- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CompAct, a compositional 3D HOI synthesis framework that generates multi-object interactions by combining single-object interactions through body-part InterFields and flow matching without multi-object training data. Experiments demonstrate improvements in interaction synthesis and contact generation over existing methods, supported by ablation studies and perceptual evaluations.
Critical strengths
- This paper tackles an important and challenging problem of synthesizing multi-object HOI without requiring multi-object interaction training data. The core idea of composing multiple single-object interactions is meaningful and could be an important step forward for scalable HOI synthesis.
- The idea of body-part InterFields and using them to guide the interaction composition are well motivated and specifically designed.
- One of the interesting advantages is that the proposed representation naturally supports different conditional generation settings and interaction editing. Figure 2 provides a clear explanation of how these components are integrated.
- Experimental results are promising without using multi-object training samples.
Critical weaknesses
- Although composing single-object interactions is a promising approach, it is not fully clear how this formulation handles dependencies between multiple interactions that share the same body parts. For example, interactions involving both hands and upper body are often physically coupled. The proposed per-part composition may not fully capture such dependencies, particularly when multiple objects impose conflicting constraints on the same kinematic chain.
- The main contribution of this paper is compositional multi-object synthesis. However, in Appendix Table 5, CompAct performs worse than mTRiDi in several reconstruction metrics when both human and object are jointly generated (H, O, I), although it provides better contact gap. This raises a question on whether the method accurately captures the full multi-object interaction distribution.
Questions for authors
- In L064-L065, the paper states that a multi-object interaction is a composition of single-object interactions. Could you explain why this assumption is reasonable when multiple interactions can strongly influence each other?
- How does CompAct handle cases where two objects require conflicting body configurations? For example, when the same hand or arm needs to interact with two objects simultaneously.
- In L272-L275, the paper states that InterFields settle before the human pose during sampling. Why does this happen? Is this an observed behavior of the model or an assumption of the proposed guidance?
- In L318-L335, the paper explains that multiple interaction branches can claim the same body part. How does the model ensure that the resulting body configuration satisfies all the interactions when the predictions from these branches are different?
- In Appendix Table 5, CompAct performs substantially worse than mTRiDi in MPJPE and object reconstruction error for (H, O, I), while achieving lower contact gap. What causes this difference? Does the compositional guidance prioritize contact satisfaction over the reconstruction of realistic multi-object configurations?
- The paper states that the framework supports multi-object interaction synthesis without multi-object training. Does the method also prevent collisions between different objects? How are object-object relationships considered during composition?
- The method generates static interaction configurations rather than full interaction sequences. How can the proposed compositional formulation be extended to dynamic HOI where contacts appear and disappear over time?
- LLM-estimated contacts can refer papers such as TeHoR (CVPR 2026, Nam et al.), ContactPrompt (arXiv 2026, Jung et al.).