- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes QuPA-StickerGen, a framework for personalized sticker generation that uses the user’s sticker usage history as a signal of visual preference and the textual query as a direct signal of semantic intent, instead of a retrieved reference sticker. Training stickers are grouped into style clusters with CSD embeddings and VLM-based filtering, and one LoRA adapter is trained per cluster. A query-based style distribution (from semantically similar training queries) and a history-based style distribution (with temporal decay) are fused according to query confidence, and the top adapters are composed for generation. The paper also introduces StickerGen, built by linking U-Sticker and StickerQueries, and motivates the formulation with a preliminary study comparing History + Query, History + Reference, and History + Query + Reference. The method is evaluated on StickerGen and WXChallenge with SDXL and FLUX against generation, retrieval, and LLM-pipeline baselines, together with a human evaluation.
Critical strengths
-
StickerGen combines user sticker usage histories and textual queries with ground-truth stickers in one public dataset, which existing public sticker datasets do not provide together (Section 2.3). This could be a useful resource for personalized sticker generation.
-
Using the textual query directly as the semantic signal, instead of a retrieved reference sticker, is a reasonable direction, and the human evaluation shows a preference for the proposed method in query alignment (45.3% vs. 33.3% chance level).
Critical weaknesses
- The ablation does not support the main claim that jointly modeling the query and the history improves generation. In Table 5, History + Query and History only are nearly identical in Overall score (StickerGen: .4258 vs. .4250 with SDXL, .4054 vs. .4044 with FLUX), and on WXChallenge with SDXL, History only is higher (.3679 vs. .3659). The semantic scores of Query only and History only are also similar (e.g., .1735 vs. .1725 on WXChallenge with SDXL). In addition, the Overall scores in the WXChallenge columns do not match the average of Style and Semantic (e.g., History only with SDXL: Style .3952 and Semantic .1725, but Overall .3679), while they do match in the StickerGen columns. This makes it difficult to determine how the Overall scores are computed and whether the query contributes to the reported gains.
- The preliminary study in Section 4, which is the basis for formulating the task as History + Query (Section 1, first contribution), has prompts that do not match its settings. In Appendix B.2, the History + Reference prompt includes the query (“The search query is: {query}” and “reflects the query {query}”), while the History + Query + Reference prompt does not include the query. It is therefore unclear which inputs each setting in Table 2 actually received, which makes it difficult to rely on the conclusion that the retrieved reference may introduce noise.
Questions for authors
- (Clarification) How are the Overall scores in Table 5 computed, and why do the WXChallenge columns not match the average of Style and Semantic?
- (Clarification) Which inputs did each setting in Table 2 receive? Are the prompts for History + Reference and History + Query + Reference in Appendix B.2 swapped, or were the experiments run with these prompts?
We sincerely thank the reviewers for their time and constructive feedback. We appreciate their valuable insights and will continue to refine and strengthen our work.