- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CoRe-Gen, a framework for spectrum-to-structure generation under imperfect fingerprint conditions. It combines synthetic-spectrum encoder pretraining, corruption-aware decoder pretraining, and a differentiable fingerprint-to-memory bridge for joint encoder–decoder finetuning. The authors also incorporate structural information into autoregressive decoding.
Critical strengths
- Jointly updating the spectrum encoder through the molecular generation loss is a useful idea.
- Addressing the mismatch between clean fingerprints used during training and predicted fingerprints used at inference is well motivated.
Critical weaknesses
-
The data separation and potential leakage issues in large-scale synthetic-spectrum pretraining need more explanation. In Section 4.1, the authors state that molecules overlapping with the test sets are removed from both pretraining corpora. However, I strongly suspect that the current pretraining data contain molecules highly similar to the test molecules. I suggest reporting the similarity distribution between current using pretraining dataset and the test set, and pretraining both the encoder and decoder on the standard pretraining dataset released with MassSpecGym1.5 [1]. Table 5 shows that removing encoder or decoder pretraining causes the largest performance drops further support the concern, while the other modules have only minor effects, suggesting substantial over-engineering.
-
Some terms and symbols are unclear. What does “encoder-aligned evaluation” mean in the abstract? In Equation (2), is used without being introduced.
-
Updating the encoder through the decoder is an interesting idea, but the descriptions in the Introduction and Related Work do not clearly explain how backpropagation works. On page 4, why are the fingerprint dimensions divided into groups, and what is the rationale behind the definition of ? A direct MLP connection would also allow backpropagation. The authors should include this ablation.
-
Section 3.2 is hard to follow. Which dataset does “training corpus” refer to? Why is grouping necessary, and has an ablation without grouping been conducted? What is the rationale behind and in Equation (4)? Grouping is introduced earlier, but its connection to the subsequent equations is unclear, as is the use of and in Equations (6)–(8). The authors should include ablations with random bit flips without grouping, using both occurrence-based and fixed probabilities.
-
In Section 3.3, how was the five-component tuple in Equation (9) chosen? Are there ablation experiments supporting this choice?where does the rule-dependent mask in Equation (11) come from?
Questions for authors
My biggest concern is potential data leakage during pretraining. In addition, the proposed method appears overly engineered and offers limited insights.