acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Layer-Edit Coverage Beyond Sampling: From Candidates to Selected Answers

Abstract

Can layer-execution edits supply correct answers that ordinary sampling misses, and can a selector recover them? We study skipping, repetition, and substitutions that combine the two in frozen language models. Our grid contains approximately 14.2 million correctness evaluations over 1,261 paths, five mathematical difficulty strata, and four prompt conditions on Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, with a Qwen3-4B comparison. Across three model–difficulty groups of 565 questions each, the exhaustive 1,260-edit pool covers 15–56 questions missed by all 57 unedited-model samples. Yet question-held-out path ranking and direct 57-path voting correctly answer only 0–3 of these additional questions and trail 57-sample self-consistency by 23–57 correct answers per group. Shortlists exclude many available answers, and voting rarely recovers those retained. The edit grid also has reproducible structure: average substitution performance tracks constituent effects, while 45–51% of discovered substitution events with failed constituents succeed again on the rewrite prompt. Tested pre-generation rankers show no improvement over a structural prior, despite informative post-generation correctness signals. These findings separate additional candidate coverage from the ability to select a correct answer. They use original-checker scores and previously inspected questions and outputs; unequal coverage pools and unmeasured end-to-end costs preclude an efficiency claim.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, mathematical reasoning, test-time computation, layer-execution editing, answer selection, self-consistency

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_7577OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies layer skipping, repetition, and substitution in frozen language models. It measures additional answer coverage, the ability of selectors to recover those answers, and how combined edits behave across prompts.

Critical strengths
  • The evaluation tracks candidate availability, shortlist retention, and final answers. It shows where additional correct candidates are lost during selection, providing useful evidence about the gap between coverage and output accuracy.
  • The composition analysis identifies combinations that succeed even when both component edits fail. About 45–51% of these discovered cases succeed again under a rewritten prompt, revealing useful limits of predicting combinations from their components.
Critical weaknesses
  • Correctness labels need stronger validation. The paper documents a checker false positive, grading disagreements, and incomplete generation records. A single falsely accepted answer can inflate coverage across 1,260 edits, making independent verification important for the central finding.
  • The coverage comparison uses 1,260 edited paths and 57 ordinary samples, leaving the contribution of candidate count unresolved. The 57-path voter also answers 23–57 fewer questions correctly than self-consistency across the three groups. Missing runtime and token measurements leave its practical tradeoff unclear.
Questions for authors
  • Could you independently verify the additional-coverage cases and the cases determining the voting comparison, using consistent grading and confirmed question and path identities?
  • Could you compare coverage at shared candidate counts and report generation time, output tokens, and feature-extraction costs for the 57-path voter and self-consistency?
Reviewer_FJSsOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates layer-execution edits in frozen language models, including layer skipping, repeating, and substitution. The authors constructed an exhaustive editing grid comprising 1,261 execution paths and conducted experiments on mathematical problems using Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct and Qwen3-4B. The results show that layer edits can cover a subset of correct answers missed by standard sampling, but tested path ranking and voting methods rarely select these answers, with overall performance falling below 57-sample self-consistency. The paper also analyzes the compositional structure of substitution edits and finds that some substitutions can still succeed repeatedly even when both constituent edits fail.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper clearly distinguishes between candidate answer coverage and the effectiveness of the final answer selection, and the problem is clearly defined.

  2. This paper evaluates a relatively large and systematic grid of skipping, repetition, and substitution edits.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main coverage results rely on an exhaustive oracle and use correctness labels from the evaluation phase to determine whether candidates exist. However, these results cannot directly establish improvements in output accuracy under a practical selection procedure.

  2. The edit pool contains 1,260 paths, while self-consistency has only 57 samples, indicating a substantial budget imbalance for coverage comparisons. The end-to-end costs of generation, feature extraction, and selection are also not fully reported.

  3. The selection results are weak: the edit voting over edited paths underperforms self-consistency in all three main groups, and the prefill ranker does not outperform the structural prior. Thus, the paper demonstrates additional candidate coverage, but the tested selection methods do not consistently improve output accuracy over self-consistency.

  4. The experimental results are limited to Qwen models, the DART-Math, and four fixed prompt conditions. There is insufficient evidence of generalization to other models, tasks, and prompts.

  5. The “failed constituents but successful substitution” phenomenon is intriguing, but the current analysis establishes correlation rather than revealing the underlying mechanism.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the coverage and accuracy conclusions remain valid under a strictly matched end-to-end compute budget between layer edits and self-consistency?

  2. Why do the proposed rankers fail to outperform the structural prior or self-consistency, and have stronger shared-pool verifiers been tested?

  3. Can the additional coverage be reproduced on independent questions, other mathematical tasks, or different model families?

  4. Do the successful substitutions with failed constituents remain frequent after controlling for prompt noise and question-specific effects?

Reviewer_7cMVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors compare candidate generation using 1,260 layer edits of a frozen LLM with 57 standard Self-Consistency samples. They investigate additional candidate coverage, methods for selecting correct answers without access to ground truth, and patterns of interaction between layer edits. The results show that layer editing can produce additional correct answers, but the tested selectors rarely recover them and underperform Self-Consistency in final answer accuracy.

Critical strengths
  1. The large-scale evaluation of 1,260 structural edits across multiple difficulty levels and models provides insight into their effects on answer correctness and reveals patterns in how individual operations interact, including cases where combining two unsuccessful edits produces a correct answer.
  2. The paper clearly distinguishes between the presence of correct answers in the candidate pool and the accuracy of the final output. By tracking candidates from the full pool through shortlisting and voting, the authors effectively illustrate the gap between the potential of layer editing and the ability of the tested selectors to realize it.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The code for the main experimental pipeline is not provided, although the Supplementary Material includes a more detailed version of the paper with additional implementation details in the appendices. Differences in appendix structure and numbering between the two versions make it difficult to cross-reference the materials and follow the experimental setup.
  2. Despite the scale of the experiments, the paper's distinct scientific contribution is not sufficiently clear. The distinction between candidate coverage and output accuracy is already established in prior work, while the experiments provide limited evidence for the broader value of layer editing beyond the specific settings and selection methods studied. Unequal candidate pools, limited selection methods, and known scoring errors and inconsistencies in the stored data further limit the strength of the conclusions. As a result, the paper provides valuable empirical evidence, but it remains unclear what new, generalizable insights about layer editing can be drawn from it.
Questions for authors
  1. Does layer editing still provide additional coverage over ordinary sampling under matched computational budgets? Given the central role of this result, such a comparison would help establish the practical significance of the observed coverage.
  2. Given the known checker errors and inconsistencies in the stored data, could the authors independently verify all 113 additionally covered problems, confirming at least one correct structural answer and the absence of correct answers among the corresponding SC samples?
  3. Why is the main ranker trained to predict correctness across 0-shot, 1-shot, and 2-shot prompts simultaneously when the final evaluation uses 0-shot Rewrite? Have the authors tested whether training on 0-shot correctness alone improves path selection?
  4. How well do the main findings hold on entirely unseen questions? Since the experimental data were repeatedly examined during method development, it would be important to validate the results on a new dataset using a fixed, predefined protocol.
  5. How many distinct problems are represented by cases where combining SKIP and REPEAT produces a correct answer despite both edits failing individually, and how many of these problems contribute additional coverage? Does the effect remain statistically significant when accounting for multiple events from the same question?
  6. Why are SKIP and REPEAT evaluated using D-validity in Section 4.2, while SUB is evaluated using R-validity? Could this make it difficult to isolate the effect of combining the edits?
  7. What motivated the different training setups for the Qwen2.5 and Qwen3 rankers, with difficulty 4+5 used for the former and only difficulty 5 for the latter? Was training under matched conditions evaluated?
  8. How exactly were the five structural edits used in Table 5A selected, and what data were used to make that selection?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.