- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work investigates cross-domain edge classification on dynamic text-attributed graphs. It introduces a domain-wise holdout self-supervised pre-training pipeline for few-shot adaptation on target domains, with Bag of Events (BoE) designed as a baseline without explicit temporal-spatial encoding. The proposed STSA integrates time offsets and node occurrence frequencies via MLP, and leverages Contrastive Semantic Forecasting (CSF) to predict interaction text embeddings. The topic is meaningful. The experimental setup, covering four domains, eight datasets and frozen-encoder evaluation, forms a solid foundation.
Critical strengths
-
The research question carries practical value. By combining cross-domain unsupervised pre-training with target-domain edge classification, this work can examine whether the model learns reusable interaction representations, rather than merely fitting prediction patterns on a single graph.
-
The BoE model achieves strong performance even with weakened explicit spatiotemporal encoding, demonstrating that complex structural designs do not guarantee improved transferability. This finding offers valuable insights to re-examine the respective roles of semantics, graph structure, and temporal information in dynamic graph models.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper attributes the weaker performance of complex methods compared to BoE to overfitting on the source domain’s structural, temporal and linguistic distributions. However, Table 1 shows that most baselines already approach majority-class prediction without pre-training, and pre-training yields only marginal or no improvement. This suggests an alternative explanation: the target-domain training setup, optimization conditions or input adaptation prevent these methods from learning effective classifiers. Their failure to generalize does not emerge after pre-training.
-
The number of classes across the eight tasks varies widely from 2 to 266. Fixing the label pool to the most recent 500 instances creates substantially different learning setups. For binary tasks, this may yield sufficient class coverage. However, 147 classes in GDELT and 169 classes in ICEWS are absent from the fine-tuning samples. In addition, using consecutive recent samples can introduce strong temporal locality bias.
Questions for authors
See Weakness
We thank Reviewer gEWD for their time carefully reviewing our work and providing useful feedback. Your primary concerns overlap with those raised by fellow reviewers, and are therefore addressed in the General Response at the top to avoid repetition.
Mapping of Shared Concerns to the General Response:
Because both of your specific weaknesses (and corresponding questions) are fully covered by the new control experiments and discussion in these two sections of the General Response, we kindly refer you there for our complete response.