- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FedDCOL, a federated oversampling framework for imbalanced tabular classification. The method first defines a class-overlap score using neighborhood label consistency and relative distances to class centers, based on which local samples are partitioned into safe, boundary, and noisy regions. It then develops SC-Diff, a tabular diffusion model augmented with a prototype-relation constraint and an inter-class margin constraint. During federated training, SC-Diff is repeatedly updated and used to generate minority-class candidates, which are filtered according to the same structural criterion before being incorporated into classifier training. Experiments on seven tabular datasets report improvements in AUC, F1-score, and G-mean over six baselines
Critical strengths
--Minority-class scarcity is indeed a meaningful challenge in federated tabular learning, and dynamically updating a generative oversampler during federated optimization is a reasonable direction beyond one-shot preprocessing.
--The authors report results on seven datasets using AUC, F1-score, and G-mean, perform Friedman/Nemenyi testing, include parameter sensitivity studies, and provide component-level ablations
Critical weaknesses
+FedDCOL combines several existing ingredients, including neighborhood-based overlap estimation, prototype modeling, tabular diffusion, margin/prototype regularization, minority-class oversampling, and federated gradient aggregation. The main additional idea is to continually update the diffusion model and regenerate minority samples across communication rounds. However, the current experiments do not convincingly isolate whether the gains come from dynamic updating itself, the use of diffusion instead of other generators, the structural constraints, or the candidate filtering strategy. Stronger controlled comparisons with static diffusion, periodically retrained oversampling, and diffusion without structural constraints are needed.
+The proposed overlap score combines same-class KNN consistency and relative class-center distance through a specific exponential transformation, but the functional form and thresholds are largely heuristic. More importantly, FedDCOL applies KNN and Euclidean class-center distances directly after concatenating min-max normalized numerical variables with one-hot categorical variables. Such geometry may not reliably reflect semantic similarity in heterogeneous tabular data. Since the safe/boundary/noisy partition is central to the entire framework, the authors should justify this metric more rigorously and compare it against alternatives such as Gower distance, learned embeddings, or other tabular similarity measures.
+The paper defines the prototype set using embeddings of all safe samples rather than a small number of representative class prototypes. As a result, the relation vector has dimensionality proportional to the number of safe samples, which can make the prototype-relation constraint increasingly expensive as local dataset size grows. This also makes the term “prototype” somewhat misleading. In addition, the nearest-prototype margin formulation may be unstable when many reference embeddings are used. The paper should provide complexity analysis and compare against class centers or clustered prototypes.
+All experiments use only five clients with full participation in every round, while the default client partition uses a Dirichlet concentration of 1. This does not adequately test realistic federated settings with more clients, partial participation, unequal data sizes, heterogeneous imbalance ratios, or client dropout. At the same time, FedDCOL repeatedly trains and communicates a diffusion model, generates candidates, evaluates their structure, and updates the classifier, yet no systematic communication, runtime, memory, or scalability analysis is provided. These omissions weaken the practical federated-learning claims of the paper.
+Although the paper includes ablation studies and sensitivity analysis, it does not directly address the key causal question of whether continual dynamic oversampling outperforms comparable static or periodically updated generative oversampling approaches. Sensitivity analysis is performed exclusively on the BUPA dataset even though the method involves many critical hyperparameters. Furthermore, the manuscript suffers from multiple writing and formatting issues. Representative examples include misspellings such as “CLass Overlap Structure Modeling”, “Mini‑bacth”, “Multionmial”, and “Blances samples”, as well as redundant phrasing “Equation equation 6”. Some labels in Figure 1 are also rendered too small for clear readability. More rigorous experimental decomposition and comprehensive proofreading are required.
Questions for authors
--How do the authors justify the specific formulation of the class-overlap score?
--How reliable is the proposed overlap modeling for mixed-type tabular data?
--Why are all safe-sample embeddings treated as prototypes in the prototype-relation constraint?