall accuracy, making it difficult to distinguish genuine understanding of global structure from the use of local features or heuristic cues.
- The conclusions are primarily based on controlled synthetic tasks, leaving generalization to natural scenarios, longer contexts, or more complex relational combinations insufficiently validated.
Questions for authors
- Since the task texts are generated by a generative model, did the authors further analyze how linguistic biases or implicit shortcuts might affect the experimental conclusions?
- Beyond the multiple-choice evaluation, did the authors consider additional analyses to distinguish genuine understanding of global structure from the use of local heuristic cues?
- Beyond controlled synthetic tasks, do the authors plan to validate the generalization of structural transfer on more natural corpora or more complex contexts?
2 comments
Response to comments on multiple-choice evaluation and generalization to more realistic settings
W2. The evaluation relies on multiple-choice questions and overall accuracy, making it difficult to distinguish genuine understanding of global structure from the use of local features or heuristic cues.
INSTILL investigates whether LLMs can recognize and transfer relational structures across different contexts. Importantly, models are not given explicit graphs to compare. They must infer relational structures from cognitive scenarios described in natural-language and identify the same structure despite changes in entities, expressions, and domains. This provides a controlled way to examine the abstraction and transfer of structural knowledge. As discussed in Section 3 (Lines 146-151), structural knowledge lacks a canonical representation, making it difficult to assess directly. Therefore, we adopt a multiple-choice format to evaluate this capability without requiring models to explicitly represent the inferred structures.
Cognitive science-inspired evaluations often assess latent cognitive abilities through observable behavior on controlled tasks, without assuming that the underlying mechanisms are identical to those of humans [5, 6]. For example, CogEval [5] evaluates cognitive maps and planning through tasks that vary underlying structures, without aiming to directly compare LLM performance with humans or establish that LLMs exhibit human-like cognition. ReCogLab [6] also draws on cognitive science experiments to investigate relational reasoning in LLMs, while cautioning that similarities in observed behavior do not necessarily imply identical cognitive mechanisms. In line with this perspective, INSTILL aims to characterize the ability of LLMs to generalize relational structures, rather than establish that they acquire or represent structural knowledge in the same way as humans. Our findings reveal how this ability varies across structural families, domain shifts, and structure sizes, with substantial differences in robustness across models.
[5] Momennejad et al., Evaluating Cognitive Maps and Planning in Large Language Models with CogEval, NeurIPS 2023.
[6] Liu et al., ReCogLab: A Framework Testing Relational Reasoning & Cognitive Hypotheses on LLMs, ICLR 2025.
W3. The conclusions are primarily based on controlled synthetic tasks, leaving generalization to natural scenarios, longer contexts, or more complex relational combinations insufficiently validated.
Q3. Beyond controlled synthetic tasks, do the authors plan to validate the generalization of structural transfer on more natural corpora or more complex contexts?
We designed INSTILL as a controlled evaluation to systematically examine how structural inference and transfer vary across structures, domains, and graph sizes. Our results reveal clear performance differences across these factors, even within relatively simple settings.
We agree that extending the evaluation to more natural scenarios, longer contexts, and more complex relational combinations is an important direction. However, such settings can introduce additional confounding factors, making it difficult to identify which factors contribute to differences in model performance. As an initial investigation, we therefore prioritize controlling these factors to better understand how structural properties and domains affect model performance. Extending this evaluation to more natural and complex settings remains an important direction for future work.
Response to comments on potential linguistic biases and heuristic shortcuts
We sincerely appreciate your careful evaluation and valuable feedback on our manuscript. We hope that our responses to your comments below clearly address your concerns.
We would like to clarify that we have examined potential linguistic shortcuts and their effects on structural inference performance. To investigate potential shortcuts arising from linguistic cues, we compare congruent and incongruent conditions in our main experiments (Section 4.3, Table 2), examining how domain similarity affects structural inference performance. We further evaluate entity-count and embedding-similarity heuristics in Appendix C.1. The results show that such shortcuts do not consistently identify the correct candidate across different domains.
In addition, to further examine whether models rely on local structural cues, we conducted an additional experiment controlling for degree sequences. We compared two conditions: one where all candidates shared the reference’s degree sequence (matched) and another where only the correct candidate did (unmatched). In both conditions, the distractors were non-isomorphic to the reference. GPT-5.4 and GPT-5 maintained high accuracy even when degree sequences were matched, whereas their mini variants showed larger performance declines. This pattern is consistent with our main findings, as models that achieve higher performance on structural inference tasks tend to show smaller performance declines under more challenging conditions. Detailed results and discussion are provided in Appendix C.6.
We acknowledge that linguistic patterns in LLM-generated descriptions may introduce biases that influence model predictions. However, the reliability of an LLM-generated benchmark depends not simply on the use of LLMs, but on whether the generation process is carefully controlled and the resulting data are rigorously validated to ensure their suitability for the intended evaluation [1, 2, 3, 4]. In INSTILL, the underlying structures and correct answers are constructed and verified programmatically, while an independent human audit confirms that the generated descriptions preserve the intended relational information with 99.23% accuracy. Although these procedures do not eliminate all potential linguistic biases, we believe that our task design, programmatic verification, and independent human validation support the reliability of our evaluation across different structures and domains.
[1] Jiang et al., Raising the Bar: Investigating the values of large language models via generative evolving testing, ICML 2025.
[2] Yuan et al., LLM-Powered Benchmark Factory: Reliable, generic, and efficient, ACL 2026.
[3] Huang et al., DataGen: Unified synthetic dataset generation via large language models, ICLR 2025.
[4] Li et al., AutoBencher: Towards declarative benchmark construction, ICLR 2025.