Questions For Authors
- The methodological contribution could be more clearly distinguished from established fusion approaches
HPIF integrates bilinear sampling, feature splatting, gated residual updates, and multi-stage interaction, while POCE combines local neighborhood attention with both regular and shifted window-based image attention. These mechanisms have substantial precedents in the literature, including the related works discussed in the paper, such as DeepInteraction, ViT-CoMer, and Swin Transformer.
At present, the core contribution seems to rest on the integration and adaptation of these modules for CAD primitive representations. To enhance the paper's impact, it would be beneficial to pinpoint the specific shortcomings of prior fusion mechanisms within this domain and illustrate how the proposed architecture overcomes these challenges.
- The improvements brought by certain components appear relatively small, and the paper would benefit from including statistical uncertainty estimates to validate their significance.
In Table 4(b), with POCE retained, I2P alone achieves a PQ of 92.57, whereas bidirectional interaction yields 92.74—a marginal gain of 0.17 points. Similarly, in Table 4(c), PCT alone achieves 92.66 PQ, while combining PCT and ICT results in 92.74, representing an additional gain of only 0.08 points. Furthermore, the performance difference between three-point and five-point image sampling is merely 0.09 points.
While these results warrant further investigation, the paper fails to report means, standard deviations, or confidence intervals from repeated runs. Consequently, the statistical reliability of these marginal differences remains uncertain.
- The computational costs and the comparability with external baselines are not sufficiently characterized.
The framework employs a dual-backbone architecture, eight HPIF modules, and additional context attention, along with a multi-stage training procedure that involves independent branch training, joint optimization, and subsequent context-module training. However, the paper fails to report key efficiency metrics, such as parameter counts, FLOPs, inference latency, peak memory usage, or training GPU-hours.
The FloorPlanCAD baseline results are directly adopted from prior literature. While retraining VecFormer on ArchCAD-Public is a positive step, merely stating that it was trained to convergence is insufficient to ensure full comparability in terms of pretraining, optimization budget, and tuning effort. Although the internal ablations help assess individual components, an external accuracy–efficiency comparison remains necessary.
- The primary ablation studies fail to establish the effectiveness of individual components in the absence of layer priors.
Table 4 presents all component ablations on FloorPlanCAD with layer priors, which contrasts with the paper's emphasis on practical settings where such metadata is unavailable. Since PCT explicitly restricts neighborhoods to primitives within the same layer, its performance in a single-layer, no-prior setting is particularly critical to evaluate.
I recommend conducting the principal ablations for HPIF, PCT, and ICT on FloorPlanCAD without priors, as well as on ArchCAD-Public. These experiments would also help elucidate which components are responsible for the more substantial gains observed on ArchCAD-Public.
Additionally, the point representation incorporates a normalized layer identifier as its third coordinate. Since layer identifiers are inherently categorical, their numerical ordering does not necessarily convey geometric meaning. The paper should clarify the identifier assignment protocol and evaluate the model's robustness to permutations that preserve layer membership while altering the numerical values.
- The analysis offers limited insights into instance grouping and failure modes
Figure 2 and the supplementary visualizations primarily depict primitive-level semantic coloring. While these examples illustrate classification differences, they do not directly reveal whether adjacent primitives of the same category are correctly separated into distinct instances.
Given that the task is panoptic symbol spotting, I recommend incorporating instance-level visualizations, along with a breakdown of Recognition Quality (RQ) and Segmentation Quality (SQ). Additionally, results stratified by category or symbol density would provide deeper insights. It would be particularly informative to analyze challenging cases involving nearby repeated symbols, overlapping strokes, and small objects, as well as to include representative failure cases such as instance merging, splitting, and missed detections.
While the paper appropriately identifies complete-drawing inference as future work, it would still be valuable to report performance and memory usage as a function of primitive count within the current cropped-region setting. Such data would provide useful evidence regarding the method's scalability.
- The reproducibility details should also be clarified
Several implementation details require clarification to ensure reproducibility, including raster resolution, stroke width, line-segment sampling rules, input geometric attributes, sources of pretrained weights, ICT window size, and the set of trainable components at each optimization stage. While the appendix specifies default PCT neighborhood parameters, these additional configuration choices are equally critical.
The highest-priority additions include repeated runs for key ablations, component analysis without priors, and accuracy–efficiency comparisons with strong baselines. These experiments would substantially strengthen the evidence for the necessity of bidirectional fusion and POCE, while helping to establish the paper’s contribution beyond a mere combination of existing mechanisms.
https://iclr.cc/Conferences/2027/AuthorGuidelines
Recommended: Reproducibility statement
It is important that the work published in ICLR is reproducible. Authors are strongly encouraged to include a paragraph-long Reproducibility Statement at the end of the main text (before references) to discuss the efforts that have been made to ensure reproducibility.