- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes HI-Adapter, a framework that adapts pretrained VLAs for history-dependent manipulation while keeping their backbones frozen. It combines a spatiotemporal vision adapter for encoding recent multi-view observations, recurrent memory for consolidating historical features, and policy adapters that condition action generation on this memory. Part of the memory is supervised through SigLIP feature reconstruction and relative temporal-order prediction, alongside action supervision. The method is evaluated on RoboMME and six real-world tasks using RDT-1B and .
Critical strengths
- The consistent adapter design offers a practical way to augment pretrained VLAs with memory while training only a small fraction of their parameters. In particular, the vision adapter could be useful for policies that need to process multi-view, multi-frame observations.
- The paper presents six real-world manipulation tasks that collectively test multiple memory requirements, including counting and temporal reference.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper's positioning relative to existing memory-augmented policies is unclear, and its efficiency claims lack comparisons of task performance, training cost, and inference latency against such methods. Additionally, the Related Work discussion frames prior PEFT applications as limited in scope, but does not explain why this constitutes a limitation motivating the proposed method, where adapters serve as a technical design choice for memory augmentation.
- Inconsistent terminology for the vision and memory components, together with notation mismatches (e.g., in Figure 3(a) versus in Equation (2)), makes the methodology difficult to follow. Figure 2 further obscures the visual/language-conditioning and memory-injection paths, as well as the distinction between proprioceptive inputs and noisy action tokens.
- The component ablations do not isolate the contributions of recurrent aggregation, reconstruction/order supervision, or the memory slot partition (while the spatiotemporal-only variant for is also omitted from Table 1). Targeted ablations and analyses of memory content would better establish the benefits of these design choices and whether the action-oriented slots retain additional control-relevant information.
- Several quantitative claims conflict with the reported tables. For example, Table 1 labels 's Permanence improvement as 19%p rather than 29%p, while Section 4.2 describes the final real-world success rates (14.16% and 19.16%) as gains instead of the corresponding 8.33%p and 7.5%p improvements.
- The paper lacks sufficient implementation detail for reproducibility, particularly regarding SigLIP target selection (anchor view, selection rule, target count, and candidate history window). The history-buffer sampling schedule and auxiliary-loss weights are also not specified.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses above and provide the corresponding clarifications and supporting analyses.