acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Repo2Skill-Evo: Repository Skills Go Stale in Silence

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents increasingly operate over evolving software repositories, where success depends on repository-specific procedural knowledge: which APIs to call, which scripts to run, and which conventions the current release expects. Agent skills externalize this knowledge into reusable units, and prior work shows that they can improve agent performance. What remains unclear is whether that improvement is durable. The same version specificity that makes a skill useful also makes it fragile: after a release, it may become stale without raising any explicit signal while continuing to provide obsolete guidance. Externalizing knowledge into a skill can therefore make its decay invisible. We study whether agents can keep this externalized knowledge current. Repo2Skill-Evo casts each release transition as a skill-maintenance task: given a skill set and the official patch, an agent must update obsolete skill content while preserving guidance that remains valid. Across 57 real-world repositories and 105 selected release transitions, every evaluated transition invalidates part of the skill set. Yet six frontier agents reach only 29.9%–69.7% avg@3 macro under a patch-grounded removal metric that balances stale-content recall against over-editing precision. Across runs, two opposing errors dominate: incomplete coverage of affected files in the skill set leaves stale content untouched, while overbroad editing is associated with higher recall but lower precision. Repository skills go stale in silence, and even frontier agents cannot reliably maintain them.

Primary area:
datasets and benchmarks
Keywords:
LLM Agents, Agent Skills, Large Language Models, Agent Evaluation, Software Evolution

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_b1xkOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates "silent staleness," a critical lifecycle issue where repository-specific agent skills become obsolete and misleading after software releases without raising explicit errors. The authors introduce Repo2Skill-Evo, a benchmark of 105 official release transitions across 57 repositories, pairing fixed V1V_1 skill sets with release patches and patch-verified obsolete line annotations to evaluate whether frontier LLM agents can reliably maintain externalized procedural knowledge.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-written paper and easy to follow. The core concept of framing agent skills as versioned knowledge assets is practical, timely, and well-motivated.
  2. Strong motivating study showing that fixed skills match source-code access in downstream utility while reducing token consumption by over 80%, clearly justifying the value of skill maintenance.
  3. High-quality dataset construction across 57 real-world repositories with manually verified gold obsolete lines, complemented by thorough trace-level failure diagnostics and oracle localization ablations.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The physical line-based removal metric is overly rigid and penalizes benign paraphrasing or formatting adjustments of valid context lines as "off-target edits," which conflicts with the high retention scores observed in the NL Judge.

  2. The empirical story lacks an end-to-end evaluation loop on V2V_2 downstream tasks. Without testing the stale V1V_1 skills versus agent-maintained V2V_2 skills on actual V2V_2 tasks, it remains unclear how severely silent staleness degrades real execution or whether a ~70% maintenance F1F_1 is already sufficient in practice.

  3. Missing comparison against a "re-distillation from scratch" baseline. It is unclear how incremental patch-based maintenance compares to simply re-running the Repo2Skill distillation pipeline (or equipping the maintenance agent with the static Grounding Gate from Section 3.1) on the V2V_2 repository in terms of token cost and final quality.

Questions for authors

Refer to the Weaknesses

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Maintenance Metrics, Downstream Utility, and Regeneration Cost

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. Our additional experiments connect maintenance F1 to downstream utility and compare incremental maintenance with full V2 regeneration.

1. F1 reflects the requirement for minimal, patch-grounded updates

The maintenance prompt explicitly requires minimal, patch-grounded edits and prohibits unrelated rewriting, reformatting, or cosmetic changes. Under this objective, rewriting valid content without release evidence counts as an off-target modification even when the original information remains intact. Precision measures the fraction of removed or revised V1 lines belonging to the gold stale set; Recall measures how much of that set is covered.

2. Maintained skills improve downstream V2 utility

We evaluated one V2 artifact-generation task for each of the same ten repositories used in the motivating study. All conditions use the same GPT-5.4 executor, tools, budget, and V2 scoring rules. Ten conditions × ten tasks × three runs yield 300 artifact evaluations.

Skill conditionF1 on these 10 transitions (%)V2 utility /10
No skills—6.12
Stale V1 skills—6.44
Claude Opus 4.6 maintained63.78.22
GPT-5.4 maintained61.48.04
GLM-5.1 maintained59.97.86
Kimi-K2.5 maintained45.07.38
Doubao Seed2 Pro maintained32.76.74
MiniMax-M2.5 maintained29.16.68
GPT-5.4 regenerated—8.30
Claude Opus 4.6 regenerated—8.44

F1 values are existing avg@3 macro scores on this subset. Utility measures the correctness and usefulness of generated V2 task artifacts.

All six maintainers improve mean utility over stale V1 skills. Claude and GPT achieve gains of 1.78 and 1.60 points, respectively. These gains show practical benefits at the observed F1 levels; the adequacy of an update depends on which instructions a downstream task requires.

For the 180 maintained outputs, we compute Spearman correlation within each transition across six models × three runs, then average across ten transitions. The resulting mean ρ = 0.81 indicates a strong positive association between F1 and utility within matched tasks.

This association supports retaining F1 as the primary metric across 105 transitions. F1 is computed deterministically from output differences and fixed, patch-grounded annotations. Downstream utility also depends on task choice, executor behavior, sampling, and grading, making it a complementary measure of practical value.

3. Regeneration improves mean utility at substantially higher preparation cost

We regenerated skills directly from V2 repositories through fully autonomous runs of the original Repo2Skill multi-stage pipeline. Regeneration reconstructs skill packages from V2 source; maintenance updates existing V1 skills using the official release patch.

ModelMaintenance tokensRegeneration tokensRegeneration / maintenance
GPT-5.41.21M4.91M4.06×
Claude Opus 4.61.76M6.37M3.62×

Values are mean logged input-plus-output tokens for V2 skill preparation over the same ten transitions and three runs. Ratios and savings are calculated before rounding.

Regeneration improves mean utility over same-model maintenance by 0.26 points for GPT and 0.22 for Claude. Maintenance saves 75.3% and 72.4% of preparation tokens, respectively. These results quantify the trade-off between the additional utility of reconstruction and the lower token cost of updating existing assets.

Thank you for the detailed response. My concerns have been addressed, I will maintain my original score.

Reviewer_AwSbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces a benchmark for maintaining agent skills as repositories evolve. Given a V1 skill set and the V1-to-V2 release patch, an agent must update the skills. The dataset covers 57 repositories, 105 version transitions, 1,158 skills and 12,217 gold stale lines (median 92 per transition, range 5-375). The primary metric is a patch-grounded precision/recall/F1 on removal of stale lines, complemented by an LLM judge scoring five dimensions (0-2 each) using GPT-5.4 and Opus-4.6. Across six models, avg@3 F1 ranges from 69.7 (Opus-4.6) to 29.9 (MiniMax-M2.5); GPT-5.4 has high recall but low precision (74.6 / 55.7). Diagnostics show that localization coverage correlates with F1 (r = 0.650) and an oracle localization run on the hardest 20 transitions raises F1 from 32.8 to 45.0. A 10-repository utility study with GPT-5.4 shows that skills raise task utility from 5.88 to 8.68, comparable to source-only access (8.64).

Critical strengths
  • Timely problem. Skill/documentation drift for coding agents is a real, under-studied maintenance problem.
  • Grounded metric. Tying gold labels to the actual release patch gives an objective, reproducible signal for the removal side.
  • Useful diagnostics. The coverage-F1 correlation and the oracle-localization experiment usefully isolate localization as the main bottleneck.
  • Clear presentation. The task, data pipeline and results are generally easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
  • Central concern: maintenance quality is not fully validated by the headline metric. Patch-grounded F1 measures removal or revision of obsolete lines, while final-state quality is evaluated separately by an LLM judge. Credit is due for the complementary judge, but the key unresolved question is whether high-scoring outputs preserve correct, useful guidance and improve downstream behavior.
  • No downstream validation of maintained skills. The paper never shows that stale skills hurt agents or that the maintained skills improve downstream task success; the 10-repo utility study compares skills vs no skills, not stale vs maintained.
  • Single-annotator gold labels. Gold stale lines come from a single expert with no inter-annotator agreement.
  • Curated, staleness-positive dataset. All transitions contain staleness, so false-positive behavior on transitions requiring no change is untested.
  • Turn-budget confound. The 50-turn budget is exhausted in 68.6% of MiniMax runs and 41.3% of GLM runs, so rankings partly reflect budget handling rather than maintenance ability.
  • Self-bias risk. V1 skills are generated by Opus/GPT, which are also evaluated, and the judges overlap with the evaluated models.
  • Small utility study. Ten tasks with one model is too small to support general claims.
  • Positioning needs a sharper empirical distinction. The paper discusses related skill-lifecycle work, including SkillGuard and SkillOps. The review should therefore ask what the release-conditioned benchmark uniquely measures, rather than imply that these references are absent.
Questions for authors
  1. How well do patch-grounded F1 and the final-state judge predict downstream task success? Can you validate final-state judgments against human assessment?
  2. Do maintained skills improve downstream agent success compared with the stale V1 skills?
  3. What is inter-annotator agreement on a subset of transitions labeled by a second expert?
  4. How do models behave on transitions where no skill change is needed?
  5. How do rankings change with a larger turn budget, or when excluding budget-exhausted runs?
  6. Are results consistent when V1 skills are generated by a model not in the evaluated set and judged by a non-evaluated judge?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Downstream Utility, Budget Sensitivity, and Evaluation Design

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. Our additional evaluations connect maintenance F1 to downstream utility and examine ranking stability after excluding budget-exhausted runs.

1. Downstream utility supports F1 as the primary metric

We evaluated V2 artifact-generation tasks on the same ten repositories as the motivating study. All conditions use the same GPT-5.4 executor, tools, budget, and V2 scoring rules. The eight conditions reported here cover 240 artifact evaluations: eight conditions × ten repositories × three runs.

Skill conditionF1 on these 10 transitions (%)V2 utility /10
No skills—6.12
Stale V1 skills—6.44
Claude Opus 4.6 maintained63.78.22
GPT-5.4 maintained61.48.04
GLM-5.1 maintained59.97.86
Kimi-K2.5 maintained45.07.38
Doubao Seed2 Pro maintained32.76.74
MiniMax-M2.5 maintained29.16.68

F1 values are existing avg@3 macro scores on this subset. Utility measures the correctness and usefulness of generated V2 task artifacts.

All six maintainers improve mean utility over stale V1 skills. Claude and GPT achieve gains of 1.78 and 1.60 points, respectively.

For the 180 maintained outputs, we compute Spearman correlation within each transition across six models × three runs, then average across ten transitions. The resulting mean ρ = 0.81 indicates a strong positive association between F1 and utility within matched tasks.

This association supports retaining F1 as the primary metric across 105 transitions. F1 is computed deterministically from output differences and fixed, patch-grounded annotations. Downstream utility also depends on task choice, executor behavior, sampling, and grading, making it a complementary measure of practical value.

2. Model rankings remain stable after excluding budget-exhausted runs

To compare models on the same tasks, we retain the 54 transitions where every model has at least one normally terminated run. Before filtering, we use all three original runs; after filtering, we use only normally terminated runs. In both cases, we average within each model–transition pair, then across the same 54 transitions.

ModelBefore filtering F1 (%)After filtering F1 (%)
Claude69.369.3
GLM65.168.6
GPT61.661.6
Kimi49.651.4
Doubao40.641.6
MiniMax32.936.9

All six rank positions remain unchanged on this common subset. The main benchmark retains all runs under the shared 50-turn limit, stated initially and tracked in every observation.

3. V1 generation and gold annotations

We tried all six models for V1 generation. Only GPT-5.4 and Claude Opus 4.6 produced skills that met our quality expectations, so we used them to construct the V1 skill sets.

A second expert independently reannotated cases covering ten repositories without seeing the original labels and obtained the same stale-line sets.

4. Transitions requiring no skill update

If a release leaves all existing skills valid, the expected behavior is to inspect its changes, confirm that no skill update is needed, and finish without edits. Our benchmark excludes these cases and focuses on 105 official release transitions with verified stale content.

5. Distinction from SkillGuard and SkillOps

SkillGuard focuses on detecting which environmental changes invalidate a skill's operational assumptions. It extracts executable contracts, checks them against known or live conditions, and uses violations to guide localized repair.

SkillOps focuses on persistent defects within a skill library, such as redundancy, interface incompatibility, and missing validation. It uses typed contracts, skill graphs, and execution feedback to guide merging, repair, retirement, and other maintenance actions.

Repo2Skill-Evo evaluates how an agent updates an existing repository skill set following an official release. Given the V1 skills and the V1-to-V2 source patch, the agent must identify affected content across skill prose, scripts, and references, then update it while preserving valid guidance. Across 57 repositories and 105 official transitions, manually verified stale-line annotations measure obsolete-content coverage and edit selectivity. The empirical focus is the agent's ability to trace repository changes into the required skill updates across files.

Reviewer_pJJAOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the problem of “silent staleness” in Agent Skills during the continuous evolution of software repositories—that is, after a repository version is updated, the original Skill can still be loaded and used normally, but some of the knowledge it contains may no longer be valid. The authors propose the Repo2Skill-Evo evaluation benchmark, which covers 57 real-world software repositories and 105 version upgrades. The benchmark requires agents to update stale skill content based on official release patches while preserving knowledge that remains valid. The paper evaluates maintenance quality using patch-based, line-level Precision, Recall, and F1 scores and tests six state-of-the-art LLM agents. Experimental results show that the average F1 score of the best model is only 69.7%, with the main bottlenecks being incomplete identification of affected files and inaccurate editing decisions. Based on this, the authors emphasize that Repository Skills should be treated as knowledge assets that require continuous maintenance alongside software versions.

Critical strengths

1.The research question has practical significance. The paper focuses on the problem of silent obsolescence of agent skills during the continuous evolution of software repositories. By treating skill maintenance as an independent research task, it broadens the perspective of existing research, which primarily focuses on skill generation and usage. 2. The evaluation benchmark demonstrates high authenticity and systematic rigor. The authors constructed the benchmark based on 57 real-world repositories and 105 version upgrades. They conducted evaluations using official patches and manually verified obsolete content. Through multi-model comparisons, execution trace analysis, and Oracle Localization experiments, they systematically revealed the current limitations of agents in terms of skill localization and editing decisions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation metrics are disconnected from actual agent utility. The paper primarily uses patch-based row-level Precision, Recall, and F1 scores to evaluate skill maintenance quality, but does not demonstrate a correlation between these metrics and the actual task utility of the agent after maintenance. The importance of different skill contents may vary significantly: omitting updates to critical APIs may lead to task failure, while accidentally deleting some general knowledge may have almost no impact on performance. The current F1 score not only treats different knowledge lines equally but also applies a symmetric evaluation to Recall and Precision, even though the actual harm caused by these two types of errors may not be the same. More importantly, the paper does not compare the performance of the Stale V1 Skill and the Maintained V2 Skill on real V2 repository tasks; therefore, it cannot quantify the actual harm caused by silently outdated Skills, nor can it verify whether a higher maintenance F1 score translates to better downstream utility. This undermines the validity of the core evaluation metrics and the practical significance of the paper’s main conclusions.
  2. The lack of a comparison with Skill Regeneration means that the necessity and cost advantages of the maintenance strategy have not been demonstrated. The paper emphasizes that Skills need to be maintained as the repository evolves, but it does not compare the quality, computational cost, and downstream utility of incrementally maintaining V1 Skills versus directly regenerating Skills from the V2 repository; thus, it fails to demonstrate that Maintenance offers practical advantages over Regeneration. It is particularly noteworthy that the initial V1 Skills were generated from candidates produced by two strong models and were subsequently selected, revised, and validated by experts, whereas the subsequent V2 Skills rely entirely on autonomous maintenance by the Agent. This implies that the paper neither demonstrates that automated skill generation itself can consistently produce high-quality skills nor explains why the same build process was not used to directly regenerate the V2 skill. If regeneration could yield a higher-quality skill at a comparable cost, the actual necessity of the incremental maintenance strategy emphasized in this study would be questionable.
  3. There is a clear asymmetry between the V1 generation and V2 maintenance processes, and the causes of maintenance failure remain unclear. The authors designed a multi-stage process for V1 skill generation that included steps such as ANALYZE, LOGIC, MATERIALS, DRAFT, and VALIDATE, and introduced expert review to ensure the quality of the initial skills. However, during the V2 maintenance phase, the authors used only a uniform, generic agent scaffold and prompt, without designing targeted mechanisms for patch analysis, skill localization, targeted editing, or validation. This raises a critical question: Does the currently observed low maintenance F1 score reflect an inherent lack of capability in the LLM agent, or is it due to an overly simplistic maintenance process? The paper’s Oracle Localization experiment has already demonstrated that more comprehensive localization information can improve maintenance performance, but it did not further validate the effectiveness of a structured maintenance process. Furthermore, even if more complex processes can significantly improve maintenance quality, it remains unknown whether the additional analysis, validation, and tool invocations would offset the cost advantage compared to regenerating the skill. Therefore, the lack of ablation experiments comparing different maintenance processes and a joint analysis of maintenance quality and cost makes it difficult for the paper to fully elucidate the true capability boundaries of the existing agent.
Questions for authors

We hope the authors will further clarify the following three issues: (1) Have they evaluated the utility of the “Stale V1 Skill” and the “Maintained V2 Skill” in real-world downstream tasks? Is there evidence showing a correlation between the “Maintenance F1” score and actual utility, and do recall and precision have the same impact on utility? (2) Have you compared the quality and cost of incrementally maintaining skills versus regenerating skills directly from the V2 repository? In particular, given that the initial V1 skills were curated and revised by experts, can automated skill generation alone guarantee the same level of quality? (3) Why does V1 skill generation employ a multi-stage distillation and validation process, while V2 maintenance uses only a generic agent scaffold? Have more structured maintenance processes been attempted, and what are the respective performance improvements and additional costs? The answers to these questions will directly influence my assessment of the validity of the paper’s evaluation and the practical necessity of skill maintenance.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Downstream Utility, Regeneration Cost, and Maintenance Protocol

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. Our additional experiments connect maintenance F1 to downstream utility and compare incremental maintenance with regeneration.

1. Downstream utility supports F1 as the primary metric

We evaluated V2 artifact-generation tasks on the same ten repositories as the motivating study. All conditions use the same GPT-5.4 executor, tools, budget, and V2 scoring rules. Ten conditions × ten repositories × three runs yield 300 artifact evaluations.

Skill conditionF1 on these 10 transitions (%)V2 utility /10
No skills—6.12
Stale V1 skills—6.44
Claude Opus 4.6 maintained63.78.22
GPT-5.4 maintained61.48.04
GLM-5.1 maintained59.97.86
Kimi-K2.5 maintained45.07.38
Doubao Seed2 Pro maintained32.76.74
MiniMax-M2.5 maintained29.16.68
GPT-5.4 regenerated—8.30
Claude Opus 4.6 regenerated—8.44

F1 values are existing avg@3 macro scores on this subset. Utility measures the correctness and usefulness of generated V2 task artifacts.

All six maintainers improve mean utility over stale V1 skills. Claude and GPT achieve gains of 1.78 and 1.60 points, respectively. Stale skills retain useful knowledge, while maintenance substantially improves their applicability to V2.

For the 180 maintained outputs, we compute Spearman correlation within each transition across six models × three runs, then average across ten transitions. The resulting mean ρ = 0.81 indicates a strong positive association between F1 and utility within matched tasks.

Recall measures coverage of patch-verified obsolete content, while Precision measures edit selectivity. F1 combines them symmetrically with uniform line weights to provide a reproducible maintenance target. We also report Precision and Recall separately, since the utility consequences of missed updates and off-target edits depend on the affected content and task.

The observed association supports retaining F1 as the primary metric across 105 transitions. For a given output, F1 is computed deterministically against fixed, patch-grounded annotations. Downstream utility additionally reflects task choice, executor behavior, sampling, and grading. Thus, F1 provides a consistent basis for maintenance comparison, complemented by downstream evaluation of practical value.

2. Maintenance delivers substantial utility gains at lower preparation cost

We regenerated skills from V2 repositories through fully autonomous runs of the original Repo2Skill multi-stage pipeline. Maintenance updates existing V1 skills using official release patches, whereas regeneration rebuilds skill packages from V2 source.

ModelMaintenance tokensRegeneration tokensRegeneration / maintenance
GPT-5.41.21M4.91M4.06×
Claude Opus 4.61.76M6.37M3.62×

Values are mean logged input-plus-output tokens for V2 skill preparation over the same ten transitions and three runs.

Regeneration improves mean utility over same-model maintenance by 0.26 points for GPT and 0.22 for Claude. Maintenance saves 75.3% and 72.4% of preparation tokens, respectively. These results demonstrate a clear quality–cost trade-off: maintenance provides a token-efficient update of existing assets, while regeneration yields slightly higher utility at substantially greater token cost.

3. V1 generation establishes the initial asset; V2 maintenance evaluates autonomous adaptation

V1 generation constructs a reusable skill asset from repository source, using multi-stage extraction and validation to establish a reliable starting point. V2 maintenance evaluates how effectively an agent adapts this asset to repository changes.

The maintenance protocol provides clear task requirements, operational guidance, and tools for inspecting, searching, and editing skills. It specifies patch-grounded updates, preservation of valid knowledge, coverage across affected files, and completion within budget. A shared generic scaffold keeps operational support consistent across models, while agents autonomously organize these operations into a workflow. This allows the benchmark to assess planning, localization, evidence tracing, and editing under consistent conditions.

Oracle localization isolates the contribution of file identification. Providing affected-file paths raises mean F1 from 32.8% to 45.0% on the 20-transition diagnostic subset under the same tools and 50-turn cap. Agents must still identify obsolete content within those files and make the appropriate updates.

The benchmark therefore specifies the maintenance objective and operating constraints while leaving the execution strategy to the agent. Choosing where to look, how to organize edits, and when the update is complete forms part of the autonomous capability being measured.

Reviewer_pJJAOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Reviewer pJJA

  1. Validity of Evaluation Metrics (Partially Addressed) The newly added downstream task experiments are very valuable. The Spearman correlation coefficient reached 0.81, indicating a strong association between maintenance F1 and downstream utility. However, two issues remain. First, the correlation was calculated within the same repository transition, across different models and runs. Although task differences were controlled for, differences in the models’ inherent capabilities may have influenced the correlation. Stronger models may achieve both high F1 and high utility, which does not necessarily mean that F1 can reliably distinguish between different maintenance results generated by the same model. I would like to see further analysis that controls for model identity and repository transitions. Second, F1 only evaluates whether outdated content in V1 has been deleted or modified; it does not directly evaluate the correctness of the replacement content in V2. A skill might remove all outdated knowledge but introduce incorrect new instructions, while still achieving a high F1 score. Therefore, the correlation experiments support F1 as a proxy metric but do not fully prove that it can measure the correctness of the skill after maintenance. Additionally, it would be valuable to report the correlations between Precision and Recall, as well as Utility, separately.

  2. Comparison of Maintenance and Regeneration (Largely Resolved) I find the Regeneration experiment added by the author to be persuasive. The results demonstrate a clear trade-off between quality and cost: Regeneration offers slightly higher utility, while Maintenance significantly reduces token consumption during the preparation phase. This directly addresses my previous doubts regarding the actual value of incremental maintenance; therefore, I consider this issue to be largely resolved. It would be even more persuasive if the author could further provide an uncertainty analysis of the utility differences between the two methods, but I no longer consider the absence of a Regeneration control group to be a major flaw.

  3. Maintenance Method Design (Partially Addressed) I understand the author’s explanation: The benchmark aims to standardize the evaluation of agents’ autonomous behavior under a unified scaffold, rather than to optimize a specific maintenance algorithm. This is a reasonable choice in benchmark design. However, it is still important to distinguish between evaluating agents under a fixed, simplified scaffold and assessing their general skill maintenance capabilities. The original V1 generation process included structured analysis, evidence collection, and verification, whereas V2 maintenance primarily employs a general-purpose agent workflow. The Oracle Localization experiment has already demonstrated that providing additional guidance can significantly improve maintenance performance. Therefore, while the current experiment demonstrates that the agent has capability limitations under the tested protocol, it cannot prove that these limitations persist under a more structured maintenance process. Adding a Structured Maintenance Baseline would help clarify this point. Alternatively, the authors should explicitly qualify their conclusions to the current scaffold and operational constraints.

Overall Evaluation The authors’ response has significantly improved my assessment of the paper, particularly the newly added Utility and Regeneration experiments, which address two important empirical gaps in the original paper. However, the issue that F1 solely evaluates content on the deletion side still persists, and the Utility validation covers only 10 repository transitions—one downstream task per repository. Since the paper’s main experiment includes 105 transitions, the generalizability of the new experiments remains limited. In my view, this paper is now better suited as a benchmark and empirical study focused on a fixed definition of maintenance tasks. If the authors could clearly distinguish between “Patch-grounded Removal F1” and “Overall Skill Maintenance Quality,” and limit their conclusions regarding the agent’s capabilities to specific scaffolds, the overall research design would be more sound.

Thank you for asking whether F1 distinguishes outputs from the same maintainer on the same release. Our earlier result (mean Spearman ρ = 0.81) compared all 18 outputs within each transition before averaging across the ten transitions. To account for differences between maintainers, we now examine variation across the three runs of each maintainer on each transition. For each metric, we subtract the group means from the run-level scores and their paired utility scores, then compute Pearson correlation across the centered observations. The correlations with utility are 0.77 for F1, 0.69 for precision, and 0.82 for recall. Across the ten V2 tasks, higher-F1 runs from the same maintainer on the same release tended to yield more useful downstream artifacts.

We retain patch-grounded removal F1 as the primary metric because it captures both coverage and selectivity. Recall measures the fraction of patch-verified stale V1 lines that the agent removes or revises. Precision measures the fraction of all removed or revised V1 lines that belong to that stale set. Once the annotations are fixed, the output diff fully determines the score. This gives us a reproducible comparison across all 105 transitions that is independent of downstream task choice and judge variability. Our NL judge complements F1 by assessing whether replacement guidance is correct and valid information is retained. The downstream study assesses the practical value of the maintained skills on one V2 task per repository across ten repositories.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.