acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SEER: Boosting Agentic Reasoning via Entropy-Reducing Evidence Selection

17 views

Abstract

Agentic reasoning has shown great potential for many real-world applications. Its success largely relies on whether limited context windows can contain the evidence needed for subsequent decisions of agents. However, properly selecting the useful evidence remains highly challenging due to the rapidly growing interaction histories. To tackle this problem, we propose **S**electing **E**vidence by **E**ntropy **R**eduction (**SEER**), a novel and theoretically-grounded context management framework to boost the agentic reasoning. We cast the context management rigorously in an Information Bottleneck (IB) formulation, which can well balance the *compactness* and *effectiveness* of contexts. Then, the IB formulation naturally gives rise to SEER, which measures the value of each evidence based on its marginal reduction in the agent's entropy over subsequent environment feedback. By prioritizing high-value evidence, SEER dynamically constructs compact contexts enriched with information that supports subsequent reasoning. Extensive experiments on challenging benchmarks show that SEER significantly outperforms all baselines across multiple model scales and families in terms of accuracy and task completion, improving over the strongest baseline by up to **9.4 points**.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
context engineering, evidence selection, large language models, agentic reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_3zNSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes SEER. SEER uses an Information Bottleneck perspective for context management in LLM agents. It does not select evidence by semantic relevance or compression rate. Instead, it selects evidence by how much it reduces the agent's uncertainty about the next environment feedback. It uses marginal entropy reduction per unit token cost as the admission score. The method first formulates context construction as a cost-aware Information Bottleneck objective. It then replaces the latent relevance variable with observable proxy outcome categories. Next, it uses hypothetical actions induced by candidate evidence to predict the proxy outcome distribution. It estimates the action-conditioned entropy from this distribution. This avoids real-environment counterfactual executions for each candidate.

Critical strengths
  1. The criterion is decision-theoretic. Evidence value is tied to uncertainty reduction over future feedback. This is cleaner than relevance or compression alone.
  2. It covers four benchmarks. It includes multiple model families and scales. It adds budget-matched comparisons, threshold sweeps, and ablations. Tables 3 and 4 give a credible case that the gains are not just more evidence or more scoring calls.
  3. The robustness checks are practical. They cover taxonomy granularity, prompt variants, module assignment, and error propagation.
Critical weaknesses
  1. ACC on ExCyTIn-Bench is around 25.7. SGC on AppWorld-C is 5.8. Several confidence intervals include zero, including AppWorld-C SGC and SWE-Bench. The paper should separate established gains from directional support more clearly.

  2. Table 14 reports roughly 24–28% semantic error for proxy scoring. Table 15 shows non-trivial calibration error. The theory depends on bounded entropy error. But the observed maximum error is around 1.75. It is unclear how tight the threshold rule remains in practice.

  3. Inference overhead is not fully resolved. SEER uses many more LLM calls than ACE. On Qwen3-8B it uses 57.4 calls versus 30.0. Wall-clock time is also higher than ACE.

  4. Generalization evidence is still narrow. SWE-Bench and WebArena are only tested with Qwen3 backbones. Cross-domain transfer of the evidence taxonomy and the extractor/curator is not systematically studied.

Questions for authors
  1. Fixed-budget comparison against ACE and ExpeL. Table 8 shows that SEER uses substantially more LLM calls than ACE (57.4 vs. 30.0 on Qwen3-8B) and higher wall-clock time than ACE. Please add a controlled comparison under a fixed total LLM-call budget and, separately, under a fixed wall-clock budget.

  2. Sensitivity of admission to proxy-scoring error. Table 14 reports 24–28% semantic error. Table 15 reports non-trivial calibration error. Admission depends on estimated marginal entropy reduction, not top-1 accuracy. Please add a analyse.

Reviewer_Ha27OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SEER is a training-free context-management method for interactive LLM agents. It selects evidence using predicted reductions in feedback uncertainty per token and periodically consolidates the retained context. The approach is motivated by a cost-aware Information Bottleneck formulation. Experiments on ExCyTIn-Bench and AppWorld, with additional benchmarks in the appendix, evaluate task performance and efficiency through budget-matched comparisons, ablations, and extensive diagnostics.

Critical strengths

S1. The ExCyTIn gains are clear: ACC improves by 8.4 and 9.4 points over the strongest baselines for the two Qwen sizes. The AppWorld-N comparisons also match total-token and wall-clock budgets, which helps address the extra computation used by SEER.

S2. The paper tests alternative selectors, taxonomy and prompt choices, heterogeneous module assignments, and intermediate-error propagation. These controls provide useful checks on the context-management pipeline and its sensitivity.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Equation 10 applies softmax to scores, but Appendix B.2 asks for probabilities that already sum to one. The paper should say which calculation is actually used, since this changes entropy and evidence selection. The absolute default tau is also needed to reproduce the method.

W2. I follow the motivation for the IB view, but the transition to the implemented objective needs more justification. Candidate contexts can change the action and feedback distribution, so the fixed-marginal-entropy assumption is not immediate. The stratified entropy–reward associations in Figure 4 are useful diagnostics, but do not causally validate this information-theoretic interpretation.

W3. The commercial-model extension uses GPT-4.1-nano (it is really old), so it does not yet establish whether SEER benefits stronger API agents with better long-context handling. Since evidence extraction, scoring, and curation all add model calls, a stronger-model comparison is important for assessing the practical value of the context-management pipeline.

Questions for authors

Q1. I may be missing a detail, but it is not clear to me how the scorer's output is converted into the distribution used for entropy. Could you give pseudocode or a seven-class example, including the absolute default tau, tuning split, probability/logit handling, and parsing fallbacks? Do Tables 4, 13, and 15 use that same distribution?

Q2. Under what joint distribution is the proxy marginal entropy independent of the context mapping when the mapping also changes the induced action? Could you give assumptions that justify the IB-to-action-conditioned objective transition, or explicitly present the operational entropy criterion as an empirically motivated surrogate?

Q3. How are the retrospective proxy distributions estimated, and do estimation errors change which evidence is admitted? Figure 4a derives step rewards from the episode-level RWD/T, while the horizon and difficulty stratifications remain observational. A matched-state comparison of alternative evidence choices and their downstream outcomes would help assess evidence utility. Please also explain how confidently predicted failures affect selection.

Q4. Does SEER still improve a representative strong API model on long-history tasks compared with the same model's standard history handling? Please use the same tools and context allowance, and include extraction, scoring, and curation in the reported cost and latency.

1 comment

Dear authors,

Thank you for the clarifications. I think the probability handling, threshold, and matched-state interventions address several concerns. Although the discussion deadline is approaching, two points remain important to me.

1. Added value for a strong API agent

In my reading, the practical question in Q4 remains open. I would appreciate any existing comparison of the same strong API agent using standard history handling versus SEER, with matched tools/context and all auxiliary calls included in cost and latency. This requires no RL training of a closed-source model. I understand why stronger models might benefit less, but I am still unsure what added value has been demonstrated for them. If untested, please state that gap and limit the applicability claims accordingly.

2. Revised theoretical scope

I would also appreciate pointers to the revised passages separating the reference-law equivalence from the deployed surrogate, and the local predicted-objective guarantee from task-success guarantees. Please keep online and retrospective entropy distinct. I think consistent revisions here would resolve much of my theoretical concern.

Reviewer_dt9VOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a training-free context management method, SEER, for LLM-based agents. The method extracts evidence (i.e., compact memory items) from agent-environment interactions and selectively retains items based on their estimated marginal reduction in the entropy of subsequent environment feedback, normalized by token cost. The authors motivate this approach using an Information Bottleneck (IB) formulation and evaluate it on several agentic benchmarks, reporting improvements over existing context management methods.

Critical strengths

The paper considers a practical problem of selecting useful information from long interaction histories of LLM agents. The proposed method is simple and does not require additional training. The experiments cover several benchmarks and backbone models, with various ablation studies and comparisons under matched inference budgets. In particular, the improvements on ExCyTIn-Bench (cybersecurity investigation via SQL) are substantial.

Critical weaknesses

Despite its simplicity and empirical performance, I have several concerns regarding its theoretical motivation, the choice of the evidence-selection criterion, and its broader applicability. My main concerns are as follows.

  1. (Motivation and framework) While I understand the motivation from the IB principle, I find its connection to the actual method somewhat loose. The proposed objective is essentially a trade-off between predicted entropy and context length, which seems reasonable as an intuitive heuristic. However, I am less convinced by the choice of the relevance variable. In particular, the authors replace the latent decision-relevant variable YtY_t with a proxy representing the categorical outcome of the next environment interaction, but it is unclear why this proxy should capture information relevant to optimal decision-making. Moreover, the theoretical analysis mainly characterizes the threshold-based selection rule with respect to the proposed surrogate objective, rather than establishing its connection to downstream decision quality. I therefore think the IB formulation provides a useful motivation, but the emphasis on its theoretical justification is somewhat overstated.

  2. (Evidence-selection criterion) Related to the last point, I am not entirely convinced that reducing uncertainty about the next environment feedback is a generally useful criterion for evidence selection. For example, a tool-execution outcome can be highly predictable without being particularly useful for completing the task. Also, since the hypothetical action changes depending on the candidate evidence set, the reduction in entropy may simply reflect a change to a more predictable action, rather than the usefulness of the additional evidence. It might be sensible under a certain assumption and the empirical results suggest that this criterion works well in the considered settings, but I think its underlying rationale deserves more discussion.

  3. (Generality and applicability) The method seems particularly suited to tasks involving structured tool executions, such as SQL queries and API calls, where the next environment feedback can be naturally categorized into a small number of outcomes. I wonder how well this idea extends to other types of reasoning tasks, such as general coding or mathematical reasoning, where the immediate outcome may not be a good indicator of progress toward the final goal. The relatively small improvements on SWE-Bench also raise some questions about broader applicability. I think the paper would benefit from a more explicit discussion of the settings in which the proposed criterion is expected to work well, as well as its potential limitations.

  4. (Presentation of empirical results) The abstract highlights an improvement of "up to 9.4 points," but it is difficult to interpret this number without knowing the benchmark, metric, and baseline. I would suggest reporting the actual performance figures for a representative setting instead. Also, while the improvements on ExCyTIn-Bench are substantial, some of the improvements on other benchmarks are relatively small, with confidence intervals including zero. I think the empirical claims could be presented with a bit more nuance.

Questions for authors

I have two high-level questions:

  1. What justifies using the categorical outcome of the next environment interaction as a proxy for the latent decision-relevant variable in the IB formulation? Is there any theoretical or empirical characterization of when this proxy is informative about downstream task performance?

  2. Since different candidate evidence sets can induce different hypothetical actions, how should we interpret their entropy differences as measuring the relevance of the evidence itself, rather than merely the predictability of different actions?


While the method demonstrates promising empirical results, I am not fully convinced by its information-theoretic justification or the generality of the proposed evidence-selection criterion. I think the paper would be more compelling if it were framed as a practically motivated method for context management in structured tool-use environments, rather than emphasizing a general IB-based framework for agentic reasoning. In particular, the authors could focus more on understanding when and why the proposed entropy-based criterion works well, while being more explicit about its limitations. With a more focused scope and appropriately qualified theoretical claims, I think the empirical contribution could stand on its own.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.