- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The core innovation of this paper lies in proposing a method that simultaneously models the dependencies among lag nodes, between lag and exogenous nodes, and among exogenous nodes. By integrating TMFG topology construction and LoGo partial correlation inference, the proposed framework demonstrates strong forecasting performance across multiple datasets.
Critical strengths
The problem addressed by the authors represents a valid and worthwhile research direction.
Critical weaknesses
(1) Relegating all mathematical formulations in Section 3 (Methodology) to the appendix is highly unconventional for standard academic writing. Similarly, moving all experimental results (tables) and visualizations (figures) from Sections 4 and 5 entirely to the appendix is strongly discouraged. This structural flaw severely hampers the readability of the manuscript and constitutes the primary reason for my rejection recommendation. I believe this significantly violates standard ICLR submission guidelines regarding the proper division of content between the main text and the appendix.
(2) The paper fails to provide sufficient in-depth experimental analysis or visualizations to demonstrate the actual effectiveness of the proposed modeling approach for mixed temporal and exogenous dependencies. This critical omission significantly weakens the paper's motivation and undermines its claimed novelty.
(3) The mathematical formulas presented in Figure 1 are cluttered and do not conform to standard academic formatting conventions. The authors are strongly advised to carefully refine and reformat this figure.
(4) The abstract fails to effectively highlight the core novelty of the research. Additionally, the use of abbreviations is non-standard. For instance, in the sentence “It further applies TMFG sparse topology construction and LoGo partial correlation inference to extract compact structural features,” the acronyms (TMFG and LoGo) are introduced without their full expansions. Furthermore, the abstract lacks a clear explanation of the underlying purpose and significance of applying these specific techniques.
Questions for authors
no further questions