- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the influence function, and it claims that the standard first-order estimate reduces individual contributions to a sum, where the substantial differences among members are hidden. Therefore, they establish a Bregman centroid formulation of the linearized group influence function, and utilize the Bregman information to quantify the variation. The proposed estimator achieves higher R2 than standard group influence in predicting target changes.
Critical strengths
N/A
Critical weaknesses
- I strongly doubt this submission was finished by AI agent, since I find it is really hard to follow and understand.
- The experiments are too simple and toy. Now this paper is still focused on MNIST with MLP, while I believe recent papers of the influence function have conducted the empirical experiments on LLMs and even VLMs. Therefore, I do not think the experiments of this paper is solid and convincing.
Questions for authors
Refer to the weakness.
3 comments
Thanks, i would like to keep my score
We would like to clarify our earlier response regarding AI assistance. The authors formulated the research questions, developed the core methodology, and wrote the initial drafts of the manuscript, establishing their structure and flow, and used AI to help polish the language. Our previous response emphasized verification and responsibility but did not clearly articulate the authors’ role in developing the research itself.
We also take the concern about clarity seriously. Could the reviewer point to specific passages, sections, or paragraphs that were difficult to follow? Concrete examples would help us understand what made the impression that the submission was generated by an AI agent.
We thank the reviewer for their feedback.
A2. Our experiments are a controlled mechanism study of how group structure affects influence prediction. We vary the partition and component weighting while holding the source model and nonlinear PBRF reference fixed. The study covers Dogfish logistic regression, MNIST MLP, and CIFAR-10 ResNet9. These results do not establish effectiveness at LLM/VLM scale.
A1. As disclosed in the manuscript, we used generative AI to assist our research and writing, and reviewed and verified the AI-assisted work. We made the final decisions on methodology, interpretation, and presentation and take responsibility for the final content.