- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents an agentic workflow that composes reference retrieval, spatial grounding, keyframe editing, and prompt refinement around a frozen video editor. A VLM planner uses experience cards distilled from verified execution trajectories to guide subsequent workflows. The experiments report improved editing performance and demonstrate transfer of the auxiliary tool space to VACE.
Critical strengths
- The framework addresses a practically relevant problem: providing appropriate auxiliary guidance for video edits that depend on target appearance, spatial relationships, and interactions. This is an intuitive idea that could potentially improve performance across diverse video editing scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
-
My major concern is the paper’s limited technical novelty. The framework primarily combines auxiliary editing tools with VLM-based planning, verification-driven revision, and retrieval of summarized execution experience. Section 2.2 already discusses tool-using video editing through Aurora and reusable workflow induction or optimization through Agent Workflow Memory and AFlow. However, the paper does not clearly establish a substantive new mechanism beyond combining these directions for video editing.
-
The controlled comparisons are also insufficient. The tool-removal and no-memory ablations show that access to these components is beneficial, but they do not demonstrate the superiority of the proposed composition and memory design. Although Aurora is included, the paper does not document a controlled comparison using the same editing backbone and tools. In addition, the framework uses the Qwen model family for planning and verification, while Edit Accuracy is also measured by a Qwen-family evaluator using eight sampled frames. This leaves the potential for correlated judging errors insufficiently examined.
-
A minor weakness is that the paper lacks some implementation details. The experience-learning split size, memory size, retrieval , verifier acceptance criteria, and numerical tool budget are missing or insufficiently specified.
Questions for authors
-
The Introduction states that memory is frozen at test time, but Sections 5.1 and 5.4 describe online experience accumulation. Which protocol was actually used in the experiments?
-
Were the H3 baseline results obtained using the official prompt enhancement method (H3-Context-IR)? If not, the prompt-enhanced baseline should be included, as it serves a similar function by providing auxiliary textual guidance.