acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

How Much Can Successful Behavior Change Before Success Breaks?

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

An LLM agent can complete the same task in different ways. Can one successful behavior be changed into another, one valid edit at a time, while preserving reliable task completion? Such flexibility matters when agents take detours or combine previously successful decisions. We introduce interventional success regions to study this question. Restartable checkpoints are linked by valid edits to their action histories and belong to the success region when the agent can reliably finish the task from them. We prove that success rates and specified local measurements can agree while successful connectivity differs. We develop a budgeted search procedure and test discovered paths with fresh continuation trials. In ALFWorld and τ-bench retail, adding connectivity information improves predictions of task success on unseen task families, reducing Brier loss by 3.37%. The largest gains occur when initial-condition and interface changes are combined. The average predictive benefit extends to models and task families unseen during predictor training, although gains vary across models. We propose a recovery training method that selects checkpoints using success-region structure and trains agents to predict recovery success. Across three models, the resulting procedure raises success under changed task conditions by 5.12 percentage points over a baseline matched for training difficulty. When both methods use the same checkpoint selection rule at test time, the gain remains 4.19 points [95% CI: 1.88, 6.46], supporting a benefit from training itself. These results show that success-region connectivity provides useful information for predicting task success and guiding recovery learning.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, agent reliability, behavioral robustness, success-region connectivity, out-of-distribution generalization, recovery training

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_CYTcOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces interventional success regions: graphs of restartable agent checkpoints connected by executable history edits. It provides a counterexample showing that matched success rates and specified local statistics do not determine successful connectivity. Experiments study connectivity features for predicting OOD success.

Critical strengths

The paper studied an interesting question about agent reliability and used a mathematical framework for studying it.

Critical weaknesses
  • The recovery experiments do not clearly show which part of the method leads to the improvements, since several factors change between comparisons.
  • Important implementation details and experimental records are missing, making the reported results difficult to reproduce and fully verify.
Questions for authors
  • In Table D1, all nine cells have sd=0.000721, is this a typo?
  • The genai statement is "Generative AI tools were used to assist with manuscript editing, language polishing, and LaTeX typesetting.", but the attached code looks AI-generated too.
Reviewer_NVCUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether the connectivity between successful agent behaviors provides additional information about agent reliability beyond conventional success rates and local robustness measures. The authors introduce Interventional Success Regions, representing restartable checkpoints as nodes connected through executable history edits, and define Successful Connectivity to characterize success-preserving paths between checkpoints. A theoretical construction demonstrates that identical local reliability measurements can correspond to different connectivity structures. Experiments on ALFWorld and τ-bench show that connectivity features improve held-out success prediction, reducing Brier loss by 3.37%. A connectivity-guided recovery curriculum further improves shifted task success by 5.12 percentage points over difficulty-matched training.

Critical strengths

S1. A formally defined perspective on agent reliability.

The paper introduces a structural characterization of successful agent behaviors. Proposition 1 demonstrates that graphs with identical node-level success values and specified local measurements can exhibit different connectivity. This provides a theoretical foundation for studying behavioral relationships beyond conventional local reliability statistics.

S2. Empirical evaluation with meaningful controls.

The experiments include local-feature baselines, rewired-graph controls, and joint backbone/task-family holdout. Table 1 shows incremental predictive improvements, while Table 2 demonstrates recovery-training gains under both method-specific and fixed test-time selectors. These comparisons provide evidence supporting the proposed framework’s empirical utility.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Insufficient justification of the practical significance of successful connectivity.

The paper establishes that connectivity is mathematically distinct from local reliability measures, but does not convincingly explain why this distinction represents a practically important aspect of agent reliability. Two successful behaviors may be disconnected simply because they employ different strategies, without indicating any reliability deficiency. Moreover, connectivity depends on the chosen edit operations, graph construction, and path constraints (Sections 2–3). The paper does not sufficiently establish that the resulting structure captures a meaningful failure mode rather than a property of the measurement procedure. This weakens the fundamental motivation for introducing connectivity as a new reliability dimension.

W2. Insufficient evidence that connectivity is necessary for the reported practical benefits.

The diagnostic framework requires substantial graph construction, replay, and continuation evaluation, yet its main predictive improvement is a relatively modest 3.37% reduction in Brier loss (Table 1). The paper does not establish whether this benefit justifies the additional measurement cost compared with simpler robustness evaluations under matched budgets.

Furthermore, although the recovery curriculum improves task success, its gains cannot be attributed exclusively to global connectivity. In particular, Section 6.3 reports that a node-only selection rule reproduces the Global method’s selected training rows on a shared candidate bank. This raises doubts about whether the proposed global structure is essential to the recovery-training improvements.

Questions for authors
  1. Practical motivation: Can the authors provide a concrete example where disconnected successful behaviors indicate a meaningful reliability deficiency, rather than simply representing different successful strategies?
  2. Measurement dependence: How sensitive are the connectivity measurements and predictive results to the choice of edit operations, success threshold, and maximum path length?
  3. Cost-effectiveness: Under equivalent evaluation budgets, does connectivity-based prediction outperform simpler approaches based on additional perturbation tests or continuation-success measurements?
  4. Training contribution: Given that a node-only rule can reproduce the Global method’s selected training rows (Section 6.3), what additional benefit does global connectivity provide beyond node-level information?
Reviewer_C7sGOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether one successful behavior of an LLM agent can be turned into another valid edits without breaking reliable completion. The paper treats restartable checkpoints as nodes of a graph linked by executable edits to their histories, and measures how well the successful checkpoints are connecte. On ALFWorld and τ-bench retail, connectivity features improve the prediction of success under shift by a 3.4% relative reduction in Brier loss. Choosing recovery-training checkpoints from connectivity gaps raises shifted success by about 5 points over a difficulty-matched curriculum, which shows its positive impact in diagnosing agents and organizing recovery learning.

Critical strengths
  1. The question is new, as far as I know. This paper asks a different question. Given two different successful behaviors on the same task, is there a valid edits between them such that every intermediate checkpoint still succeeds reliably. The paper separates how much perturbation an agent tolerates and whether its successful behaviors are joined by reliable routes into two questions. Prior works not measures whether the success region is connected.

  2. The recovery study separates the full procedure from the trained actor. Panel (a) evaluates each curriculum with its own test-time selector, and panel (b) fixes the selector. The study also ablates the recovery targets and the graph context (Fig. 3), and it audits replay fidelity (L172–173).

Critical weaknesses

My main concerns are the following:

  1. The predictive gain is small and not robust From experiments results, the gain is small (0.0059 Brier) and the gain comes mainly from composed shifts. Connectivity also significantly hurts the strongest backbone, Claude Opus 5 (P1–P2 = −5.6 [−10.6, −0.9]). Most importantly, in a new experiement (R2), “new graph measurements and outcomes give P1–P2/P3–P2 gains of +0.005771/+0.004744. Scoring the same predictions against the original 7G outcomes changes them to −0.002398/−0.002130, with both intervals below zero”. Predictions from the R2 graph measurements help on R2 outcomes, but hurt on the original 7G outcomes, with both intervals below zero

The paper claims 4–5 pp gain comes from connectivity guided selection. but connectivity does not decide which checkpoint is trained. Gap pairs (score 0.8) always outrank connected pairs (0.05). Every gap pair also nominates the same fallback, "the lowest-numbered weak cycle node" (L316–317). Each round therefore trains on this one node (L354), and the paper notes that "a node-only rule reproduces Global's selected rows" (L421–422). Global vs. Matched thus compares the lowest-numbered weak node with the lowest-success weak node. Please state what node index encodes, and add a no-graph baseline that picks the earliest weak node or a random one.

  1. The paper is hard to follow. W7. The main text is hard to follow The paper includes lots of implementation details such as pair-ID tie-breaking, four-decimal rounding before the softmax, and the order in which breadth-first search visits neighbors (L317–325), while it leaves the basic objects to the appendices such a
  • what a task family, a shift and an edit are in each environment;
  • how the 240 graphs are built;
Questions for authors
  1. How are the registered graphs built? Do all of them have 20 nodes, a cycle and four anchors. What does node index encode?
  2. What are R2 and 7G? Do graph measurements and target executions share rollouts, seeds or environment instances?
  3. What is the total rollout and token cost per measured graph, for recovery training, and for evaluation?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.