- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a perceptual video codec, SRDVC, which decouples predictive reference evolution from reference-conditioned coding. Specifically, an LDS module decomposes dynamics estimation, state evolution, and observation prediction, while a DMA module imposes asymmetric source allocation for reference utilization. The resulting perceptual-quality-optimized video codec achieves improvements over GLC-Video of −72.67 in LPIPS and −63.97 in DISTS.
Critical strengths
- The motivation for decoupling predictive reference evolution from reference-conditioned coding is insightful.
- The paper provides relatively comprehensive ablation studies and analytical experiments.
Critical weaknesses
- I find the overall organization and presentation of the paper rather unusual, specifically in the following aspects:
- The paper lacks a clear logical progression from motivation, analysis of existing methods, and problem formulation to the proposed method and its experimental validation. Instead, the entire paper feels like a collection of loosely connected components, making it difficult to assess whether the motivation, methodology, and experimental results reasonably support one another.
- The presentation is highly fragmented, even across individual sections and paragraphs. Moreover, many essential theoretical derivations, methodological details, and even experimental settings are only briefly mentioned in the main text, with readers repeatedly referred to the supplementary material for these critical details. This substantially increases the difficulty of reading and understanding the paper.
- The paper exhibits a peculiar defensive writing style. In many places, explanations seem to appear abruptly, seemingly intended to preempt potential questions or criticisms, without fitting naturally into the surrounding discussion. One example is Lines 179–182.
- The paper contains numerous paper-specific terms and abbreviations that are not adequately explained. For example, it is unclear what "MASP" in Line 298 refers to.
- The paper lacks comparisons with recent methods at a comparable level, such as GVC-RT: Towards Real-Time Generative Video Compression at Ultra-Low Bitrates. In addition, the rate-distortion curves suggest that the performance advantages of the proposed method are mainly concentrated in the high-bitrate region, while its performance at low bitrates is slightly inferior.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the above weaknesses to clarify the main logical chain and clear expression of this paper.
Closing discussion after the rebuttal
Thank you to the authors for the rebuttal and to the reviewers for engaging in the discussion. As we wrap up, I’d appreciate a brief final assessment from each reviewer. After reading the rebuttal and the discussion so far, what is the main reason you lean toward acceptance or rejection, and what evidence supports that view? Please note which concerns the rebuttal resolved and which remaining concerns, if any, are decisive for your recommendation.
If your assessment differs from another reviewer’s, please point to the specific claim or evidence you interpret differently. Authors are welcome to clarify any factual points that remain open. This will help us identify where we agree and understand the reasons for any remaining disagreement.