acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Stout: Structured Order-Aware Quantization Training for Large Language Models

Abstract

Layerwise quantization-aware training (QAT) reduces the training cost of large language models by optimizing one layer at a time. However, a fixed input-to-output order assigns adaptation by depth, without considering which layers can best recover from errors introduced by other layers. It can therefore leave layers with limited adaptation ability to handle errors after more capable layers have been frozen. We introduce Oats, Order-aware Adaptation Score, which estimates a layer’s potential recovery from other layers’ quantization errors. Our local analysis explains this recovery, and experiments show that Oats predicts it more effectively than own-layer sensitivity. Based on Oats, we propose Stout, Structured Order-Aware Quantization Training, a two-stage framework for efficient QAT. The first stage computes Oats through shared measurements and trains layers with the model’s output loss in ascending score order, preserving stronger adaptation opportunities for later. The second stage trains scales with fixed quantized weights using ScaleKernel, a fused backward kernel that avoids dense weight-gradient intermediates in global memory. On Qwen3.6-35B-A3B at 2bit, Stout improves LiveCodeBench pass@1 and the BFCL aggregate score by 0.87% and 2.68% over the development-selected ordering baseline. Compared with a matched compiled or fused baseline, ScaleKernel lowers second-stage training time and peak alloated GPU memory by 0.85% and 14.47%, respectively. Our code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/status/stout-613D

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large+Language+Model, Weight+Quantization, Quantization-aware+Training

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_SF8rOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Stout, a two-stage framework for efficient layerwise QAT. It introduces Oats, a curvature-aware score that estimates each layer's ability to recover from quantization errors and guides the training order. It also proposes ScaleKernel to reduce memory overhead during scale training. Experiments demonstrate improved quantization performance and memory efficiency.

Critical strengths

The paper is well-written and well-structured. The proposed method is supported by theoretical analysis and extensive experiments, including comparisons with different layer ordering strategies and quantization baselines.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The theoretical analysis does not fully justify the proposed ordering strategy. The derived recoverable loss measures the potential benefit of adapting an individual layer, but it does not necessarily guarantee that sorting layers by this score leads to a better overall QAT outcome, given the interactions between layers.

  2. The necessity of the proposed scoring metric is not fully established. Although the authors compare different curvature approximations and sensitivity-based ordering, it remains unclear whether simpler gradient-based metrics could achieve similar performance without estimating inverse Fisher information.

  3. The two proposed components are relatively independent. Oats improves the layerwise training order, while ScaleKernel optimizes the backward implementation of scale training. Their combination does not introduce a unified algorithmic contribution beyond integrating these two techniques.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the weaknesses.

Minor: The provided code seems not accessible.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer SF8r

We thank Reviewer SF8r for three precise conceptual objections, and we address each below.


W1: "The derived recoverable loss measures the potential benefit of adapting an individual layer, but it does not necessarily guarantee that sorting layers by this score leads to a better overall QAT outcome, given the interactions between layers."

A: We agree, and Apx. B.6 says so. It gives the exchange model that would be needed to justify sorting and shows that neither condition it requires follows from Theorem 1: a layer also leaves errors that later layers must absorb, and the score would additionally have to rank the residual fractions 1−ρi1-\rho_i. Ascending Oats is a schedule the experiments support; we do not derive it from the theorem.

The measurement does account for interactions in expectation. Proposition 1 shows that under complementary partitions E[Cl]\mathbb{E}[C_l] retains both the individual responses of the other layers and the norm of their combined response, so reinforcement and cancellation survive without forming an interaction matrix. Tab. 13 quantifies the residual: nonadditivity 0.104 at K=1K=1, with the sampled response at cosine 0.897 to the direct one.

The ordering ablation bears on the global question. Perturbing the Oats order by increasing rank distance gives, on Qwen at 2 bit:

Orderτb\tau_b with Oats ↑LCBBFCL
Oats ↑1.00075.7173.06
Scored on a different corpus0.93675.6772.96
Most divergent of five scoring draws0.87275.0173.16
Random permutations, mean of three≈ 073.7768.42

The outcome is unchanged down to τb≈0.87\tau_b \approx 0.87: LCB drifts by 0.70 pp and BFCL is flat, in fact 0.10 pp higher for the most divergent draw than for the default, which is well inside the seed spread. An arbitrary order loses most of the gain. We have no measurements between τb≈0.87\tau_b \approx 0.87 and ≈0\approx 0, so this locates no threshold; what it shows is that the result survives the perturbation an imperfect score actually produces and does not survive discarding the score.

The two directions make the same point. Ascending and descending Oats use identical per-layer scores and differ only in arrangement, and that arrangement is worth 4.91 pp BFCL (p<0.001p<0.001, three seeds), with held-out CE moving the same way (1.687 against 1.736). Ascending Oats also beats the two competing score-based orders, sensitivity by 3.83 pp and reference potential by 2.39 pp.


W2: "It remains unclear whether simpler gradient-based metrics could achieve similar performance without estimating inverse Fisher information."

A: Apx. C.3 identifies the development-selected ordering baseline as the raw external response, which is the same Δg~\Delta\tilde{g} without curvature weighting. Removing the inverse Fisher costs 0.87 pp LCB and 2.68 pp BFCL end to end, and 0.15 Kendall τ\tau in predicting measured recovery.

Scoreτb\tau_b with measured recovery, full budgetBFCL gain over forward
Own-layer sensitivity−0.07+1.38
Potential difference0.71+0.81
Raw external response0.71+2.53
Reference potential0.79+2.82
Oats0.86+5.21

The curvature term is also cheap. It is one of the four scoring traversals in Eq. (46), about 0.2 h of an 11.07 h pipeline, estimated by ordinary backward passes on labels sampled from the model (Lemma 1) and stored as one value per quantization group, so applying its inverse is a division rather than a matrix inversion. Tab. 14 shows the group-mean form differs from the full diagonal by 3.2%.

Both halves are needed for the reason Theorem 1 gives: the gradient response measures how much adaptation the other layers' errors demand of a layer, and the curvature determines how much of that demand the layer can meet. A layer with a large response but stiff curvature cannot use it. The two one-sided scores show this directly. Own-layer sensitivity uses curvature without the cross-layer response and is uninformative at −0.07-0.07; the raw response uses the response without curvature and reaches 0.71; combining them reaches 0.86.


W3: "The two proposed components are relatively independent. Oats improves the layerwise training order, while ScaleKernel optimizes the backward implementation of scale training. Their combination does not introduce a unified algorithmic contribution."

A: The independence is a verified design property, and it is what makes the attribution credible. There is no interaction, which is what allows the accuracy to be attributed to Oats and the memory to the kernel. It also means either component can be adopted alone.


Minor: "The provided code seems not accessible."

A: We apologise for this, We correct the link in the abstract to https://anonymous.4open.science/r/stout-613D/readme.md.

Reviewer_ouhmOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the ordering of layer training in the first stage of two-stage layerwise quantization-aware training (QAT). Conventional methods train layers in a fixed input-to-output depth order; the authors argue that this ignores differences in each layer's ability to compensate for quantization errors introduced by other layers. The paper proposes Oats, which quantifies "how much loss a layer can recover from other layers' quantization errors" via shared gradient measurements under complementary partitions plus a pseudo-label Fisher diagonal curvature estimate. Building on this, Stout performs stage-one layerwise CE training in ascending Oats order, and introduces ScaleKernel, a fused backward kernel that reduces weight-gradient tiles to groupwise scale gradients on chip, avoiding dense intermediates in global memory.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-motivated and practically relevant problem. Layer ordering is an under-explored degree of freedom in layerwise QAT. The paper frames it as a measurable, optimizable quantity, and argues causality through clean ablations (ascending vs. descending, the depth-matched arm). The experimental design is careful.
  2. Efficient measurement design. Scoring requires only 4 data traversals to cover all layers, accounting for 7.42% of total time, and the equal-total-time comparison (Tab. 3) shows the ordering benefit covers this cost.
  3. Clean attribution. Tab. 2 decouples the accuracy gain (Oats) from the system gain (ScaleKernel); Tab. 23 provides honest significance analysis over three seeds; Appendix C.9 deliberately stratifies receivers by depth and adds a depth-matched ordering arm to disentangle Oats from depth — this proactive deconstruction of the authors' own signal is commendable.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Thin theoretical guarantees; the central claim rests mostly on empirics. Theorem 1 is a quadratic identity whose applicability to non-convex QAT (STE + AdamW) relies on several untested local assumptions; the unequal-curvature correction (B.3) and the scalar sorting model (B.6) are explicitly offered as "intuition only." Meanwhile, the differences among ordering arms in Fig. 5 are of the same magnitude as training-seed noise in Tab. 23. The ordering ablation itself lacks multi-seed repetitions. Given that the authors themselves stress that a 0.22 LCB gap is not significant, the single-run comparison of six ordering arms in Fig. 5 is statistically under-supported. I ask for multi-seed results.
  2. The entanglement between Oats and depth is not fully resolved. The depth-matched arm retains only 1.40 of the 2.59 points, meaning roughly half the gain comes from moving layers across depth bands. Moreover, the depth-stratified recovery measurement in C.9 uses only 24 receivers on a single model at a single bitwidth. A free and simpler alternative — reverse depth order — performs almost identically to forward depth order in Fig. 5 (72.8 vs. 73.3), which weakens the case that one must measure Oats: for a practitioner, whether the residual gain justifies the scoring cost is not quantified convincingly.
  3. The ScaleKernel contribution is questionable as a standalone contribution. A 0.85% runtime reduction is negligible in systems terms (the authors concede it is bounded by the GEMM itself); the 14.47% memory saving is measured against a "fastest compatible fused reference" whose relationship to the custom-epilogue route in CUTLASS is unclear. If the underlying idea already appears in CUTLASS tutorials, the kernel is an adaptation rather than a new method; the paper should clarify the difference from existing fusion primitives. System measurements also cover only Qwen at 2bit, limiting generalizability.
  4. The ordering signal drifts during training but is never exploited. Fig. 10 shows agreement between the initial order and re-ranked remaining layers drops to ~0.61 as training progresses; Tab. 15's refresh experiment costs 3.25 extra hours for essentially zero quality difference (76.03 vs. 76.09). This negative result actually raises a sharper question: if the static initial score is suboptimal and refresh is too expensive, is the Oats ordering gain merely coincidental alignment with the early training state? The paper offers no quantitative explanation for why an ordering measured in the initial RTN environment transfers to the mixed trained/frozen environment (Tab. 14 reports a substantial Fisher change of 0.174).
  5. Insufficient experimental coverage. (a) Llama-3.1-8B is not evaluated at 4bit and has no system measurements, undercutting the "two models" framing; (b) The ordering gain depends on "sufficient residual error" — the paper's own mechanism predicts the gain should shrink as bitwidth increases, and the 1.66–2.93 point gains on QTIP support this, yet the ordering ablation at 4bit is entirely missing, which is precisely the setting deployments care about.
Questions for authors

See Weakness 4 &5, answering the questions there.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer ouhm (1/3)

We thank Reviewer ouhm for a precise and well-targeted review, and we are glad they found the experimental design careful and the attribution clean. We address each weakness below and report the resulting changes to the manuscript.


W1.1: "Theorem 1 is a quadratic identity whose applicability to non-convex QAT (STE + AdamW) relies on several untested local assumptions; the unequal-curvature correction (B.3) and the scalar sorting model (B.6) are explicitly offered as 'intuition only.'"

A: We agree that the analysis motivates Oats rather than proving a globally optimal ordering for non-convex QAT, and Apx. B.6 says so. What we can establish is that the score is predictive and that the ordering it induces works at finite budget. In Apx. C.8, Oats reaches a partial rank correlation of 0.954 with measured recovery after controlling for layer depth, against 0.484 for depth alone, so its predictive power is not a restatement of depth. In the ordering ablation, ascending Oats beats depth order by 2.59 pp LCB and 5.21 pp BFCL. The theory selects the direction; the experiments test it.


W1.2: "The differences among ordering arms in Fig. 5 are of the same magnitude as training-seed noise in Tab. 23. The ordering ablation itself lacks multi-seed repetitions. I ask for multi-seed results."

A: The ordering ablation in Fig. 5 was already run with three independent training seeds (0/1/2) per arm, not a single run, as Apx. C.9 describes; the error bars in Fig. 5 are that standard deviation. The values were not printed, so we tabulate mean ± Std here.

OrderingLCBBFCL
Forward (depth ↑)73.12 ± 0.3067.85 ± 0.12
Reverse73.46 ± 0.3168.56 ± 0.60
Sensitivity73.47 ± 0.7969.23 ± 0.50
Raw external response74.84 ± 0.9570.38 ± 0.11
Reference potential74.20 ± 1.1070.67 ± 0.05
Oats (depth-matched)74.52 ± 1.3372.39 ± 0.13
Oats ↓72.88 ± 1.0268.15 ± 0.33
Oats ↑75.71 ± 0.3073.06 ± 0.11

Ascending Oats has the highest mean on both metrics. On BFCL it beats every other arm by at least 2.39 pp, its margin over reference potential (t=34.3t=34.3, p<10−4p<10^{-4}), which survives Bonferroni correction over every arm-metric comparison in the ablation.

On LCB the arms are not separable at three seeds: Oats ↑ at 75.71 ± 0.30 does exceed forward at 73.12 ± 0.30, but raw external response reaches 74.84 ± 0.95 and a Welch test against it gives t=1.51t=1.51, p=0.25p=0.25. We therefore rest the ordering claim on BFCL and state in Sec. 4.2 that LCB does not separate at this sample size.

The direction of the score also matters: on LCB, the metric of Fig. 5, descending Oats is the worst arm in the table, so reversing a measured score is worse than the depth order it replaces.


W2: "The entanglement between Oats and depth is not fully resolved… A free and simpler alternative — reverse depth order — performs almost identically to forward depth order, which weakens the case that one must measure Oats; whether the residual gain justifies the scoring cost is not quantified convincingly."

A: Depth alone does not produce the gain. Forward order is ascending depth, so the entire gap between Oats ↑ and forward is already a gap over depth sorting. Forward and reverse score about the same as the random permutations, so depth carries little ordering signal in either direction and reverse is no substitute for a measured score. Every zero-cost order stays well below Oats ↑. We also report three random permutations for comparison.

OrderingScoring (h)LCBBFCL
Forward (depth ↑)073.12 ± 0.3067.85 ± 0.12
Reverse073.46 ± 0.3168.56 ± 0.60
Random permutation 1073.90 ± 0.8067.47 ± 0.19
Random permutation 2073.43 ± 1.5869.39 ± 0.15
Random permutation 3073.98 ± 0.6268.39 ± 0.38
Oats (depth-matched)0.8874.52 ± 1.3372.39 ± 0.13
Oats ↑0.8475.71 ± 0.3073.06 ± 0.11

The depth-matched arm keeps every layer inside its original depth band and still gains 3.00 pp BFCL over the best zero-cost order. Ordering clearly matters, depth cannot find a good one, and a measured score can.

On cost, the 0.84 h of scoring is paid once per pipeline, about 7% of its total time and under one tenth of a single additional training seed (8.6 h of stage one). It buys 3.67 pp BFCL and 1.73 pp LCB over the best zero-cost order chosen in hindsight.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer ouhm (2/3)

W3.1: "The ScaleKernel contribution is questionable as a standalone contribution. A 0.85% runtime reduction is negligible… the 14.47% memory saving is measured against a 'fastest compatible fused reference' whose relationship to the custom-epilogue route in CUTLASS is unclear."

A: ScaleKernel address a significant issue in Scale-only training methods, which train <1% parameters, yet eager and compiled autograd both materialise a full PP-element weight-gradient buffer before reducing it to the P/128P/128 scale gradients. ScaleKernel reduces the weight-gradient tiles on chip and writes only dsds, making backward memory proportional to the parameters actually trained. The reference below is a Triton 3.0.0 kernel that fuses dequantization and the scale factor into the epilogue but still materialises the dense dWdW.

BackendStage-2 time (h)Peak allocated (GiB)
Eager autograd2.508262.9642
TorchInductor compiled1.751242.1651
Fused Triton 3.0.0 reference1.685642.2025
ScaleKernel1.671236.0966

Against eager autograd ScaleKernel cuts stage-two time by 33.4% and peak memory by 42.7%; against TorchInductor, 4.6% and 14.4%; against the fused reference, 0.85% and 14.47%. We claim memory, not runtime, and remove the 0.85% from the abstract.

On CUTLASS: the custom-epilogue mechanism is standard and we do not claim it. What is specific is that the reduction is a weighted group-sum against frozen integer codes unpacked from uint32 inside the kernel (Apx. B.10, Alg. 2), that tiles align to complete quantization groups so each writes final dsds without atomics or a second pass, and that only the weight-gradient GEMM is fused because dX=dYW^⊤dX = dY\hat{W}^\top must stay exact. All three baselines in Tab. 10 materialise the dense dWdW, so this instantiation is not already available. Gradient error is at or below the fused reference and quality is unchanged at −0.014-0.014 pp LCB (Tab. 19, Tab. 2). Sec. 3.4 now states this.


W3.2: "System measurements also cover only Qwen at 2bit, limiting generalizability."

A: We add Qwen 4 bit to Tab. 10.

BitsBackendStage-2 time (h)Peak allocated (GiB)
2Fused Triton reference1.685642.2025
2ScaleKernel1.671236.0966
4Fused Triton reference1.649551.3934
4ScaleKernel1.626345.0364

ScaleKernel reduces peak memory by 14.47% at 2 bit and 12.37% at 4 bit, stage-two time by 0.85% and 1.41%, and step latency by 0.83% and 1.47%.


W4: "The ordering signal drifts during training but is never exploited… is the Oats ordering gain merely coincidental alignment with the early training state? The paper offers no quantitative explanation for why an ordering measured in the initial RTN environment transfers to the mixed trained/frozen environment."

A: The gain is not coincidental alignment with the early training state. Ascending and descending Oats use the same score at the same cost, and reversing the direction costs 4.91 pp BFCL (t=24.4t=24.4, p<0.001p<0.001, Welch, n=3n=3), while descending sits within noise of forward (+0.30 pp, p=0.25p=0.25). A score that happened to align with the early state would not carry a penalty of that size for being reversed.

Transfer is already measured. The ranking computed in the initial RTN environment predicts the stage it governs: end-of-stage-one LCB, measured at the same seeds but never reported per arm, gives ascending Oats +1.95 pp over forward (t=5.9t=5.9, p=0.02p=0.02) and descending −0.80-0.80 pp. Tab. 12 shows the same at the level of recovery, where the initial-environment score still predicts recovery after full-budget adaptation (τb=0.86\tau_b=0.86), and Tab. 24 shows the gain surviving replacement of the quantizer entirely (+2.46, +1.66 and +2.33 pp LCB), which an order matched to one early training state would not.

The drift in Fig. 10 is largely an artifact of a shrinking support. It is computed over unvisited layers only, so the support falls from 40 layers to 10; by the 10-left point, 30 of 40 placements are already fixed, and τb\tau_b over 10 remaining layers of similar score is unstable by construction. What drifts late is the order within the high-score tail, not which layers are in it, and membership is what the schedule decides. Tab. 14 is the same story: 0.174 is a mean relative change in the Fisher diagonal, and it moves the score by only −0.065-0.065, so by Eq. (21) a perturbation of this size rescales scores far more than it reorders them.

On the refresh experiment, Apx. C.6 already notes that a small mean difference does not establish equivalence, and we now quantify it: at the reported standard deviations with n=3n=3, the smallest detectable difference is 0.59 pp LCB at α=0.05\alpha=0.05 and 0.77 pp at 80% power. The comparison also holds total time fixed at 14.50 h, so refresh does not add 3.25 h, it spends 2.41 h more on scoring and correspondingly less on training.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer ouhm (3/3)

W5.(a): "Llama-3.1-8B is not evaluated at 4bit and has no system measurements, undercutting the 'two models' framing."

A: The Llama 4-bit quality results exist and were omitted from the submission. We add them, and Apx. C.1 is updated accordingly.

Llama-3.1-8B, 4 bitLCBBFCL
BF1615.9230.21
RTN13.5827.45
GPTQ13.3927.52
Full QAT14.1527.20
QuIP#13.7427.05
QTIP15.3526.73
EfficientQAT14.4027.71
CE-QAT14.9327.82
Stout15.8828.25

Stout is the strongest quantized result on both metrics and the only one that comes close to the BF16 reference, as on Qwen at 4 bit. LC-QAT is the one baseline we do not have at 4 bit, on either model. We also add the stage-two backend measurements on Llama, which the submission did not report:

Llama-3.1-8B, 2 bitStage-2 time (h)Peak allocated (GiB)
Fused Triton reference3.2512.51
ScaleKernel3.2610.36

Peak memory falls 17.2%, while stage-two time is unchanged. The dense model therefore shows the same pattern as the MoE and a slightly larger memory saving, which is what the claim predicts: the kernel removes a buffer, not arithmetic.


W5.(b): "The ordering gain depends on 'sufficient residual error' — the paper's own mechanism predicts the gain should shrink as bitwidth increases… yet the ordering ablation at 4bit is entirely missing, which is precisely the setting deployments care about."

A: At 4 bit the model starts closer to BF16, so our mechanism predicts a smaller gain and the paper demonstrates ordering at 2 bit. We have now run the ablation at 4 bit with the same four arms.

Qwen, 4 bitLCBBFCL
Forward (depth ↑)80.51 ± 0.8474.81 ± 0.46
Random permutation80.23 ± 1.3575.17 ± 0.71
Oats ↓79.43 ± 0.2376.55 ± 0.31
Oats ↑81.53 ± 0.3177.26 ± 0.51

Oats ↑ is best on both metrics. On BFCL the gain over forward is +2.45 pp (p=0.004p=0.004, Welch, n=3n=3), about half the 2-bit gain of +5.21, as the mechanism predicts. On LCB the +1.02 pp gain does not separate at three seeds (p=0.16p=0.16). Descending Oats also moves: on BFCL it rises above forward, so the premium for the ascending direction falls from +4.91 pp at 2 bit to +0.71 pp here, while the premium for using the score at all survives — with little residual error left, which layers are identified matters more than where they are placed. On LCB descending Oats stays last.

Reviewer_38HTOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Stout (Structured Order-Aware Quantization Training), a two-stage framework for improving the accuracy and efficiency of layerwise quantization-aware training (QAT) for large language models.

The key contribution is Oats (Order-aware Adaptation Score), which estimates a layer's ability to compensate for quantization errors introduced by other layers. Based on a local quadratic recovery analysis and efficient gradient measurements, Stout trains layers in ascending Oats order, preserving more adaptable layers for later optimization.

The second contribution, ScaleKernel, is a fused backward kernel that reduces scale gradients on chip without storing dense weight-gradient intermediates.

Critical strengths

S1. A well-motivated and practically important problem. The paper identifies training order as an overlooked factor in layerwise QAT. Its observation that later-trained layers must compensate for previously introduced quantization errors provides a clear motivation for adaptation-aware scheduling.

S2. A theoretically motivated and computationally practical approach. Oats connects cross-layer gradient responses with recoverable loss through a curvature-weighted formulation. Complementary layer partitions and diagonal Fisher approximation make the score practical without separately evaluating every pair of interacting layers.

S3. Convincing ordering ablations and recovery analysis. The paper compares Oats against forward, reverse, sensitivity-based, and other ordering strategies. Controlled recovery experiments, depth-stratified comparisons, and quantizer-transfer experiments provide meaningful evidence that Oats captures information beyond simple layer depth or sensitivity.

S4. Strong evaluation on challenging low-bit LLM tasks. Experiments cover a large mixture-of-experts model and a dense model, with comparisons against multiple PTQ and QAT baselines. Coding and tool-use benchmarks are particularly relevant because aggressive quantization can substantially degrade these capabilities.

S5. Useful systems contribution with appropriate ablations. ScaleKernel addresses unnecessary dense gradient materialization during scale training. The paper separates ordering-related accuracy improvements from kernel-related memory savings, and compares the kernel against eager, compiled, and fused implementations.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The theoretical analysis relies on restrictive approximations. Sections 3.1–3.2; Equations 6–11; Appendix B. The recovery formulation assumes locally quadratic losses with shared positive-definite curvature, whereas practical QAT uses discrete quantization and approximate gradients. Oats further replaces the ideal gradient response and curvature with complementary-partition measurements and diagonal Fisher estimates. Although empirical correlations support this approximation, the connection between the theoretical recovery criterion and actual optimization remains incomplete.

W2. The effectiveness and generalizability of Oats remain insufficiently established. Sections 3.2–3.3; Appendices C.5, C.9, and C.10. Oats is computed once using only 64 examples and a single complementary partition. Its depth-controlled recovery analysis is limited to 24 receiving layers from one model and bit width. Although the paper provides useful robustness experiments, the reliability of this fixed ordering across different architectures, training datasets, and quantization configurations remains uncertain.

W3. Performance improvements are not uniformly significant or consistent. Section 4.2; Appendix C.3; Table 23. Stout does not outperform competing methods on every task, leading on 22 of 33 reported task columns. More importantly, the three-seed comparison on Qwen at 2-bit shows that its LiveCodeBench advantage over LC-QAT is not statistically significant (p = 0.135). The paper appropriately acknowledges this limitation, but stronger evidence is needed to establish a consistent advantage over the best-performing baselines.

Questions for authors

Q1. Theoretical validity of Oats How accurately does the curvature-weighted Oats score approximate actual recoverable loss when the quadratic and shared-curvature assumptions are violated? Can the authors provide additional evidence connecting the approximate score to finite-step QAT dynamics?

Q2. Robustness of the ordering criterion How stable is the Oats ranking across different scoring datasets, random seeds, model architectures, and quantization bit widths? Does the ranking remain effective when evaluated beyond the original 64-example scoring subset?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer38HT (1/2)

We thank Reviewer 38HT for a careful review, and we are glad they found the problem well motivated, the ordering ablations convincing, and the separation of accuracy and systems contributions useful.


W1 & Q1: "The recovery formulation assumes locally quadratic losses with shared positive-definite curvature, whereas practical QAT uses discrete quantization and approximate gradients… How accurately does the curvature-weighted Oats score approximate actual recoverable loss when these assumptions are violated?"

A: We agree the quadratic assumptions do not hold exactly under QAT, and the paper states this in B.2, B.3, B.5 and B.7 rather than claiming otherwise. What Theorem 1 supplies is the form of the score, a gradient response weighted by inverse curvature, and Eq. (20) extends it to a single finite preconditioned step. Whether that form predicts real recovery is a separate question, and we measure it.

Fig. 6 and Tab. 12 measure recovery from actual finite-budget AdamW training with discrete quantization and STE, not from the quadratic model. Oats correlates with the measured recovered CE at ρ=0.95\rho = 0.95, and at Kendall τ\tau = 0.89, 0.71 and 0.86 across the short, medium and full budgets. On the 24 depth-stratified receivers it reaches ρ=0.963\rho = 0.963, and 0.954 after partialling out depth. Own-layer sensitivity, which rests on the same assumptions, scores between −0.11-0.11 and −0.07-0.07. The score is used ordinally, so rank preservation is what the algorithm requires.

We also measure each approximation separately. Removing the curvature weighting costs 0.21 and 0.15 Kendall τ\tau at the short and full budgets (Tab. 12), and 2.68 pp BFCL end to end. Replacing the full Fisher diagonal by group means perturbs the curvature by 3.2%, and a state-matched Fisher differs from the shared one by 0.174 in mean relative terms while moving the score by only −0.065-0.065 (Tab. 14). Reversing the score costs 4.91 pp BFCL (p<0.001p<0.001, three seeds), which would not happen if the approximations had reduced it to noise.

The correlations above are ordinal, so we also check the score's calibration against the quantity it is meant to approximate. For each receiver we project its weights onto a random low-dimensional subspace where the curvature can be formed exactly by Hessian-vector products, compute C∗=12Δg⊤H−1ΔgC^* = \tfrac{1}{2}\Delta g^\top H^{-1} \Delta g exactly within that subspace, and compare it against the Oats score restricted to the same subspace. Both are evaluated on the same model state, which isolates the error introduced by the diagonal-Fisher and partition approximations. These are agreement statistics, not a worst-case bound, and they do not measure error against observed finite-budget recovery, which is what Fig. 6 and Tab. 12 cover.

Projected-subspace check, Qwen 2 bit, 24 receiversValue
Rank correlation between Oats and exact C∗C^*0.91
Calibration slope, log⁡COats\log C_{\text{Oats}} on log⁡C∗\log C^*0.93
Median ratio COats/C∗C_{\text{Oats}} / C^*1.12

W3: "Stout does not outperform competing methods on every task, leading on 22 of 33 reported task columns… the three-seed comparison shows that its LiveCodeBench advantage over LC-QAT is not statistically significant (p = 0.135)."

A: We do not claim an LCB advantage over LC-QAT, and C.10 already states this. The claims we do make on Qwen at 2 bit are separated at three seeds:

Qwen 2 bit, three seedsLCBBFCLLM Eval
Stout − CE-QAT+1.78 (p<0.001p<0.001)+5.10 (p<0.001p<0.001)+1.74 (p<0.001p<0.001)
Stout − LC-QAT+0.21 (p=0.135p=0.135)+1.21 (p<0.001p<0.001)+0.25 (p=0.007p=0.007)

CE-QAT is the comparison that isolates the contribution, since it shares our checkpoint, quantizer, training data and update budget and differs only in the layer order. LC-QAT is a native-format baseline carrying its own quantizer and recipe (§4.1).

Oats also composes with LC-QAT rather than competing with it. Applying the ascending Oats order inside the LC-QAT codebook improves that method by +1.66 pp LCB and +2.85 pp BFCL over its own forward-order run (Tab. 24). On Llama at 2 bit, Stout leads LC-QAT by +1.41 LCB, +2.34 BFCL and +2.95 LM Eval; on Qwen at 4 bit it leads every baseline on all three (Tab. 1).

On the 22 of 33 columns, a sign test against an equal-performance null gives one-sided p=0.040p = 0.040; we report this as descriptive, since the 33 columns span shared models and bit widths and are not independent trials. C.3 reports where the eleven losses fall rather than aggregating them away. They concentrate on tasks where quantization leaves little residual error for an order to redistribute, and the method ahead is always another trained or native-format baseline rather than a training-free one.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to the reviewer38HT (2/2)

W2 & Q2: "Oats is computed once using only 64 examples and a single complementary partition… How stable is the ranking across different scoring datasets, random seeds, model architectures, and quantization bit widths?"

A: 64 examples and K=1K=1 are where the ranking saturates rather than a budget we settled for. Tab. 20 sweeps each estimator factor separately: 32 examples reach τb=0.778\tau_b = 0.778, 64 reach 0.983, and 128 do not improve on 64 (0.972) at twice the cost. Damping and curvature samples behave the same way, with the defaults at the top of their sweeps.

Generalization across quantizers is already measured. Tab. 24 applies the Oats order inside three quantizers, each against its own forward-order baseline, with gains of +2.46, +1.66 and +2.33 pp LCB. Across architectures, Stout leads every quantized baseline on LCB, BFCL and the LM Eval average on both the 40-block MoE and the 32-block dense model (Tab. 6, Tab. 7).

What the submission does not separate is the scoring data from the ranking it produces, and we add that:

Scoring configurationRank agreement τb\tau_b with the default order
32 examples0.778
64 examples0.983
128 examples0.972
Five independent 64-example draws, worst pair0.872
64 examples from a different corpus0.936
Score computed at 4 bit rather than 2 bit0.836

Rank agreement is only a proxy, so we also train end to end from the most divergent of these orders:

Order used for stage oneLCBBFCL
Default Oats ↑75.7173.06
Most divergent alternative scoring draw75.0173.16
Order scored on a different corpus75.6772.96

On the bit-width axis we have now run the ordering ablation at 4 bit, at three seeds:

Qwen, 4 bitLCBBFCL
Forward (depth ↑)80.51 ± 0.8474.81 ± 0.46
Random permutation80.23 ± 1.3575.17 ± 0.71
Oats ↓79.43 ± 0.2376.55 ± 0.31
Oats ↑81.53 ± 0.3177.26 ± 0.51

Oats ↑ is best on both metrics. The BFCL gain over forward is +2.45 pp (p=0.004p=0.004), about half the 2-bit gain of +5.21, which is what our mechanism predicts once less residual error remains to redistribute; the +1.02 pp LCB gain does not separate at three seeds (p=0.16p=0.16).

On the architecture axis we have now run the same ablation on Llama-3.1-8B at 2 bit, with a random permutation as the noise reference. Forward order is the CE-QAT row of Tab. 1 and ascending Oats is the Stout row.

Llama-3.1-8B, 2 bitLCBBFCL
Forward (depth ↑)6.66 ± 1.8215.20 ± 1.61
Random permutation5.61 ± 1.2516.89 ± 1.99
Oats ↑9.00 ± 0.9120.38 ± 1.25

The gain transfers to the dense model almost unchanged: +2.34 pp LCB and +5.18 pp BFCL over forward, against +2.59 and +5.21 on Qwen at 2 bit. BFCL separates (p=0.013p=0.013) and LCB does not (p=0.142p=0.142), matching Qwen at 4 bit; at Qwen 2 bit both metrics separate. Against the random permutation the split reverses, LCB separating (p=0.023p=0.023) and BFCL not (p=0.073p=0.073), so at three seeds the dense model supports the ordering claim on BFCL against forward and on LCB against an arbitrary order, not on every pairing. Run-to-run spread is wider here than on Qwen, which is expected at 2 bit on a dense model whose BF16 LCB is only 15.92.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank all reviewers for their time, and are glad they found the problem "well-motivated and practically important" (38HT), the paper "well-written and well-structured" (SF8r), and the experimental design "careful" (ouhm).

The reach of the theory was the shared concern. We now state plainly that the local analysis motivates the ascending order rather than proving it optimal, and we also restate ScaleKernel as a memory rather than a runtime contribution, and fixed the code link. All revisions are in blue.

We respond to each reviewer below.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.