- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work proposes WaveKernel, a continuous-kernel parameterization that synthesizes kernels as learned combinations of fixed optical propagation responses. A fixed optical excitation propagates through a simulated slab waveguide to a set of latent positions, following the scalar Huygens–Fresnel principle. Mode-wise complex coefficients provide task-specific adaptation, and a second passive propagation produces a coordinate-dependent complex optical response, whose real part gives the kernel. Averaged over seven sampling rates, WaveKernel outperforms spline by 1.57–3.66% on three sleep-staging datasets and trails it by 0.37% on ECG. Both kernels keep nearly constant accuracy across sampling rates. WaveKernel is less robust to strong broadband noise, reaching 42.08% accuracy at 10 dB white noise compared with 54.01% for spline.
Critical strengths
- WaveKernel improves accuracy over the spline-based continuous kernel without losing cross-rate stability. It exceeds spline by 1.95, 1.57, and 3.66% on ISRUC, HMC, and SleepEOG (L321–L322) in all five folds (L969–L971) with a similar parameter count (338.15K vs. 319.59K), while its worst-case drop across seven rates (0.06–0.90%) stays comparable to spline (0.17–0.57%) and far below CKConv (10.53–36.68%) (Table 4).
- The figures and tables are clear and well prepared.
Critical weaknesses
The specific challenge that WaveKernel addresses could be defined more clearly. Compared with the care given to the figures and tables, the line of argument in the text is less developed. The title and abstract present a general continuous-kernel parameterization, motivated by the statement that "the effective parameterization of continuous kernels remains an important open challenge" (L039–L040). A more concrete problem statement would help readers see why an optical basis is needed and how the experiments test it.
- Problem formulation. The introduction notes that fixed bases confine kernels to prescribed function families, while neural kernels are sensitive to optimization (L045–L049). WaveKernel, however, is itself a finite expansion over a fixed basis, determined by diffraction physics and propagation geometry, with kernels spanning at most dimensions per channel pair (L126–L129, L248–L252). It would help readers if the authors explained how this fixed basis avoids the limitation attributed to predefined bases, and which limitation the experiments are meant to test.
- Choice of optics. Section 3.2 moves directly from the need for a learnable function family (L168) to slab waveguides (L191–L206). Since the model is purely digital (L464–L468), it would help to explain why propagation responses suit the problem better than other oscillatory bases, such as Fourier, Gabor, or chirp atoms.
- Experimental domain. The introduction motivates the setting by physiological signals (L080–L083), but the only link between these signals and the basis is "a plausible inductive bias for physiological rhythms and transient patterns" (L431–L433), and consistent gains appear only on three sleep-staging datasets (L444–L446). For a general parameterization, more diverse benchmarks, such as those used for CKConv and FlexConv, would better show where the optical basis helps.
The comparison with neural kernels could be strengthened. The 10.6–23.5% margin over CKConv (Table 1) mainly reflects its collapse at unseen rates, which the authors relate to the scaling of its convolution and bias (L826–L827), an implementation choice rather than a property of MLP kernels. The 3.10–11.20% lead at the training rate (Tables 5–8) is measured against a single untuned CKConv with twice the parameters (L827; 677.25K vs. 338.15K). A tuned CKConv and FlexConv (L124–L126) at matched parameter counts would show whether the gain comes from the kernel family.
Questions for authors
- Why are the responses of Eq. (2) a better basis for physiological kernels than other oscillatory bases with a comparable number of coefficients?
- On the sleep datasets, all test rates are resampled from the same 35 Hz low-passed recording (L750, L755, L774, L845–L846), and U-Sleep, which simply resamples its input to the training rate (L847), is similarly stable (Table 4). Can the cross-rate experiment distinguish continuous kernels from input resampling? For example, how do the two compare when the model is trained on downsampled data and tested on the original high-rate recordings?
- How does WaveKernel compare with a tuned CKConv (without the scaling of the bias) and with FlexConv at matched parameter counts, both at the training rate and across rates?
- Which limitation of existing spline or neural kernels does WaveKernel resolve, and can it be measured directly? What do the learned kernels look like in time and frequency?
Clarification of WaveKernel's Contribution and Experimental Evidence
We thank the reviewer for the constructive suggestions on the motivation and experimental evaluation of WaveKernel. We have refined the problem formulation and added a controlled comparison with alternative kernel bases.
1. Motivation and Propagation-Based Inductive Bias
WaveKernel investigates whether a compact, propagation-derived basis provides a useful inductive bias for continuous temporal kernels under a fixed parameter budget. Rather than claiming a strictly larger function space, our contribution lies in the optical propagation-based parameterization, which may enable more efficient representations of certain oscillatory kernels.
Optical propagation generates basis functions with coordinate-dependent amplitude envelopes and nonlinear phase variations. Unlike Fourier and standard Gabor functions with constant carrier frequencies, their local frequencies vary with the coordinate. Unlike quadratic-phase chirps, their phase curvature is generally nonconstant. Compared with spline basis functions, they explicitly incorporate oscillatory phase structures. These properties are further analyzed in Appendix A.5.
2. Controlled Comparison with Alternative Bases
To evaluate the effectiveness of the optical basis, we added a five-fold SleepEOG experiment comparing optical, spline, Fourier, Gabor, and chirp parameterizations under matched conditions, including identical architecture, sampling grids, normalization, training settings, and 337,129 trainable parameters.
Averaged over seven sampling rates, optical achieves 59.48 ± 1.58% accuracy, compared with 56.82 ± 1.38% for spline, 56.32 ± 1.99% for Fourier, 59.05 ± 1.26% for Gabor, and 58.94 ± 1.96% for chirp.
The optical basis retains improvements of 2.66 and 3.16 percentage points over spline and Fourier, respectively, while achieving comparable performance to Gabor and chirp. These results provide experimental support for the propagation-based parameterization under matched conditions. Details are provided in Section 4.1 and Appendix D (Table 9).
3. Cross-Rate Evaluation and Input Resampling
Our cross-rate experiments demonstrate that WaveKernel can directly evaluate learned continuous kernels at different sampling rates without retraining or changing the learned coefficients.
As the sleep recordings share a common 35 Hz low-pass-filtered source, input resampling to the training rate is also a valid approach to cross-rate evaluation. A comparison using low-rate training data and native high-rate test recordings would further distinguish these strategies. We have clarified the evaluation setting in Appendix B.4.
4. CKConv and FlexConv Comparisons
The CKConv baseline follows the publicly released NeurOCNN wrapper, which applies the 1/fs factor after the affine convolution, scaling both the convolution output and bias. An alternative is to apply the scaling only to the convolution term while adjusting the bias to preserve the training-rate output.
Further comparisons with a bias-adjusted and tuned CKConv and a parameter-matched FlexConv would help assess the performance of WaveKernel against neural kernel parameterizations more comprehensively. We have clarified the CKConv implementation details in Appendix B.3.
5. Learned Kernels and Experimental Scope
Figure 6 illustrates the amplitude and phase characteristics of the optical basis functions. The learned kernels combine these responses through task-specific coefficients. A direct time- and frequency-domain analysis of the resulting learned kernels would further characterize their relationship to physiological rhythms.
We have refined the Introduction and Limitations to focus the current contribution on physiological time-series classification, supported by the results on three sleep-staging datasets and the new matched basis comparison.