acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Answer Quality: Prediction and Execution under Privileged Distillation

Abstract

Recent on-policy self-distillation (OPSD) methods have shown promise for improving language-model reasoning. A common form of OPSD uses privileged distillation, in which the teacher receives additional information, such as the correct answer, that is unavailable to the student. Yet studies of reasoning models also report cases where privileged supervision lowers answer accuracy and reduces the benefits of longer reasoning. Despite these observations, theoretical understanding of why such failures occur remains limited, making it difficult to understand when privileged supervision helps or hurts and how it should be improved. To address this gap, we develop a theoretical framework that separates two effects of privileged supervision: how well the student answers after completing the required reasoning steps (prediction), and whether it carries those reasoning steps through to completion (execution). We show that privileged supervision can make the student better at predicting the final answer once the required reasoning has been completed, while making it less likely to complete that reasoning on its own. As a result, better final-answer prediction can coexist with worse overall performance. We further show that this separation can emerge during finite distillation because learning at later reasoning steps depends on whether the student actually reaches those steps. Finally, we show a complementary effect on the teacher side: when privileged teachers are more likely to answer early, later reasoning steps are increasingly shaped by the teachers that continue reasoning. This changes what the student learns at those later steps, so different forms of privileged distillation can lead to different reasoning behavior. Experiments with Qwen3 and natural reasoning tasks provide qualitative support for these mechanisms.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
on-policy self-distillation, OPSD, privileged distillation, reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_n6JvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Paper mentions that privileged distillation can make a student better at predicting the final answer while simultaneously making it worse at actually performing the reasoning needed to reach that answer. Therefore, not necessarily better answer prediction means better reasoning, because the privileged teacher may have a high probability of producing the final answer immediately and when the student does reach the end, the privileged teacher provides a better answer signal. Also there are less training of later reasoning, as later reasoning steps receive training only if the student reaches them. Paper also compared different ways of assigning teacher targets (RETAIN, RELABEL, ON, and PROCESS).

  • RETAIN (Keep the teacher identity that generated the trajectory and target will be generated by the same teacher condition)
  • RELABEL(Keep the same prefix, but independently sample which teacher condition provides the target)
  • ON (Prefix is generated by the student, while the teacher target is generated under an independently sampled privilege condition)
  • PROCESS (Prefix is generated by the student; intermediate tokens use the unprivileged teacher as the target, while the terminal position uses a mixture of privileged and unprivileged teacher targets) An interesting result is that there is no universally best protocol. The effectiveness of each protocol depends on how the teacher condition, trajectory generation, and target assignment interact.
Critical strengths
  • A clear and useful prediction–execution decomposition: The paper identifies an important failure mode of privileged OPD: privileged supervision can improve the student's final-answer prediction while simultaneously reducing its probability of completing the reasoning process. Separating forced accuracy, free accuracy, and completion makes this phenomenon directly measurable and provides a substantially more informative lens than final-answer accuracy alone. This is consequential because it offers a concrete explanation for otherwise puzzling cases where distillation improves conditional answer quality but harms end-to-end reasoning performance.
  • A systematic comparison of different supervision and teacher-assignment protocols. The paper does more than evaluate a single distillation strategy: it compares multiple protocols, including ON vs. PROCESS and RETAIN vs. RELABEL, to study how the choice of teacher targets and the handling of teacher identity across trajectories affect learning. This is useful because it helps disentangle whether the observed behavior arises simply from privileged answer information or from how that information is propagated and assigned during the student's reasoning trajectory.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited evaluation on challenging reasoning tasks and larger models: The evaluation is primarily conducted with a Qwen3-1.7B model and relatively simple tasks such as sequential lookup and GSM8K. It remains unclear whether the observed prediction–execution tradeoff persists for substantially harder reasoning benchmarks, where longer and more careful reasoning may be genuinely necessary (e.g., AIME), or for larger reasoning models. Evaluating the method on challenging mathematical reasoning datasets such as AIME, would substantially strengthen the claim that the observed execution effects generalize beyond the controlled experimental setting.
  • The paper does not sufficiently distinguish harmful premature termination from beneficial shorter reasoning: The theoretical setup has a fixed number of required intermediate computations, making "completion" well-defined, but natural reasoning tasks generally do not have a known required reasoning length. Consequently, reduced thinking-token counts on GSM8K cannot by themselves establish degraded execution; shorter trajectories may reflect more efficient reasoning rather than premature termination.
Questions for authors
  • EARLY-PRIV deliberately gives the teacher an 80% probability of continuing and 20% probability of producing the correct answer early at intermediate decisions. The purpose is to isolate the execution mechanism. I understand that if privileged supervision changes the teacher's stopping behavior, that behavior can transfer to the student. But does naturally occurring privileged distillation in real OPSD systems actually cause this problem? Is EARLY-PRIV realistic?
  • Is shorter reasoning necessarily bad? There are some previous work mentioning shorter reasoning can be beneficial. I agree that premature answers can be harmful, but early answer does not mean bad execution.
  • Lookup task has a known required computation depth, but a model could legitimately answer(in your case solve a math problem) without a long chain.
  • Suggest having evaluation on more challenging reasoning tasks, and larger models.
3 comments

Thank you for emphasizing the distinction between harmful premature termination and efficient, concise reasoning, and for suggesting harder tasks and larger models. We agree that a short successful solution can be preferable to a longer one.

Our goal is to characterize a setting in which the computation required by the task is observable, and then examine which aspects of that mechanism are supported by language-model experiments. Below, we clarify this distinction and report the expanded evaluation and matched control.


1. Why Shorter Reasoning Is Not Necessarily Worse

Our completion measure is tied to the specified computational task. In the staged-reveal construction, future lookups are revealed through the task interface, and completion requires five correct intermediate states before answering. This gives an observable criterion for execution that a natural-language token count does not provide.

For natural mathematics, a student may legitimately skip a verbose derivation or find a shorter valid route. The paper's natural-language length results do not distinguish such efficiency from omission of necessary computation. We will make this limitation explicit in the abstract and experimental interpretation.


2. Harder Tasks and Larger Models

We evaluated fixed public Qwen3-8B BASE, math-SDPO, and math-GRPO checkpoints on both complete AIME test sets:

DatasetBASESDPOGRPO
AIME202423/3018/3021/30
AIME202521/3011/3020/30

On all 500 MATH500 problems, BASE and SDPO score 488/500 and 473/500, respectively. The paired SDPO-minus-BASE difference is −3.0 pp (95% CI: [−5.0, −1.2]), while mean generated length decreases from 5,474 to 2,653 tokens.

These evaluations broaden the observed coexistence of shorter output and lower accuracy to harder mathematics and 8B models. They do not separately measure terminal prediction and necessary-computation completion. The public checkpoints were not retrained under matched conditions, and SDPO uses JSD/TopK100/EMA0 rather than the paper's forward-KL protocol. Each problem uses one fixed sampling stream. We will present these results as expanded empirical coverage with these qualifications.


3. What the Matched EARLY–ZERO Comparison Establishes

EARLY's 20% early-answer mass is an experimental intervention, not an estimate of a universal rate in natural distillation. Its purpose is to test the consequences of early-answer supervision in a task where required computation can be measured.

In a separately recalibrated reconstruction, we added ZERO with the same legal-action normalization and trie construction, setting early-answer mass to zero in the adapted privileged intermediate-action branch. The natural unreferenced branch and off-support fallback remain. At the primary update-8 checkpoint, EARLY minus ZERO reduces completion by 26.48 pp (95% CI: [−31.17, −21.95]) and free accuracy by 22.19 pp (95% CI: [−26.49, −17.81]).

We also classified the first failure of completion across five fitted models evaluated on the same 256 questions:

Training ConditionFirst Failure: Early AnswerFirst Failure: Incorrect Continuation
TERM390
ZERO110
EARLY3491

Within this controlled task, completion failures are predominantly early answers. These counts are repeated evaluations of 256 shared questions, rather than 1,280 independent problems. The confidence intervals likewise condition on the common calibration and fixed fits. Forced accuracy also decreases under EARLY, so this reconstruction does not reproduce the original three-way signature of improved forced accuracy with worse completion and free accuracy.


4. What the Natural Continuation Interventions Show

To examine the distinction on natural tasks, we conducted two exploratory AIME continuation interventions. Neither established an accuracy recovery attributable to additional thinking. The distinction between concise reasoning and harmful premature termination therefore remains unresolved for the observed natural-task accuracy losses.

A subsequent audit found that all 107 AIME native outputs containing a closing marker already contained a complete boxed integer candidate before that marker; the remaining 13 outputs had no closing marker. This locates the intervention after an explicit candidate has appeared. It does not establish that necessary computation was complete, explain the unsuccessful outcome, or show that an earlier intervention would succeed.

Thank you again for this distinction and for the suggestions on evaluation. We will incorporate the harder-task results and matched control while making clear that the natural-task observations do not establish that shorter reasoning itself caused the accuracy losses.

Thanks for the detailed response and the additional experiments. The EARLY–ZERO comparison is helpful and provides stronger evidence for the proposed mechanism in the controlled setting. The AIME and MATH500 results also improve the evaluation.

However, my main concern remains partially unresolved. The larger-model experiments use checkpoints that were not trained under matched conditions, so it is difficult to attribute the observed accuracy differences to privileged distillation. Also, the continuation experiments do not show a clear accuracy improvement from additional reasoning.

I appreciate your efforts to address my concerns. I find the idea interesting, but I think further evidence is needed. I therefore maintain my Weak Reject rating, although I acknowledge that the additional experiments have strengthened the paper.

Thank you for your thoughtful follow-up and for recognizing that the additional experiments strengthen our paper. We appreciate your acknowledgment of the EARLY–ZERO comparison and the expanded evaluation on AIME and MATH500.

We agree that the unmatched 8B checkpoints do not establish a causal effect of privileged distillation, and that our continuation experiments do not demonstrate a clear accuracy improvement from additional reasoning. These are important limitations that we will make more explicit in the revised manuscript.

We will also sharpen the distinction between the mechanisms established in our theoretical and controlled settings and the observations on natural reasoning tasks, ensuring that our conclusions accurately reflect the available evidence.

Thank you again for your careful evaluation and constructive feedback, which have helped us improve both the experimental validation and the presentation of our work.

Reviewer_1k3AOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies privileged distillation by distinguishing prediction from execution. In a controlled setting, it shows how improved terminal prediction can coexist with lower overall accuracy. The analysis extends to a finite number of updates using exact expected gradients, where later steps receive training only when reached, and teacher-trajectory selection, where early-answering privileged teachers become underrepresented at deeper prefixes. Controlled Qwen3-1.7B experiments demonstrate the separation under an early-answer intervention. Natural-language experiments show shorter reasoning and changes in teacher composition, but do not establish consistent accuracy degradation.

Critical strengths
  • A novel prediction-execution perspective on OPSD. The distinction provides a useful way to understand why better answer supervision need not improve overall performance. Within the paper’s framework, the explanation is clear: a student can inherit a privileged teacher’s tendency to answer early without having the information that makes early answering appropriate.
  • A timely theoretical analysis of OPSD. Understanding how on-policy self-distillation changes reasoning behavior is an important question. The paper contributes a theoretical treatment of both student training exposure and teacher-trajectory selection, providing useful concepts for examining effects that final-answer accuracy alone can miss.
Critical weaknesses
  • The connection to practical privileged distillation failures remains limited. The main failure case uses an artificial adapter that encourages early answers in a constrained lookup task. Without this intervention, privileged supervision improves performance, while natural-language experiments show shorter reasoning without consistent accuracy loss. Thus, the experiments establish a possible failure mechanism but leave its role in naturally occurring failures unresolved.

  • Weak connection to other theoretical and analytical works. While OPSD is a timely and important topic, prior studies have already examined its failure modes, including suppressed uncertainty expression [1], information leakage and training instability [2], and limitations of learning from instance-specific privileged information [3]. The paper does not sufficiently clarify how its prediction-execution perspective relates to these explanations or what additional diagnostic or practical insights it provides.

[1] Jeonghye Kim et al. Why Does Self-Distillation (Sometimes) Degrade the Reasoning Capability of LLMs?

[2] Chenxu Yang et al. Self-Distilled RLVR

[3] Siqi Zhu et al. The Many Faces of On-Policy Distillation: Pitfalls, Mechanisms, and Fixes

Questions for authors

Q1. Have you observed accuracy degradation caused by transferred stopping behavior without the artificial early-answer adapter? An intervention that mitigates such degradation would help establish the mechanism’s practical relevance.

Q2. How does the prediction-execution mechanism relate to the failure explanations in [1-3]? Does it identify a distinct failure mode, and what additional diagnostic or practical implications follow?

Q3. Does the observed prediction-execution separation persist in models larger than 1.7B? Analysis of a larger model would help clarify whether the findings extend beyond the current model scale.

3 comments

Thank you for recognizing the value of the prediction–execution perspective and for emphasizing the evidence needed to connect a formal failure mechanism to naturally occurring degradation. Your requests motivated additional natural-task evaluations, continuation interventions, and measurements of actual student behavior.

The new results broaden the empirical coverage and strengthen specific controlled findings. The natural stopping attribution, a successful mitigation, and a strict prediction–execution separation above 1.7B remain open. We address these points directly below.


1. Natural-Task Degradation and Continuation Interventions

Without the artificial early-answer adapter, fixed public 8B BASE and math-SDPO checkpoints score 488/500 and 473/500 on MATH500, respectively: a paired difference of −3.0 pp (95% CI: [−5.0, −1.2]), with mean generated length decreasing from 5,474 to 2,653 tokens. On AIME2024 and AIME2025, BASE scores 23/30 and 21/30, versus SDPO's 18/30 and 11/30. These observations document shorter output alongside lower accuracy. The checkpoints were not retrained under matched conditions, and public SDPO uses JSD/TopK100/EMA0 rather than our forward-KL setup.

To test whether further continuation recovers accuracy, we conducted two interventions with different protocols:

AIME EvaluationSDPO ComparisonCorrect Answers
32-problem exploratory subsetNative vs. delayed closure (DEFER)17/32 vs. 17/32
28-problem complement: frozen scoringImmediate readout (R0) vs. additional thinking (R1)2/28 vs. 4/28
28-problem complement: post-hoc extraction sensitivityR0 vs. R113/28 vs. 13/28
  • Delayed Closure: DEFER rescues no SDPO native errors. A suffix-token-matched RESAMPLE comparator scores 14/32, but DEFER's difference from it has a confidence interval touching zero: +9.375 pp [0, 21.875]. All three wins arise from RESAMPLE losing previously correct answers. This does not establish a successful rescue.
  • Additional Thinking Before a Common Readout: On the 28-problem complement, R1 adds up to 1,024 thinking tokens before the same answer readout used by R0, with a separate 256-token answer budget. The frozen comparison has two wins, zero losses, and 26 ties: +7.14 pp (95% CI: [0, 17.86]), with exact two-sided McNemar p=0.50p=0.50. The primary test did not pass.
  • Sensitivity to Answer Extraction: A single fixed post-hoc rule extracts an answer only when the first nonempty line strictly matches Final answer: <integer from 0 to 999>; otherwise it preserves the frozen score. Under this analysis, R0 and R1 tie on every question for both models. The rule changes 27 correctness labels across the 168 BASE/SDPO × native/R0/R1 outputs, showing material readout sensitivity. It does not replace the original endpoint or establish an additional-thinking benefit.

The two subsets use different protocols and are not pooled into an AIME60 intervention effect. These results provide no confirmed accuracy recovery attributable to additional reasoning.

We also audited intervention timing: all 107 AIME native outputs containing a closing marker already contain a complete boxed integer candidate before it. This shows that the interventions operate after an explicit candidate has appeared. It does not explain the null results, establish completion of necessary computation, or imply that an earlier intervention would succeed. We will report these unsuccessful interventions and the unresolved causal attribution explicitly.

2. Additional Insight Beyond Existing Explanations

We agree that the relationship to the following work should be explicit:

  • Kim et al. [1]: Their analysis already connects richer teacher context to epistemic behavior, shorter responses, and reasoning degradation. We contribute a formal account of how improved terminal prediction can coexist with reduced completion under specified computational constraints.
  • Yang et al. [2]: They already formalize privileged-information marginalization. Our additional question is how the resulting targets interact with computational progress: an answer may be appropriate for a teacher with privileged information before the student's current readout can use that information.
  • Zhu et al. [3]: They already study distillation pitfalls including prefix mismatch. Our teacher-collected analysis holds the collection distribution fixed and examines the association between the collection reference condition and the condition used to supply labels.

These distinctions lead to concrete theoretical objects. Theorem 1 derives when completion loss outweighs terminal prediction gain. Theorem 2 derives finite population-update dynamics in which later learning depends on how often those states are reached, even without sampled-gradient noise. Theorem 3 derives how survival-dependent labeling changes fitted continuation and terminal channels under its assumptions. These mechanisms can complement existing explanations; they do not identify which mechanism caused a particular natural-task failure.

The labeling distinction now has direct student-behavior evidence. With the same collected GSM8K prefixes, RELABEL increases native close/EOS within the next 256 tokens by 12.82 pp and 8.97 pp in two fitting seeds (question-clustered 95% CIs: [3.95, 23.61] and [1.35, 17.14]). Full-answer accuracy differences remain inconclusive. This establishes a behavioral consequence of label assignment without establishing harmful omission of necessary computation.

The resulting diagnostic implication is to measure terminal prediction, completion, exposure to later training states, and the collection–label association separately when the task permits. A reduction in response length alone cannot identify an execution failure. We will organize the contribution and empirical discussion around these measurable distinctions.

References

[1] Kim et al. Why Does Self-Distillation (Sometimes) Degrade the Reasoning Capability of LLMs? arXiv:2603.24472v4, 2026.

[2] Yang et al. Self-Distilled RLVR. arXiv:2604.03128v2, 2026.

[3] Zhu et al. The Many Faces of On-Policy Distillation: Pitfalls, Mechanisms, and Fixes. arXiv:2605.11182v2, 2026.


3. What the 8B Evaluation Establishes

The complete AIME evaluations and BASE/SDPO MATH500 evaluations extend model and task coverage. They do not separately measure terminal prediction and necessary-computation completion. We therefore cannot claim that the strict prediction–execution separation has been demonstrated above 1.7B.

We will distinguish this open empirical question from the formal results, the original controlled demonstration, and the new student-behavior evidence. The abstract and conclusions will be revised to reflect that scope.

Thank you again for these constructive questions. They have helped us state more precisely what the theory explains, which behavioral predictions have additional support, and which natural-task causal claims still require evidence.

Thank you for the detailed response.

The experiment on two intervention provide additional results that no confirmed accuracy recovery attributable to additional reasoning. Also, the discussion of related work strengthens the connection to prior research helps me understand this work. However, my concern about generalization to larger models remains, especially since the main result was obtained with a small-scale model (1.7B). I highly recommend to address this concern in the future revision.

I will maintain my score.

Reviewer_vPb1OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2(−1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how privileged distillation can improve final-answer prediction while reducing the probability of completing the computation needed to answer. It develops a controlled lookup framework to analyze how stopping affects learning and the supervision available at later reasoning steps. The experiments illustrate performance separation in controlled settings, while the natural-task results show changes in reasoning length and the composition of surviving teacher trajectories.

Critical strengths

Prediction and execution as distinct outcomes. I find it useful to treat the decision to continue as a distinct outcome of distillation. A teacher with extra information can choose to stop in situations where the student still needs intermediate computation, making this a useful perspective on potential transfer failures.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Unclear added theoretical insight. The additional insight beyond the stated intuitions remains unclear to me. In particular, the role of teacher-collected RETAIN/RELABEL in extending the earlier student-collected OPSD analysis is insufficiently motivated. The teacher-trajectory study establishes an expected selection effect, but its consequences for student stopping and accuracy remain unresolved.

  2. Limited empirical support for the failure mechanism. NATURAL-FULL has the highest mean free accuracy and full completion in Table 1, with natural teachers almost always continuing at intermediate steps. The boundary between this beneficial regime and premature-answering failures remains unclear to me. The staged-reveal failure demonstration uses EARLY-PRIV, which also changes token support and within-action targets. GSM8K shows shorter reasoning with largely preserved long-budget accuracy, leaving me unsure which theoretical mechanism these length results validate.

Questions for authors
  1. What measured consequence for student trajectories or accuracy can be attributed to retaining versus independently assigning the teacher's reference condition, beyond the teacher-collection selection effect in Appendix A.2.5?

  2. Can the natural teacher's measured continuation and answer-quality differences predict whether full reference conditioning will outperform terminal-only conditioning, and how do those predictions compare with NATURAL-FULL versus TERM-ONLY?

  3. Do you have a matched control using EARLY-PRIV's legal-action normalization and trie construction with zero early-answer mass, and what does it show about completion?

  4. Which mechanism in Theorems 1–2 is supported by the GSM8K length results, and what evidence distinguishes omitted necessary computation from more concise successful reasoning?

2 comments

Thank you for identifying the need for a matched ZERO control and for asking whether teacher-trajectory selection changes the student's actual behavior. Your questions also highlight an important presentation issue: the motivation for the teacher-collected setting should be clear before the protocol definitions.

We have completed additional experiments addressing the matched control and student behavior. The new controlled study uses a new shared calibration and will be reported separately from the original experiment, rather than as additional seeds of the same run.


1. Do RETAIN and RELABEL Change Student Behavior?

The motivation for Theorem 3 is that fixing the collected-prefix distribution still leaves a consequential choice: which teacher condition supplies the label at each prefix? If reference-conditioned trajectories end earlier, their proportion among surviving trajectories changes with depth. RETAIN preserves the association between collection and labeling, whereas independent RELABEL breaks it. Under the theorem's assumptions, this changes the fitted continuation and terminal channels without implying a universal accuracy ordering.

To test whether this protocol choice affects actual students, we fitted Qwen3-1.7B with RETAIN and RELABEL for each of two seeds, using the same cached GSM8K prefixes and full-vocabulary forward KL. RELABEL assigns an independent reference bit once per trajectory and fit, retaining that bit across revisits; it does not replace each target with a fixed average distribution.

We then measured local continuation from 39 fixed prefixes drawn from 16 development questions, with two continuations per prefix. The endpoint is native close/EOS within the next 256 tokens:

Fitting SeedRELABEL − RETAIN Ending Probability95% CI
11+12.82 pp[3.95, 23.61]
22+8.97 pp[1.35, 17.14]

The intervals cluster by original question and condition on the shared cache and fitted models. Thus, changing label assignment at fixed collected prefixes changes the student's local ending behavior in both seeds. The 78 continuations per condition are not 78 independent questions, and this endpoint does not measure necessary-computation completion.

Full-answer accuracy gives a more limited conclusion. RETAIN and RELABEL score 82/96 and 85/96 for seed 11, and 84/96 and 87/96 for seed 22. Both paired differences are +3.125 pp (95% CI: [−2.08, 8.33]), so an accuracy ordering is unresolved. All four fitted models are descriptively below BASE's 90/96, and full-answer shortening is clearly supported in only one seed. These measurements establish a behavioral consequence of the protocol, while leaving its mediation through particular target components unresolved.


2. Can Teacher Continuation and Quality Predict Protocol Ordering?

The original lookup-task audit is compatible with a beneficial regime: both natural teacher conditions almost always continue at intermediate decisions, while reference information increases terminal correct-answer probability from 61.28% to 86.80%. Correspondingly, NATURAL-FULL and TERM-ONLY both retain 100% completion, with mean free accuracies of 68.20% and 66.56%.

However, both protocols already use privileged terminal supervision. The teacher-quality increase alone therefore does not predict the relative ranking of NATURAL-FULL and TERM-ONLY. We have not validated a predictor of this ordering. The new reconstruction uses a different calibration and cannot substitute for that validation, while the new GSM8K continuation diagnostics measure ending behavior rather than independent teacher answer quality. We will clarify both what the existing audit supports and what remains untested.

3. A Matched ZERO Control for the EARLY Intervention

Following your suggestion, we added ZERO using the same legal-action normalization and trie construction as EARLY. ZERO places zero early-answer mass in the adapted intermediate-action target when the reference bit is active. The natural unreferenced branch remains, and token prefixes outside the adapted support retain the specified natural-teacher fallback. Thus, the zero is a property of the adapted action-target branch; it does not mean that every teacher target, the student's early-answer probability, or its gradient is zero.

We fitted BASE, TERM, ZERO, and EARLY with five paired seeds per arm and evaluated them on the same 256 problems. At the primary update-8 checkpoint, the paired differences are:

ComparisonCompletion Difference (95% CI)Free Accuracy Difference (95% CI)Forced Accuracy Difference (95% CI)
ZERO − TERM+2.19 pp [1.02, 3.59]+1.48 pp [0.23, 2.81]−0.39 pp [−1.64, 0.86]
EARLY − ZERO−26.48 pp [−31.17, −21.95]−22.19 pp [−26.49, −17.81]−7.73 pp [−10.94, −4.69]
  • Effect of the Matched Adapter Intervention: EARLY reduces completion and free accuracy relative to ZERO, with all five seeds agreeing in direction. Forced accuracy also decreases. This reconstruction therefore does not reproduce the original pattern of higher forced accuracy with lower completion and free accuracy.
  • Improvement Relative to TERM: ZERO increases completion in all five seeds and free accuracy in four seeds, with one tie. Its forced-accuracy difference is inconclusive; the interval does not establish equivalence. ZERO also changes legal-action and internal-token targets relative to TERM, so this comparison does not isolate a single stopping logit.

These intervals condition on the common calibration and five fixed fits; they are not uncertainty intervals over a population of independently rebuilt training runs. We will present the matched control and the reconstructed results alongside, and clearly separate from, the original experiment.


4. What Does Natural-Language Reasoning Length Validate?

The GSM8K length results establish changes in generated reasoning. They do not establish omission of necessary computation or validate the complete mechanisms of Theorems 1 and 2. Shorter successful reasoning can be beneficial.

The staged-reveal task makes completion checkable through five correct intermediate states, with incorrect states left unrepaired. Natural mathematical solutions do not provide the same operational measure. Our additional natural-task interventions also did not establish a successful accuracy rescue attributable to additional thinking. We will therefore distinguish controlled completion, local ending behavior, and natural reasoning length throughout the paper.

Thank you again for these precise questions. They have helped us improve both the experimental controls and the explanation of why collection, labeling, and completion must be measured separately.

Reviewer_V1j3OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies a phenomenon that occurs when a teacher is given privileged information, and we use that privileged supervision to train the student model. This is often done in on-policy self-distillation. When performing this kind of on-policy self-distillation, the privileged supervision lowers answer accuracy and reduces the benefits of reasoning.

This paper establishes a theoretical framework to analyze this phenomenon. The intuition is that it explicitly decouples prediction and execution, which makes prediction and execution analyzable and provides conditions under which performance degenerates. This paper proposed a new analytical framework to study the mechanism of execution or not.

The experiment provides a comprehensive analysis of GSM8K tasks.

Critical strengths

This paper studies a meaningful problem: that is, on-policy self-distillation (OPSD) does not always bring performance gain. This paper provides an analytical framework to study the performance degeneration of OPSD.

This paper has both theoretical analysis and empirical results to support the claim.

Critical weaknesses

The targeted problem largely overlaps with existing work (https://arxiv.org/pdf/2603.24472v4). The comparison to this existing work should be discussed and added to this paper.

The GSM8K experiment seems too naive and like a toy, since the current pre-trained model has already observed those kinds of problems, and the results in this dataset seem less convincing.

Questions for authors

In this paper, the KL divergence is the forward KL between student and teacher. Is the reverse KL also established? And how does different KL divergence influence the results?

2 comments

Thank you for your careful assessment of the contribution relative to prior work, the role of KL direction, and the limitations of the GSM8K evaluation. We appreciate these suggestions and have added a numerical comparison of the two KL directions and evaluations on harder mathematical tasks.

Our starting point is the asymmetry between a teacher that already has access to the reference answer and a student that must still compute the information needed to use that answer. Below, we clarify the resulting theoretical contribution and the scope of the additional experiments.


1. Motivation and Contribution: Why Separate Prediction from Execution?

We agree that Kim et al. [1] already study richer teacher context, changes in epistemic verbalization, shorter responses, and reasoning degradation. We should have discussed this relationship explicitly. Our work complements these observations by analyzing how privileged supervision interacts with the student's computational progress.

In our construction, the full problem determines the correct answer, but the student's current readout cannot use that answer before the required computation. Averaging privileged targets over the student's available features removes the specificity of early answers while retaining their probability mass. At the terminal state, the same source of privileged information improves the answer channel. This yields three distinct results:

  • Prediction Gains and Completion Loss (Theorem 1): Under the restricted-readout and correct-continuation assumptions, we derive self-consistent population fits in which terminal prediction improves while completion decreases. The theorem gives conditions under which the completion loss outweighs the prediction gain, reducing free accuracy.
  • Training Exposure at Later States (Theorem 2): In the specified network, finitely many exact population updates can produce higher forced accuracy and lower free accuracy. The comparison dynamics make the dependence on reaching later states explicit through a cumulative visit clock; the finite-network analysis establishes the endpoint separation. This mechanism does not require sampled-gradient noise.
  • Collection and Labeling Conditions (Theorem 3): Under the stated teacher-survival model, the reference-condition mixture changes among surviving trajectories. Retaining or independently reassigning the labeling condition can therefore change continuation and terminal prediction even with the same collected-prefix distribution. The theorem does not imply a universal accuracy ranking between the protocols.

These results provide a mathematical account of a possible failure mechanism under stated assumptions. They do not identify stopping as the cause of the failures observed by Kim et al. We will make this complementary relationship explicit in the related work and contribution statements.

[1] Kim et al. Why Does Self-Distillation (Sometimes) Degrade the Reasoning Capability of LLMs? arXiv:2603.24472v4, 2026.


2. Reverse KL: The Phenomenon Can Occur in Both Directions

The submitted theorems concern forward KL. To examine whether the qualitative separation requires this direction, we completed all 72 prespecified conditions in a deterministic, fixed-context study with strictly positive target support and a restricted policy class. At smoothing ϵ=0.001\epsilon=0.001, reference probability ρ=0.5\rho=0.5, baseline terminal parameter a0=0.8a_0=0.8, and depth d=5d=5, we obtain:

PolicyForced AccuracyCompletionFree Accuracy
Baseline79.945%99.601%79.726%
Forward KL89.935%3.116%27.023%
Reverse KL98.646%46.781%59.453%
  • Existence Beyond Forward KL: In this construction, both directions improve prediction while reducing completion and free accuracy. Thus, the qualitative phenomenon can also occur under reverse KL.
  • Dependence on the Objective and Parameters: Among the 12 conditions at ρ=0.5\rho=0.5, free accuracy decreases in 9 forward-KL conditions and 4 reverse-KL conditions, while the remaining conditions improve. Reverse KL is also sensitive to smoothing; for the displayed parameter setting, the loss eventually disappears as smoothing tends to zero at fixed finite depth.
  • Scope and Numerical Verification: These are numerical existence results for restricted policies, rather than an LM training ablation or a full reverse-KL theorem extension. Analytic solutions agree with independent numerical optimization to within 1.54×10−101.54\times10^{-10}. We will report the complete grid and its parameter dependence.

3. Harder Tasks and Larger Models: MATH500 and AIME

To broaden the evaluation beyond GSM8K, we evaluated fixed public Qwen3-8B BASE, math-SDPO, and math-GRPO checkpoints on both complete AIME test sets:

DatasetBASESDPOGRPO
AIME202423/3018/3021/30
AIME202521/3011/3020/30

We also completed the BASE and SDPO evaluations on all 500 MATH500 problems. Accuracy is 488/500 versus 473/500, a paired SDPO-minus-BASE difference of −3.0 pp (95% CI: [−5.0, −1.2]). Mean generated length decreases from 5,474 to 2,653 tokens.

These results extend the observed coexistence of shorter output and lower accuracy to 8B models and harder mathematics. The checkpoints were not retrained under matched conditions, and the public SDPO checkpoint uses JSD/TopK100/EMA0, rather than the manuscript's forward-KL protocol. Each problem uses one fixed sampling stream. The evaluations neither eliminate possible pretraining exposure nor identify stopping as the cause of the accuracy difference.

Thank you again for these constructive suggestions. We will incorporate the expanded evaluation, the KL comparison, and a more explicit account of the relationship to prior work into the revised manuscript.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewer,

Thank you again for your time and thoughtful feedback. We hope our response has helped clarify your concerns. If you have any further questions or suggestions, we would be more than happy to discuss them.

We sincerely appreciate your time and consideration.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.