- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper targets the critical issue that existing diffusion-based recommendation models adopt user-agnostic fixed Gaussian noise, which easily leads to generation collapse during training, and proposes the RelDiff framework. The framework leverages the Actor-Critic network from reinforcement learning to generate user-conditioned preference-aware noise; it designs a NAR strategy, which constructs a push-pull loss based on a reference model to mitigate generation collapse. It also introduces a contrastive injection mechanism that integrates diffusion generation information into item embeddings, eliminating the need for iterative denoising during the inference stage. Extensive experiments are conducted on five real-world datasets, where the proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art baselines across graph-based models, contrastive learning methods and existing diffusion recommendation approaches, achieving better ranking metrics. The paper also performs comprehensive experiments including module ablation, convergence analysis, efficiency evaluation, signal-to-noise ratio testing and hyperparameter sensitivity analysis. Nevertheless, the work still has limitations: the code is not publicly available, some theoretical assumptions have inherent constraints, and statistical significance tests are not conducted.
Critical strengths
-
Existing diffusion recommendation models uniformly adopt user-agnostic standard Gaussian noise, which easily damages the sparse structure of user-item interactions. This paper utilizes Actor-Critic reinforcement learning to learn a customized noise distribution for different users based on reconstruction rewards, breaking the limitation of fixed noise.
-
NAR does not directly discard samples with poor reconstruction performance. Instead, it leverages a reference model to construct a push-pull loss to alleviate the performance stagnation in the late training stage. Then it distills the generation information into embeddings via contrastive learning, avoiding the high time cost caused by repeated denoising in diffusion inference.
Critical weaknesses
-
The appendix explicitly withdraws the original claims about guaranteed convergence acceleration and stable gradient updates. Counter‑examples show that the repulsion term in NAR may produce incorrect gradients even for genuine positive user‑item interactions. Since NAR is one of the two core innovations of RelDiff, the lack of valid theoretical guarantees weakens the interpretability and reliability of the whole method.
-
Multiple critical implementation details, reference‑checkpoint update rule, gradient‑stopping settings, exact hyper‑parameter selection workflow remain unspecified. Moreover, statistical significance tests are missing for all performance improvements.
Questions for authors
-
For the NAR strategy, when the reconstruction confidence is calculated from batch‑wise statistics, are gradients detached from these batch statistics during back‑propagation? Also, what exact update rule is adopted for selecting and refreshing the reference checkpoint ? Without these implementation details, it is hard to judge how NAR behaves in practical training.
-
The reported performance improvements lack statistical significance tests. Could you provide paired statistical test results across multiple repeated runs to confirm that the observed gains of RelDiff over baselines stem from your proposed modules instead of random fluctuation or hyper‑parameter luck?
-
The PNG module uses one‑step contextual‑bandit‑style actor‑critic optimization relying purely on immediate reconstruction reward. Is there any observed risk that the policy only optimizes reconstruction loss but fails to improve downstream ranking metrics? Have you tracked the correlation between reconstruction reward and final recommendation ranking performance in your experiments?
-
In the SNR analysis, higher SNR is obtained with learned preference noise. Does this elevated SNR truly encode user‑specific preference information, or is it merely an outcome of reducing overall noise magnitude? Could you supply control experiments such as norm‑matched random noise to rule out the magnitude‑only effect?