- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes KnowAcu, a graph-based model for recommending acupuncture points from patient symptoms. It combines five graphs built from prescription co-occurrence patterns and traditional Chinese medicine knowledge about organs and meridians. A gated graph attention network learns symptom and acupoint representations, which are used to rank candidate acupoints. The model also uses LLM-generated supervision to distinguish primary from supporting acupoints and encourage consistency between the recommendations and input symptoms. Experiments on a small dataset drawn from clinical records and literature, along with a larger synthetic dataset, show improvements over several recommendation and LLM baselines.
Critical strengths
Organ and meridian relationships add useful domain knowledge beyond the patterns observed in prescriptions.
Reconstructing symptoms from the recommended acupoints is a useful consistency check, although the paper needs to explain its implementation more clearly.
The ablation results show lower performance when the theory graphs, joint graph learning, or LLM losses are removed, suggesting that each component contributes to the results.
Critical weaknesses
The real dataset has only 546 prescriptions but 2,174 distinct symptoms. Given the number of components in the model, overfitting is a concern. The authors use five-fold cross-validation, but without standard deviations or confidence intervals, it is hard to tell how consistent the gains are.
The LLM scores the importance of acupoints and links them to symptoms, but the paper does not show whether experts checked these judgments systematically. If these associations are incorrect, the reconstruction loss could push the model to learn them anyway.
Symptoms and acupoints are connected whenever they occur in the same prescription. This treats frequent and occasional co-occurrences alike. It also ignores that a relationship may be useful for one clinical presentation but not another.
LINKO, “Multi-Ontology Integration with Dual-Axis Propagation for Medical Concept Representation” (CIKM 2025), has a similar motivation: combining medical knowledge with co-occurrence patterns through graph learning. It would be useful to discuss this work and consider it as a baseline. Since LINKO uses hierarchical ontologies, the authors would need to explain how it could be adapted for a fair comparison.
Questions for authors
sea weaknesses