acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SparRotQuant: Patterned Sparsity-Aware Rotation-Based Quantization for LLM Compression

13 views

Abstract

Low-bit quantization and semi-structured N:M sparsity are two hardware-friendly techniques for efficient large language model deployment. However, their direct combination suffers from a structural conflict: rotation-based quantization smooths weight distributions to improve low-bit representations, whereas N:M sparsity relies on strong local contrast within each weight group to determine a stable keep/prune pattern. Consequently, applying N:M pruning after rotation produces unstable sparse masks and significant quality degradation. We propose SparRotQuant, a sparsity-aware rotation-based quantization framework that incorporates the N:M sparsity constraint into calibration, aligning the learned sparse support with the rotated low-bit representation used for deployment. To guide this process, we introduce Probability-aware Balanced Group Separation (PBGS), a group-level criterion that combines retention probability with Hessian-aware sensitivity to encourage each weight group to form a reliable sparse pattern before hard projection. With frozen pretrained weights, SparRotQuant learns differentiable sparse masks during calibration while adapting rotations and quantization parameters to the resulting sparse low-bit representation. Experiments across multiple model families show that SparRotQuant maintains strong model quality under W4A4KV16 and W4A4KV4 while preserving the efficiency benefits of sparse low-bit execution.

Primary area:
infrastructure, software libraries, hardware, systems, etc.
Keywords:
model compression, GPU acceleration, hardware-aware optimization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.60 over 5 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_c4LuOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SparRotQuant, a framework that jointly optimizes rotation-based quantization and 2:4 semi-structured sparsity for LLM compression. It addresses the incompatibility between quantization-oriented rotations and stable sparse patterns by introducing Probability-aware Balanced Group Separation (PBGS), which combines retention probabilities and Hessian-aware sensitivity to guide differentiable mask learning. The framework applies exact 2:4 pruning to five selected linear projections alongside low-bit quantization. Experiments on LLaMA2, LLaMA3, and Qwen3 under W4A4KV16 and W4A4KV4 demonstrate improved perplexity and zero-shot accuracy over sparse quantization baselines, alongside inference speedups and memory savings.

Critical strengths
  1. Joint optimization of quantization and structured sparsity. SparRotQuant introduces PBGS to encourage stable 2:4 sparsity patterns while jointly optimizing rotation matrices, differentiable pruning masks, and quantization parameters. This provides a possible approach to addressing the incompatibility between rotation-based quantization and structured pruning, potentially improving the quality of jointly compressed LLMs.

  2. Comprehensive experimental validation with practical efficiency gains. Experiments across multiple LLM families demonstrate consistent improvements in perplexity and zero-shot accuracy over existing sparse quantization baselines. The ablation studies further support the effectiveness of PBGS, while hardware-level and end-to-end evaluations demonstrate meaningful inference acceleration and memory savings.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient novelty and missing closely related work. The paper overlooks DenoiseRotator[1] and RotPruner[2], which similarly employs learnable rotations to concentrate weight importance and improve pruning robustness. Despite the substantial conceptual overlap, the authors neither discuss this closely related work nor provide experimental comparisons. This raises concerns about the novelty of SparRotQuant and whether PBGS offers meaningful improvements beyond existing rotation-based pruning methods.

  2. Limited pruning scope and insufficient experimental justification. SparRotQuant applies 2:4 pruning to only five linear projections, excluding W_o and W_down, whereas DenoiseRotator supports pruning all seven projections. Although the authors discuss coupled approximation errors, their analysis does not sufficiently justify excluding these important layers. Furthermore, the rotation-placement ablations involve different amounts of pruned parameters, making the comparisons potentially confounded. The lack of experiments with all seven projections and matched model-wide sparsity raises concerns about the generality and actual compression effectiveness of the proposed method.

  3. Typos

  • Line 391: "SparRotQuant calibration deployment workflow" -> "SparRotQuant calibration and deployment workflow"

[1] DenoiseRotator: Enhance Pruning Robustness for LLMs via Importance Concentration. NeurIPS 2025

[2] RotPruner: Large Language Model Pruning in Rotated Space. https://openreview.net/forum?id=wV9iMiyQcc

Questions for authors
  1. Novelty relative to Existing Works. DenoiseRotator and RotPruner similarly employ learnable rotations to concentrate weight importance and improve pruning robustness. Why is this closely related work not discussed? Can the authors clarify the fundamental differences between PBGS and DenoiseRotator's importance concentration objective, particularly regarding their methodological novelty?

  2. Comparison with DenoiseRotator. Can the authors provide experimental comparisons with DenoiseRotator under matched quantization settings, calibration protocols, and pruning budgets? Such comparisons would help establish whether SparRotQuant offers meaningful improvements over existing rotation-based pruning methods.

  3. Limited pruning scope and experimental fairness. Why does SparRotQuant exclude WoW_o and WdownW_{\mathrm{down}} from 2:4 pruning, whereas DenoiseRotator supports all seven linear projections? Can the authors evaluate sparsification of these additional layers and report model-wide sparsity ratios? Furthermore, can they provide rotation-placement ablations under matched overall sparsity budgets to distinguish the effects of coupled approximation errors from those of pruning more parameters?

Reviewer_g7qMOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the interaction between rotation based quantization and structured sparsity. Its motivation is that rotations learned for a dense quantized model can weaken the local differences used to select sparse patterns. SparRotQuant therefore learns rotations, differentiable hard concrete gates, and quantization parameters together while keeping pretrained weights frozen. Its central criterion is Probability aware Balanced Group Separation, referred to as PBGS. This criterion combines retention probability, Hessian sensitivity, and squared rotated weight magnitude. Then it encourages the resulting saliency to concentrate on two entries in each four element group. After calibration, the method selects binary masks for the query, key, value, up, and gate projections. It then performs a short recovery stage that updates only quantization parameters.

Experiments cover LLaMA2, LLaMA3, and Qwen3 under W4A4KV16 and W4A4KV4. On LLaMA2 7B under W4A4KV16, SparRotQuant improves average accuracy from 60.76 to 61.89 and reduces WikiText2 perplexity from 6.62 to 6.49 relative to sparse SpinQuant. The paper also reports comparisons at equal calibration time, results using C4 calibration, and measurements of sparse operator and model prefill efficiency.

Critical strengths
  1. Learning the sparse representation during rotation calibration is well motivated. The final pruning decision depends on the transformed weights rather than the original representation. The method addresses this dependence directly. It does not assume that rotations optimized for dense quantization will remain suitable after pruning.

  2. The improvement over sparse SpinQuant appears across four models and both KV precision settings. It also persists when calibration uses C4. Table D.3 compares methods at the same calibration time and applies the same recovery procedure. This provides evidence that longer calibration alone does not explain the gain.

  3. The deployment evaluation includes sparse operator correctness checks and measured prefill performance. It does not rely only on nominal sparsity. Appendix C.1 also makes clear that sparse SpinQuant and SparRotQuant have comparable efficiency under the same sparse kernel. This appropriately separates model quality from acceleration provided by the shared representation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is that Table 2 does not isolate the full PBGS objective. The No PBGS variant also changes the final projection rule. It keeps the largest gate probabilities rather than using the complete saliency score. The probability only row supports a separation loss in that simpler setting. However, a comparison using the same full saliency for projection is still needed. Only then can we attribute the main gain to PBGS during calibration, rather than just a change in the exported mask selection.

  2. The mechanism analysis also leaves a gap. Figure 7 measures the stability of the minimum reconstruction cost pattern. But this pattern need not be the pattern selected by the PBGS saliency used for export. Moreover, Figure D.2 starts from the shared dense initialization rather than the final relaxed model. So neither experiment directly measures how faithfully the learned soft gates translate into the deployed binary masks before recovery.

  3. The Hessian sensitivity is central to both PBGS and final mask selection. Yet Equation 10 and Algorithm A.1 describe it only as a statistic estimated from calibration data. Without an explicit estimation rule, it remains unclear which reconstruction objective defines this sensitivity. It is also unclear whether it uses the current rotated activations and how it is updated as the learned rotation changes. All of these directly affect the criterion being optimized.

  4. Table D.1 does not isolate the explanation for avoiding joint sparsity placement because the compared variants prune different fractions of the model. Memory decreases from 3.39 GB for input rotation placement to 2.91 GB for joint placement. The lower accuracy of the joint variant may therefore reflect stronger overall compression rather than the coupled interface error emphasized in Observation 2. So the experiment does not yet establish that explanation under a matched total sparsity budget.

Questions for authors
  1. I think the No PBGS comparison in Table 2 needs a small adjustment. Right now, the variant also changes the projection rule, so it's hard to see the effect of the full PBGS objective alone. If we keep the complete saliency score for projection and use the same initialization, calibration time, and recovery, does the gain still hold? This would separate the learning objective from the final selection rule.

  2. How stable are the masks actually selected by SparRotQuant? It would be great to see model quality right before and after replacing the relaxed gates with binary masks, before recovery. Connecting these changes back to PBGS and the minimum cost margins in Figure 7 would directly test if the criterion predicts the behavior of the deployed masks.

  3. The Hessian sensitivity is a black box right now. Equation 10 and Algorithm A.1 only say it is estimated from calibration data. What is the exact reconstruction objective and formula? Which activations define it? Also, how often is it refreshed as rotations change, and is it held fixed during each update? Answering these would fully specify the optimization in Equation 17.

  4. For Table D.1, the variants prune different fractions of the model, so the comparison is unfair. Could we compare input rotation, output rotation, and joint placement using the same total number of retained weights? Reporting the targeted projections and storage for each variant would separate the degradation from the value/output interface and the effect of just pruning more weights.

Reviewer_c6pzOpenReview ↗
Rating
4
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents a method for combining rotation-based low-bit quantization with structured group (N:M) sparsity. The core problem is that rotation based quantization benefits from quantizing weights in a uniform space, while structured group sparsity operates best when values are naturally spread. The authors solve this by adding a differentiable sparsification complementary importance-based retention objective to the train time quantization to optimize the two in tandem. They show results across a variety of model sizes and tasks with consistent improvements for their method over the baselines. They provide rigorous ablations for the design choices.

The paper is dense with technical detail, but the authors do a sufficient job of making the high level goal clear. Where I would like to see more intuitive description and motivation is in the derivations of both the "Observations" and PBGS loss components. The results are significant and show a clear value in the application of the techniques. Appropriate ablations are done to show the necessity of each component (which is much appreciated with the number of components involved). I did find that the Figure 1, while visually appealing, is not the best presentation of many bar charts for accuracy that each need more space to be clearly interpreted. I would suggest breaking out each barchart (rather than organizing them circularly) and limiting the result in the main paper and providing the rest in the appendix.

Critical strengths

The paper tackles a difficult problem of combining two optimizations that are seemingly at odd and shows clear gains above the two on their own.

Critical weaknesses

The paper has a lot going on, both in terms of number of techniques and number of results. More could be done to direct the reader's attention to the most important components.

Questions for authors

Have sparsity-first, quantization-second approaches been considered?

Reviewer_xdAgOpenReview ↗
Rating
4
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SparRotQuant addresses the conflict between rotation-based quantization and 2:4 structured sparsity, where rotations that improve quantization can make subsequent pruning more damaging. It jointly optimizes rotations, differentiable masks, and quantization parameters while freezing pretrained weights, using a PBGS objective that combines retention probabilities, Hessian sensitivity, and weight magnitudes to encourage clear keep/prune separation. Experiments on four LLaMA and Qwen models under W4A4KV16 and W4A4KV4 report quality improvements over sparse SpinQuant, supported by component ablations, mask-stability analysis, and kernel and prefill efficiency benchmarks

Critical strengths
  1. Clear motivation and an interpretable methodological contribution. The paper presents a clear and well-motivated analysis of the tension between rotation-based quantization and structured sparsity. Its joint calibration framework and PBGS objective translate this insight into an understandable approach that encourages local weight groups to become suitable for exact 2:4 projection. I consider this consequential because it provides a useful design principle for jointly optimizing quantization and sparsity, potentially informing further research. The calibration-specific components are removed before deployment, preserving the existing sparse low-bit execution format.

  2. Broad empirical evaluation supported by mechanism-focused analysis. These experiments help connect the observed quality improvements to the intended sparse-pattern formation mechanism and assess their robustness across settings. This combination of performance results and targeted analysis strengthens my confidence in the practical value of the proposed approach.

Critical weaknesses

The kernel comparison lacks sufficient implementation detail. Appendix C.1 states that the proposed kernel stores INT4 values but executes INT8 sparse MMA instructions, while Table C.1 reports approximately 1.5× speedup over dense INT4 SpinQuant. Given the comparable theoretical effective throughput of sparse INT8 and dense INT4 on RTX 4090, the source of this improvement needs clarification. The authors should specify the dense baseline’s implementation and instruction path, clarify whether conversion and scaling costs are consistently included, and explain the main performance bottlenecks. These omissions make the fairness and reproducibility of the efficiency comparison difficult to assess.

Questions for authors
  1. Which kernel and MMA instructions are used for the dense INT4 SpinQuant baseline, and do both timings consistently include conversion and scaling costs?

  2. What explains the approximately 1.5× speedup, given the comparable theoretical effective throughput of sparse INT8 and dense INT4 on RTX 4090?

2 comments

Thank you for the comprehensive response, which addresses most of my concerns. I will keep my original score.

We sincerely thank you for your kind response, thoughtful evaluation, and continued support of our work! We are especially grateful for your clear accept recommendation and your acknowledgment that our rebuttal has addressed most of your concerns. Your constructive feedback has been invaluable in strengthening our manuscript and experimental analysis. We deeply appreciate the time and care you have devoted to our paper, and your encouragement means a great deal to us. Thank you once again for your generosity and thoughtful consideration.

Reviewer_DCJxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

SparRotQuant, a sparsity-aware rotation-based quantization framework, is proposed for LLM compression. Moreover, Probability-aware Balanced Group Separation (PBGS) is integrated. Several experiments reveal certain advantages of SparRotQuant.

Critical strengths

1, The overall proposed methods are clearly modelled and has a clear motivation.

2, LLM compression is an important research topic in the current era. Generally speaking, the proposed methods in this manuscript are interesting.

3, The presented experimental results may indicate some possible futural applications.

Critical weaknesses

1, Some presentations are not valid and are somewhat strange. I do not quite know whether such presentations are directly generated by LLMs without manual verification. For example, In Section 2, when authors comment Rotation-based quantization, they write "However, these objectives are mainly designed for dense quantized inference and do not explicitly model the local N:M structural constraints required by hardware-friendly sparse patterns." N:M structure constraints are tools instead of goals, the goal is the overall compression and quality. N:M structural constraints are not necessary for every quantization approach. Moreover, in Section 2, when authors comment Hessian-guided compression, they write "These methods show the value of curvature for preserving compressed model quality,but mainly use it after the compression target is fixed." It is confusing to say after the compression target is fixed as clearly, compression methods come after the targets are fixed. Meanwhile, the format of Learnable Differentiable Mask in Section 2 is also strange, where the words "Learnable Differentiable Mask" suddenly just jumped to a new line.There are quantities of similar presentations, and I just list three.

2, The PBGS is rooted in 2:4 sparsity. However, such fixed sparsity does not sound well in the context of general N:M sparsity. Even its objective is built on the average of group scores over all target 2:4 group. Why 2:4 is chosen, whether 2:4 is general in compression-oriented practical applications or whether 2:4 is actually a good choice are not demonstrated in the manuscript. The overall idea and methodological flow of PBGS seems rather limited.

3, The theoretical parts of this manuscript are weak. The approaches are generally heuristic without any proven theories. Whether there might some error bounds or computation complexity bounds are not presented.

4, Numerical stability is important in the context of LLM compression. The low-precision or sparsity may reduce the actual orthogonality in the rotation or whether the proposed quantization approaches has good numerical stability is not discussed in the manuscript.

5, Although experiments conducted in RTX 4090 is acceptable, considering the heuristic natures of authors' proposed approaches, authors are encouraged to discuss whether their approaches sound well in larger LLMs or more modern hardware. Specially, whether the advantages of SparRotQuant still hold for more modern hardware or larger LLMs should be further demonstrated.

6, Generally speaking, the improvements over SpinQuant are moderate. Authors are encouraged to demonstrate more advantages over SpinQuant.

7, The overall experiments are conducted under the fixed 2:4 sparsity. Whether changing the rigid setting may result in different leaders remains unclear.

8, LLM compression is a popular topic. However, authors do not compare their methods with other important baselines, such as baselines mentioned in Section 2 and the following papers. It is important for authors to incorporate such comparisons, as the compression is the goal instead of N:M sparsity.

[1] MaskPro: Linear-Space Probabilistic Learning for Strict (N:M)-Sparsity on Large Language Models. ICLR 2026. https://arxiv.org/html/2506.12876v1

[2] Accelerating LLM Inference with Flexible N:M Sparsity via A Fully Digital Compute-in-Memory Accelerator. https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.14365

Questions for authors

I will carefully read authors' feedback in the rebuttal stage. I would be willing to change my scores if it is necessary.

1, If one changes 2:4 sparsity, will your proposed approaches perform well? Please conduct some experiments to validate your points.

2, Could you demonstrate the numerical stability of your approaches?

3, Whether the advantages of SparRotQuant still hold for more modern hardware or larger LLMs should be further demonstrated.

4, Could you conduct experiments over other settings instead of fixed 2:4 sparsity?

5, Please conduct experiments to compare your work with the following baselines and the important baselines mentioned in Section 2.

[1] MaskPro: Linear-Space Probabilistic Learning for Strict (N:M)-Sparsity on Large Language Models. ICLR 2026. https://arxiv.org/html/2506.12876v1

[2] Accelerating LLM Inference with Flexible N:M Sparsity via A Fully Digital Compute-in-Memory Accelerator. https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.14365

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.