acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

When Should Control Move? Phase-Scoped Leadership for Embodied LLM Teams

Abstract

Embodied LLM teams must coordinate task dependencies while their members retain different observations and procedural memories. A task graph specifies what should happen, but not which agent should construct the next plan. We introduce phase-scoped dynamic leadership: agents exchange compact evidence, jointly select a coordinator and phase objective, execute a phase DAG, and replicate progress across coordination rounds. A locked-leader control preserves the same normal phase-planning loop. We formalize the distinction between sharing sufficient advice and accessing local context by transferring planning authority. We evaluate three-agent teams in Minecraft through an eleven-task, 330-run comparison and a 40-run leadership-trace evaluation. Free-form coordination is economical on simple collection, while locked leadership is the stronger structured default. On three tasks with asymmetric memories, Dynamic achieves 9/30 terminal successes versus Static's 1/30, at 1.55 times the mean LLM-call count. The trace evaluation records 4/20 versus 0/20 successes and directly observes leader changes in 8/20 Dynamic runs. Re-election often retains the same agent, and rotation alone does not ensure success. These findings support phase-scoped authority as a targeted coordination mechanism, while separating observed protocol behavior from causal claims about expertise alignment.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
multi-agent systems, large language model agents, embodied AI, multi-agent coordination, dynamic leadership, task planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_bX1jOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

this paper introduce phase-scoped dynamic leadership for embodied LLM teams: agents exchange compact evidence, jointly select a coordinator and phase objective, execute a phase DAG, and replicate progress across coordination rounds. the experiments demonstrated Dynamic achieves 9/30 terminal successes versus Static’s 1/30, at 1.55 times the mean LLM-call count. the paper demonstrated an explicit account of the information and cost conditions that motivate transferable authority the paper also provides a reproducible evaluation separating task-level outcomes, inference use, and actual leader changes, including all run summaries and all recorded leadership sequences.

Critical strengths

The comparison between static and dynamic coordination provides a useful perspective on the role of agent-specific information in multi-agent systems planning. Use the same LLM across both settings helps isolate the effect of coordinator assignment from differences in model capabilities. The phase based framework represents tasks as dependency graphs, provides a structured and interpretable approach to this problem.

Critical weaknesses

I am still not clear theoretically how to prove Dynamic outperforms static, because the static coordinator also has some information. There are limited methodology novelty. The paper compares static and dynamic coordinator assignment, but lack of theoretical support. The technical contribution is unclear. After reading the paper, I am not clear what new algorithms distinguishes this work from existing multi-agent systems. I think the research contribution isn't enough for top tier conferences.

Questions for authors

the notations make me confusing, for example, "l' in line 192 which says it's a incubator is different from the "l" in line 139 which says it's coordinator How does the proposed framework decide which agent has the most decision relevant information at different phases? Is there a quantitative measure of information sufficient enough to guide coordinator election? in table 4, both static and Dynamic success rate are pretty low, though dynamic is a little bit better than static. I am not convinced the proposed coordination mechanism is effective or reliable.

1 comment

Thank you. We do not claim that Dynamic theoretically dominates Static. The information-sufficiency result explicitly allows a fixed coordinator to perform equally well when shared advice contains the decision-relevant information. Any advantage of transferring authority must depend on additional useful local context and justify its cost.

The implemented election uses LLM judgments of candidate summaries and proposed phase objectives. It does not compute information gain or guarantee selection of the best-informed agent. We will clarify this distinction and use consistent notation for the incumbent and candidate coordinators.

The methodological distinction is joint phase-and-coordinator selection coupled to phase-local DAG authorship and progress continuity. We agree that low absolute success rates preclude a reliability claim; the evidence supports a conditional protocol comparison, not a guarantee that rotation causes success.

Reviewer_D72KOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies dynamic leadership in LLM multi-agent teams in Minecraft. Instead of keeping a fixed leader, agents vote to elect a leader for each phase based on their local procedural memories. The authors compare this dynamic leadership with a fixed-leader baseline and a free-form baseline. The results show that dynamic leadership is very expensive. The simple baseline works best on easy collection tasks, and the fixed leader works best on normal tasks. Dynamic leadership only shows marginal improvements on three custom tasks where the authors manually gave agents split memories, and even then the trace results are not statistically significant.

Critical strengths

The authors are transparent about their negative results, openly admitting that dynamic leadership performs worse than simple baselines in most tasks and costs significantly more calls.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Flawed Evaluation and Lack of Auditable Evidence. The experimental design and evaluation is unprofessional. The evaluation only relies on unblinded manual observation, putting the validity of the whole paper in concern. Besides, the experiment is a completely toy setup and have statistical weak results, making most results useless.

  2. AI-Heavy Writing and Wrong Focus. The paper spends too many pages documenting low-level framework code details, heartbeat timeouts, and protocol fields, while lacking high-level intuitions and explanations. It reads more like an engineering technical report than a main-track research paper.

Questions for authors

N/A

1 comment

Thank you for highlighting the evaluation and presentation limitations. We agree that unblinded human observation without retained terminal world states limits independent outcome auditing. Released summaries and leadership sequences reproduce the analysis, but cannot resolve that limitation.

We distinguish the 9/30 versus 1/30 task-suite result from the 4/20 versus 0/20 trace evaluation; the latter is not statistically significant. Neither isolates rotation from additional inference and failover. We also agree that the presentation should prioritize the scientific question and empirical findings, with protocol details serving reproducibility. Our supported claim is a limited, higher-cost protocol advantage in diagnostic settings, not general effectiveness.

Reviewer_gR1XOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper uses MineCraft as a testbed for studying multi-agent collaboration.

The paper has 3 organization styles:

  1. No Leader Baseline, where the agents are told to collaborate organically
  2. Static Locked Leader, where the agents hold an election at the start after which the leader stays static throughout the episode
  3. Dynamic, where there are frequent elections, where the agents select a new leader whenever they are done with one chunk of work and starting the next one

The paper tests these in four classes of tasks:

  1. single resource tasks
  2. independent resource tasks
  3. dependency chain tasks
  4. multistage tasks with split memories, where the agents have different memories (procedural knowledge, asymmetric information) and these different expertise is needed to complete the task at hand successfully

They find:

  1. Simple tasks: the no-leader baseline is about as successful as the others and far cheaper.
  2. Independent-resource and dependency-chain tasks: a static leader works best
  3. Split-memory tasks: Dynamic succeeds more often than Static
  4. Leadership logs: the leader actually changed in only 8 of 20 Dynamic runs
Critical strengths

S1. These days, there are a lot of papers that study multiagent collaboration in not so grounded setups. I really like how this paper grounds the multi-agent collaboration in minecraft where the simulated physical world presents a natively multi-agent collaboration setup.

S2. Considering the standards in the LLM multi-agent collaboration research, I would say this paper is above the standards in the field when we compare it to the recent works.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The tasks, especially Class D tasks are designed in a way that would set up the method for success.

W2. The proposed organization methods are designed in a shallow manner, where the methods are (1) no leader, (2) static leader, and (3) dynamic leader. It should be mathematically provably possible to understand which one of these is better in which type of tasks under which assumptions because the methods are very simple. In which case, a simple mathematical calculation can derive the findings of the paper. I believe experimental research is useful as far as it presents knowledge that fills a gap in the literature. I believe this paper comes short of doing that.

Questions for authors

Can you clarify how these results advance science?

  • what was previously unknown in the literature? what is the gap you identified?
  • what is the theoretical or empirical evidence that you provide to fill this gap?
1 comment

Thank you for asking us to clarify the scientific contribution. The question we target is whether the identity of a phase-DAG author matters when embodied agents share a model but retain different local contexts. Task decomposition and coordinator assignment are distinct decisions.

We agree that idealized calculations can identify conditions favoring each organization. Our analysis establishes one such boundary: sufficient shared advice removes the purely informational benefit of transferring authority. It does not predict whether an implemented LLM election selects useful context, whether coordination costs outweigh its benefit, or whether re-election actually changes the leader. Our experiments examine these questions and show that fixed leadership is generally stronger, while Dynamic records a narrower advantage in asymmetric-memory tasks.

Class D is intentionally diagnostic. All regimes receive the same per-agent memory assignments, but these constructed tasks do not establish broad generalization. We present the contribution as a conditional empirical investigation of planning authority, rather than a universally superior organization.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.