acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Adaptive Multi-Resolution Procedural Knowledge Compression for Large Language Models

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are widely used to tackle complex tasks with autonomous workflows. Recently, reusable natural language skills have emerged as a popular paradigm to inject procedural knowledge into LLM applications. Since popular skills are often invoked repeatedly, placing their full text in every context significantly increases prefill cost and latency. While text compression techniques have the potential to solve this problem, most existing methods are designed to compress factual knowledge in documents instead of procedural knowledge, making them insufficient for skill compression. In this paper, we argue that an effective skill compression method should: 1) preserve logical dependencies among workflows and tool protocols, 2) enable lightweight, offline compression for frequently updated community skills, and 3) be adaptable to varying complexities across skills. To address this, we present SKIM (SKIll coMpression), an adaptive multi-resolution soft token compression framework for procedural skills. Depending on the complexity of each skill, SKIM creates different numbers of soft tokens that not only improve the efficiency of LLM inference, but also preserve the effectiveness of skill usage. Experiments indicate that SKIM's fixed-budget configurations compress skills to as few as 15 to 55 percent of their original token length, while the adaptive variant selects the minimal budget that preserves task fidelity.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
LLM Agents, Procedural Knowledge, Skill Compression, Efficient Inference

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 17%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.75 over 4 reviews, above 83% of the others.
Reviewer_S9dbOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

In this paper, the authors propose SKIM, an adaptive framework for compressing procedural skills into reusable soft tokens. It combines progressive training with offline token-budget selection to preserve workflow and tool-use behavior while reducing repeated context costs. Reported fixed-budget configurations retain 15% to 55% of the original token length.

Critical strengths
  • The paper addresses an interesting question of how to reduce the context overhead and inference costs caused by repeatedly loading lengthy procedural skills.

  • The three-stage training design provides a coherent progression from reconstructing skill content to supporting procedural questions and downstream tasks.

  • The framework supports independently compressed skills within a shared context, accommodating tasks that require multiple skills.

Critical weaknesses
  • SKIM builds on an existing compression architecture. However, it is unclear what new technical ideas its training strategy and budget selection introduce beyond adapting existing methods to procedural skills.

  • The selector chooses between only two compressed budgets and full text, while its advantage over simpler budget-allocation rules remains unclear.

  • The same model generates diagnostic questions, produces reference answers, and evaluates compressed answers. This self-evaluation may overlook the same procedural requirements across these steps, making a compressed representation appear faithful even when important instructions are missed.

  • At inference, all selected skills use the largest individual budget. One demanding skill can therefore increase the token allocation for every simpler skill in the same request.

  • The shared LoRA is trained with compressed soft tokens, so returning to ordinary skill text may not preserve the original model’s full-text performance.

  • Character edit distance measures textual change rather than procedural importance. A small edit to a condition, tool argument, and prohibition may require recalibration even when most of the skill remains unchanged.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer S9db (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the thorough review and for recognizing the coherence of our three-stage training pipeline and experimental scope. Below we address each point in detail.

W1: Technical Contributions

As noted in Section 3.2 (citing DRIFT and Liu & Qiu, 2025), the dual-model Compressor + Projector backbone builds on prior soft compression architectures, and we do not claim the backbone itself as our contribution. Our technical contributions lie in three aspects:

  1. Formulating the challenges and deployment criteria of procedural skill compression (Sections 1 to 2, Table 1): Unlike generic factual context consumed once, agent skills are reusable procedural assets invoked across sessions. Compression must preserve conditional branches, step orderings, and tool-argument constraints while remaining offline query-independent (no per-query recompression), forward-only lightweight (no per-skill gradient tuning), and non-intrusive to base model capabilities. Directly applying existing soft compressors fails and falls below the no-skill Naive baseline even when retrained on the exact same SKIM data (Table 14).
  2. A three-stage progressive alignment recipe tailored to procedural skills (Section 3.3): To overcome scarce executable skill annotations, multi-turn tool use, and multi-skill composition, we introduce Stage 1 skill reconstruction, Stage 2 weakly supervised procedural QA warm-up repurposed from WikiHow, and Stage 3 task alignment with self-simulated ReAct trajectories and top-down skill splitting. Our ablations in Section 5.2.1 (Figure 4) confirm that removing any stage, replacing Stage 3 with factual QA (HotpotQA), or switching to off-policy teacher distillation (GPT-5.2) causes substantial degradation.
  3. Offline multi-resolution budget selection tailored to skill difficulty (Section 3.4): Skills vary widely in procedural complexity, so a single fixed budget either wastes tokens on simple skills or loses accuracy on complex ones. Using prefix truncation over a single stored artifact and zero-label offline self-evaluation, SKIM adapts the token budget per skill while adding zero online latency overhead.

W2: Comparison with Simple Budget Allocation Rules

Thanks for the comment. First, our selector is not restricted to two compressed budgets. Via prefix truncation, untrained intermediate tiers {128, 256, 384, 512, Full} can be included without retraining, reducing average tokens from 1,303 to 978 on Qwen3-8B and from 1,055 to 923 on Phi-4 at comparable accuracy (Appendix E.2 and E.3, Figure 7 and Table 9).

Second, to address your question directly, we compared SKIM-Adaptive against three label-free allocation rules that keep the exact per-dataset tier counts chosen by Adaptive and replace only the ranking criterion (higher-scoring skills receive larger budgets): ranking by full-text token length, ranking by structural complexity (total regex counts of numbered steps, code blocks, conditionals, and tool calls), and matched-proportion random allocation. Macro-averaged results (Acc. % / Avg. Tokens) across all five datasets under the Table 9 candidate set {128, 256, 384, 512, Full} at τ=0.9\tau=0.9 are:

ModelSKIM-AdaptiveBy Token LengthBy Structural ComplexityMatched Random
Qwen3-8B61.96 / 97862.15 / 167461.34 / 158660.96 / 1027
Phi-449.70 / 92349.50 / 155348.73 / 146248.06 / 913

Long or superficially complex skills often contain verbose explanations or extended examples that compress well, yet static heuristics assign all of them to Full Text and drastically inflate token usage. Conversely, short but logically dense theorems or rules often need higher resolution, yet static heuristics assign them small budgets. Thus, Adaptive consistently outperforms these static rules at equal or lower token cost.

In addition, Appendix H.2 (Table 12) has specifically studied the routing problem under different exam judges (target-model self-judgment, GPT-5.2, and two independent human annotators), showing that all exam-driven adaptive configurations consistently outperform corresponding fixed-budget baselines.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer S9db (Part 2/2)

W3: Potential Blind Spots in Self-Evaluation

Thank you for raising this concern. First, we used target-model self-evaluation in our main experiments to keep the framework self-contained and ensure a fair comparison without privileged external models or human labels (Appendix H.2). Moreover, self-evaluation is conducted only during the offline exam as part of our method, completely separate from and independent of final downstream benchmark testing, and the downstream performance itself validates the soundness of our approach. Appendix H (Tables 11 and 12) also already evaluated part of your suggestion by replacing the judge with GPT-5.2 and two human annotators, confirming no systematic self-preference bias. To further examine question generation, we replaced both the question generator and the judge with a larger external model, Qwen3-32B, across the 162 skills and 2,083 downstream test instances:

Question Gen. / Judge{128..512, Full}: Acc. (%) / Tokens{256, 512, Full}: Acc. (%) / Tokens
Qwen3-8B / Qwen3-8B (Self, Table 12)75.90 / 66675.47 / 730
Qwen3-8B / GPT-5.2 (Table 12)76.00 / 68075.47 / 738
Qwen3-32B / Qwen3-8B75.90 / 60775.80 / 659
Qwen3-32B / Qwen3-32B75.76 / 60075.66 / 650
Ref: Fixed K=512 / Full Text (Table 12)71.58 (536) / 76.86 (999)Same

Replacing both question generation and judging with a stronger external model leaves downstream accuracy virtually unchanged while slightly reducing token cost. This confirms that self-evaluation does not miss critical instructions, and as noted in Appendix H.2, substituting a stronger model or human verification for offline routing remains optional for deployment.

W4: Multi-Skill Budget Allocation

We agree with your observation. Since SKIM encodes and prefix-truncates each skill independently (Section 3.2: EK(s)=EKmax⁡(s)1:K\mathbf{E}_K(s) = \mathbf{E}_{K_{\max}}(s)_{1:K}), concatenating variable-length soft-token sequences such as [E256(s1),E512(s2)][\mathbf{E}_{256}(s_1), \mathbf{E}_{512}(s_2)] has no architectural limitation. Taking the maximum budget in Section 3.5 was simply a shortcut for reusing single-budget runs during offline evaluation. We evaluated per-skill heterogeneous compressed budgets on the two multi-skill datasets (BigCodeBench with 2.76 skills/item and CHAMP with 1.71 skills/item) under the Table 9 dense Adaptive routing (Acc. (%) / Avg. Tokens):

Model / DatasetShared Max Budget (Table 9)Per-Skill Heterogeneous Budget
Qwen3-8B / BigCodeBench46.05 / 156746.49 / 1486 (-5% tok)
Qwen3-8B / CHAMP64.13 / 130362.33 / 1271 (-2% tok)
Phi-4 / BigCodeBench50.61 / 201250.09 / 1827 (-9% tok)
Phi-4 / CHAMP60.99 / 116160.99 / 1113 (-4% tok)

Per-skill heterogeneous allocation further reduces token usage while maintaining comparable accuracy (no paired difference is statistically significant). Since the other three benchmarks are single-skill (Table 5) and the extra token savings here are modest, our overall conclusions remain unchanged. We have added this analysis to Appendix R.3 (Table 26).

W5: LoRA Handling During Full-Text Fallback

As noted in Section 3.5, the base target LLM weights remain frozen, and Stage 3 trains a modular LoRA adapter that engines such as vLLM can toggle per request. LoRA is activated only when SKIM soft tokens are present in the input. When falling back to Full Text (just as when no skill is needed), the adapter is deactivated and inference runs on the unmodified base model, preserving original Full Text performance. We have made this explicit in Section 3.5 in revision.

W6: Character Edit Distance and Recalibration

We respectfully clarify two design details already stated in Appendix I:

  1. Soft tokens are always re-encoded after every edit (~0.5 s): Appendix I states that after any edit, even changing a single parameter, condition, or prohibition, a compressor forward pass regenerates the soft-token artifact, so modified content is always encoded rather than ignored below 30%.
  2. The 30% rule of thumb only concerns whether to rerun budget tier selection K⋆K^\star (~110 s): Moreover, our controlled edit study in Appendix I explicitly instructed GPT-5.2 to make semantically non-equivalent modifications to workflows, libraries, or APIs, and even under such substantive edits, the optimal tier K⋆K^\star rarely changed below 30% edit distance (Table 13). That said, we agree that when an edit substantially alters branching complexity or tool schemas, rerunning offline calibration is advisable.

Thank you again for your detailed feedback. We hope these experiments and clarifications resolve your concerns, and we are happy to discuss further.

I thank the authors for the rebuttal. My main concerns have been largely addressed, and I have raised my score.

Thank you for taking the time to read our rebuttal and for raising your score. We sincerely appreciate your constructive feedback, which has helped us strengthen the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_zWt3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SKIM, an adaptive multi-resolution soft-token compression framework for procedural knowledge in LLM skills. While existing prompt compression approaches have primarily focused on factual or document-based knowledge, this work targets procedural knowledge, where preserving dependencies between workflow steps and tool instructions is important.

SKIM employs a multi-resolution compressor and a progressive three-stage training procedure consisting of skill reconstruction, procedural QA warm-up, and skill task alignment. It further introduces offline resolution selection to choose an appropriate compression budget for each skill and target model.

The framework aims to reduce prompt token consumption and inference overhead while maintaining the effectiveness of skill-conditioned tasks. The authors evaluate SKIM on five datasets covering code generation, mathematical and logical reasoning, theorem question answering, and tool use, comparing it with existing hard and soft compression approaches.

Critical strengths
  1. Practical motivation and efficient deployment

The paper addresses an important and practical problem: reducing the prompt overhead associated with repeatedly invoked procedural skills. The motivation is clearly presented, particularly through the example illustrating why preserving procedural knowledge is different from retaining factual information.

A notable strength is that compressed skill representations can be precomputed before deployment and reused during inference. In addition, when skills are updated, their compressed representations can be regenerated through a lightweight forward pass without retraining the shared compressor or LoRA adapter. This design makes the proposed approach potentially useful for practical skill deployment, where skills may be frequently modified or shared.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited baseline comparisons in some experimental settings

The experimental comparison includes only LLMLingua-2 as a hard compression baseline. Although the paper explains its baseline selection criteria, I wonder whether including additional hard compression methods would provide a more comprehensive evaluation.

Furthermore, in the longer-context stress test in Section 5.2.2, SKIM is compared with LLMLingua-2, but the soft compression baselines used in the main experiments are not included. This limits the comparison of different compression approaches under longer-context and retrieval-noise conditions.

  1. Limited ablation coverage for multi-turn tool-use tasks

The ablation studies in Section 5.2 primarily exclude ToolQA due to computational cost. While this limitation is understandable, ToolQA involves multi-turn decision-making and tool interactions, which are closely related to the paper's motivation of preserving procedural dependencies. As a result, the contribution of the individual training stages to such tool-use tasks remains less thoroughly evaluated.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors clarify the rationale for including only LLMLingua-2 as a hard compression baseline? Would additional hard compression baselines help provide a more comprehensive comparison?

  2. In Section 5.2.2, why were the soft compression baselines excluded from the longer-context stress test?

  3. The paper reports a comparison with and without LoRA for Phi-4 on ToolQA. Could the authors clarify whether similar comparisons were conducted for other datasets or target models?

  4. Given that ToolQA involves multi-turn tool interactions, could the authors further discuss how the exclusion of ToolQA from the ablation studies affects the conclusions about the three training stages?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zWt3 (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the constructive review. Following your suggestions, we added the hard compression baseline DAC, soft compression baselines under the stress test, and training-stage ablations on ToolQA.

W1 & Q1: Additional Hard Compression Baseline (DAC)

Our baseline selection follows the two deployment criteria in Table 1: offline query-independence and forward-only lightweight compression (no per-skill gradient optimization). In addition, the generative GPT-5.2 skill rewrite evaluated in Table 4 also serves as a strong text-level compression baseline.

To address your concern directly, we added the recent task-agnostic hard compression baseline DAC (Zhao et al., ACL 2025, arXiv:2507.11942) across both target models at 256 and 512 tokens per skill:

ModelMethodBigCodeBenchCHAMPLogicBenchTheoremQAMacro Avg.
Qwen3-8BLLMLingua-2 (256)40.7052.4782.1158.1058.35
DAC (256)40.1855.1681.5855.0257.98
SKIM-Fix (256)44.2154.2683.1660.2460.47
Qwen3-8BLLMLingua-2 (512)43.6054.7185.0061.9861.32
DAC (512)44.3057.4083.4259.0461.04
SKIM-Fix (512)45.5361.4385.0064.7964.19
Phi-4LLMLingua-2 (256)43.3756.9552.5045.9249.69
DAC (256)43.2554.2656.1846.7250.10
SKIM-Fix (256)46.5858.7463.1643.7853.07
Phi-4LLMLingua-2 (512)45.3958.3059.8748.0652.91
DAC (512)46.1454.7160.9245.3851.79
SKIM-Fix (512)49.1257.8574.7448.3357.51

DAC performs similarly to LLMLingua-2 overall, and SKIM-Fix outperforms DAC across all four model-budget groups by +2.49 to +5.72 pp on average.

W1 & Q2: Soft Compression Baselines in the Stress Test

ICAE and 500xCompressor were omitted from Figure 5 because they already underperformed Naive under clean golden skills. We evaluated both methods under the exact same BigCodeBench stress setting (5 skills per item combining golden skills and BGE-retrieved distractors, each compressed to 256 tokens and concatenated):

Method (5 Skills / Item)Qwen3-8B Acc. (%)Phi-4 Acc. (%)
Naive40.9643.77
Full Text47.1948.95
ICAE (K=256 × 5)0.000.00
500xCompressor (K=256 × 5)26.409.82
LLMLingua-2 (K=256 / 512)40.26 / 41.9343.86 / 47.46
SKIM-Fix (K=256 / 512)42.19 / 44.6547.46 / 49.30

Under multi-skill concatenation and retrieval distractors, ICAE collapses into degenerate output at 1,280 memory tokens and 500xCompressor drops on Qwen3-8B and Phi-4 compared with the clean golden setting (Table 2), with SKIM-512 outperforming 500xCompressor thanks to Stage 3 subskill-splitting alignment.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zWt3 (Part 2/2)

Q3: Comparisons With and Without LoRA on Other Datasets and Models

Thank you for raising this important question. We would like to kindly note that comparisons with and without LoRA on the remaining datasets and target model are provided in the manuscript as follows:

  1. Appendix E.4 (Figure 8): Evaluates Qwen3-8B across the other four datasets (BigCodeBench, CHAMP, LogicBench, TheoremQA) comparing a frozen target LLM (Frozen, without LoRA) against various LoRA ranks. Without LoRA, SKIM already reaches 59.3% / 61.2% macro accuracy (well above 54.76% for Naive), and adding the shared LoRA (r=16r=16) further improves it to 60.5% / 64.2%.
  2. Appendix K.2 (Table 15): Further verifies on Qwen3-8B across the same four datasets that applying a LoRA trained on our Stage 3 data to Full Text or LLMLingua-2 brings no gain (67.88% for Full Text vs. 67.36% for Full Text + LoRA).

W2 & Q4: Training-Stage Ablation on ToolQA

We ran the training-stage ablation on ToolQA (1,430 instances) with Qwen3-8B:

Training Stage ConfigurationK=256 Acc. (%)K=512 Acc. (%)Avg. ReAct Steps (256 / 512)Valid Finish Rate % (256 / 512)
Naive (no skill)28.0428.047.7777.6
Stage 1 only (reconstruction)26.6426.858.15 / 8.1374.2 / 74.1
Stage 1 + Stage 2 (w/o Stage 3)4.414.4819.14 / 18.085.7 / 12.3
Complete SKIM (Stages 1 to 3)35.6643.926.99 / 7.8081.5 / 77.6

Consistent with the single-turn trend in Section 5.2.1 (Figure 4), Stage 1 reconstruction alone stays near Naive without learning to execute tool workflows from soft prefixes. Stopping at Stage 2 (single-turn WikiHow QA warm-up without Stage 3 multi-turn skill alignment) causes format collapse in ReAct loops, where the model emits Action and fabricated Observation text on the same line until hitting the 20-step cap. Adding Stage 3 skill task alignment restores valid Finish termination and substantially lifts downstream accuracy across both budgets. We have added these results to Appendix P.2 (Table 20).

Thank you for your helpful suggestions, which have strengthened both our baselines and ablations. Please let us know if you have any further questions.

Reviewer_11jiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents SKIM, which compresses skill instructions into soft tokens of different lengths. It selects a token budget for each skill before use. Experiments on two models and five tasks show that SKIM can reduce input processing time while keeping much of the original task performance.

Critical strengths
  1. Reducing the cost of repeatedly loading skill instructions is a useful practical goal.

  2. The experiments are fairly broad. The additional human evaluation, LoRA comparisons, retrieval tests, and statistical analysis help support the results.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The motivation needs stronger evidence. The paper argues that skill instructions need special compression to preserve step order and dependencies. However, most experiments only report final accuracy. They do not clearly show where existing methods fail to preserve these dependencies or how the proposed design specifically addresses this problem. This also makes the added novelty less clear.

  2. The practical benefit is not fully established. Full text with prefix caching is a relevant baseline for repeatedly used skills, but it is not tested. SKIM also needs model-specific encoding and extra processing after skill updates. These costs should be considered when judging its overall efficiency.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you show which errors in step order or dependencies SKIM reduces compared with existing methods?

  2. Does SKIM still offer a clear efficiency gain when prefix caching and skill updates are included?

  3. Why does adaptive budget selection sometimes perform worse than a fixed budget on Phi-4?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 11ji (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the careful review and constructive feedback. We have run additional experiments to address your questions and updated the manuscript accordingly. Below are our point-by-point responses.

W1 & Q1: Preserving Procedural Dependencies

Hard compression methods drop tokens based on local entropy or distilled token probabilities. Elements such as conditional keywords and argument constraints carry low local perplexity, yet are essential for execution, so they are easily pruned. We added two analyses under the 256-token budget to quantify this effect.

First, we measured procedural marker retention in the compressed texts of LLMLingua-2 and DAC (Zhao et al., ACL 2025, arXiv:2507.11942, a task-agnostic hard compression baseline we added in response to Reviewer zWt3). Over all 581 gold skills, we counted regex matches in the original and compressed texts and computed retention as ∑min⁡(ccomp,corig)/∑corig\sum \min(c_{\text{comp}}, c_{\text{orig}}) / \sum c_{\text{orig}}. Multipliers in parentheses compare each class against overall word retention:

Compressed CorpusAll Words (%)Sequence (first/then/step)Condition (if/when/unless)Mandatory (must/should/always)Code IDs (e.g., pd.read_csv)Exact Tool Calls (e.g., FilterDB[...])
LLMLingua-2 (256)27.216.4 (×0.60)2.3 (×0.08)6.6 (×0.24)18.4 (×0.68)10.8 (×0.40)
DAC (256)25.322.3 (×0.88)45.0 (×1.78)29.1 (×1.15)8.1 (×0.32)1.4 (×0.05)

LLMLingua-2 removes almost all conditional and mandatory markers, while DAC retains more conditional words at the cost of stripping out API identifiers and exact tool-call templates. Although the two methods drop different tokens, both lose structural elements needed for execution.

Since soft tokens cannot be evaluated via surface text matching, our second analysis compares execution behavior directly by attributing trajectory errors across all 1,430 ToolQA instances on Qwen3-8B. We extracted the required tool workflows and data sources from each skill specification (for example, LoadDB[flights] -> FilterDB -> GetValue for flight queries) and inspected each ReAct trajectory step by step to record its first error: Invalid Action (empty, multiple, or unknown tool calls), Order Violation (calling a tool before its prerequisite succeeds, such as FilterDB before LoadDB), Missing Step (calling Finish without completing any valid workflow path), Argument Error (syntactically valid calls that return environment errors, such as invalid column names, wrong date formats, or loading the wrong database), and Unfinished (not reaching Finish within 20 steps).

MethodClean (%)Invalid Action (%)Order Violation (%)Missing Step (%)Argument Error (%)Unfinished (%)
Naive52.09.21.07.130.10.6
Stage 1 only (256)50.79.90.17.331.10.6
LLMLingua-2 (256)56.36.20.04.832.40.2
DAC (256)51.69.70.00.137.61.1
SKIM-Fix (256)62.18.52.21.423.81.7
Full Text72.114.22.70.010.30.6

The sharpest difference lies in argument errors. Because hard compression drops database names, column schemas, and date formats, the model issues valid tool syntax with wrong arguments, resulting in even higher argument error rates than the no-skill Naive baseline. SKIM achieves a much lower argument error rate than both hard compression methods and the highest clean trajectory rate among compressed variants.

At the design level, SKIM addresses this issue in two ways. First, soft-token compression does not prune discrete tokens from the source text, so low-entropy conditions and parameter constraints can still be encoded into the continuous prefix. Second, Stages 2 and 3 align the compressed representation directly with procedural QA and skill execution, forcing the soft tokens to retain operational steps and constraints. As shown in the table above, a Stage 1 reconstruction-only checkpoint exhibits nearly the same error profile as Naive, confirming that execution alignment rather than text reconstruction is what preserves procedural logic.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 11ji (Part 2/2)

W2 & Q2: Prefix Caching and Skill Update Overhead

We appreciate this suggestion, and we respectfully note that Full Text with prefix caching is not a direct baseline for our target setting because prefix caching generally does not hold for agent skill reuse across different users.
First, prefix caching can reuse KV states only when every preceding token is identical. In modern agent harnesses (such as OpenClaw or Claude Code), a skill is almost never placed at the very start of the prompt. Instead, the context begins with system instructions, dynamic environment states (timestamps, workspace file trees, MCP tool schemas), and an ever-growing conversation history, while skills are retrieved and injected into the middle of the context on demand. Since the preceding states and history vary across users and turns, the skill block itself cannot hit a shared prefix cache.
Second, this is even clearer under multi-skill composition, where both the selected subset and ordering of skills change per query. Whenever an earlier skill differs, the cache for all subsequent skills is invalidated.
Furthermore, the two techniques do not conflict and can be combined: SKIM's soft-token prefixes can also be cached when static, while occupying a much smaller KV footprint.

To address your question directly, we benchmarked prefill latency and KV memory on a single H20 GPU (Qwen3-8B, bf16, ~1,400 tokens for Full Text skill + query vs. ~400 tokens for SKIM-256):

ScenarioFull TextSKIM-Fix 256SKIM-Fix 512
Uncached (no history, compute skill + query) prefill (ms)215.679.3117.3
Ideal static prefix (skill at start & cached, compute query only) prefill (ms)54.154.454.6
Agent setting (2,048-tok history cached, compute skill + query after it) prefill (ms)294.499.0146.0
Agent setting (8,192-tok history cached, compute skill + query after it) prefill (ms)420.9146.7216.1
Per-request skill + query KV memory at 144 KiB/tok (MiB)205.656.1101.6

Even in the ideal static case that rarely arises in modern harnesses, SKIM matches Full Text prefill latency. In realistic agent turns where only the prior conversation history is cached, the newly injected skill + query must still run prefill and attend over all cached history KV states, increasing prefill latency as history grows, where SKIM is 2x to 3x faster. Moreover, prefix caching does not save context window budget or per-request KV memory, whereas SKIM reduces both by 2x to 3.7x.

Regarding skill updates, editing a skill invalidates a prefix cache and requires recomputation just the same, and KV caches are likewise tied to a specific model. Updating SKIM-Fix takes only one compressor forward pass (~0.5 s), which pays off within 4 to 6 calls (Table 10). The ~110 s offline calibration is only needed when re-selecting the Adaptive budget tier, and Appendix I shows that the original tier remains valid after most routine edits.

Q3: Adaptive Performance on Phi-4

Both behaviors are already discussed in Section 5.1 of our paper. Briefly, on LogicBench, Adaptive prioritizes token savings at τ=0.9\tau=0.9 and routes most skills to the 256-token tier (averaging 335 tokens, 35% fewer than Fix-512), placing its accuracy (69.61%) naturally between Fix-256 (63.16%) and Fix-512 (74.74%). On ToolQA, Phi-4 suffers from negative transfer when reading uncompressed Full Text due to context length pressure (9.79% vs. 14.83% for Naive). Because offline calibration uses Full Text outputs as the silver reference, fallback skills land on the degraded Full Text mode, whereas adding intermediate compressed tiers in Appendix E.3 (Table 9) reduces fallbacks and raises Adaptive accuracy to 27.48%.

Thank you again for your valuable feedback. We hope these experiments and clarifications address your concerns, and we welcome any further questions.

Dear Reviewer 11ji,

We hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period is drawing to a close, we wanted to gently follow up to see if you have had a chance to review our response and revised manuscript. We understand you have a very busy schedule, and we wanted to briefly highlight the new experiments added specifically for your questions: (1) procedural marker retention and step-by-step ToolQA trajectory error attribution (Appendix P, Tables 18–19), and (2) prefill latency and KV memory benchmarks across prefix-cached multi-turn agent settings (Section 5.3 & Appendix S.1, Table 27), alongside clarifications on skill updates and Phi-4 Adaptive routing.

Please let us know if these results address your concerns or if there is anything else we can clarify before the deadline. Thank you again for your time and feedback!

Dear Reviewer,

This is a friendly reminder that the ICLR 2027 discussion phase will end on November 18 at 11:59 PM AoE.

Please take some time to review author's responses before the deadline. If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to raise them in the discussion thread so that the authors have an opportunity to respond.

Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing the papers.

Best regards,

Area Chair

Reviewer_31o1OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The topic of this paper is about the skill compression for large language models(LLM). The authors propose an adaptive multi-resolution soft token compression framework for procedural skills (SKIM), which aims to make a good trade-off between the efficiency and effectiveness. The proposed method has been evaluated on five datasets and achieves a good token length compression.

Critical strengths
  • Exploring the skill compression for large language models is interesting.
  • The proposed methods achieves around 45%~85% token length compression on five datasets for 8B of Qwen3 and 14B of Phi-4 LLMs.
Critical weaknesses
  • The robustness of the proposed method on different computing equipments. The main experiments are evaluated on a single NVIDIA H20 GPU. Provide the corresponding results with other kinds of devices or different numbers of GPUs. How the SKIM framework performs under these practical settings? These results can further demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
  • Besides, provide a detailed cost analysis (e.g., inference time/training time) among different methods.
Questions for authors

Q1: How to select appropriate hyper-parameters of the proposed method? Complement the sensitive parameters in the implementation details.

Q2: Evaluate the proposed SKIM framework with other kinds of LLMs (e.g., the number of parameters is larger than 14B).

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 31o1

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical value of our problem formulation. Below we address your questions on hardware and multi-GPU scaling, training cost, hyperparameter sensitivity, and broader LLM evaluation.

Weakness: Cross-GPU Scaling, Multi-GPU Scaling, and Training Cost

During online inference, SKIM simply looks up precomputed soft-token matrices and decodes with a single shared LoRA adapter without running the compressor online, so speedups stem directly from shorter input sequences and hold across GPU types and counts. We added cross-hardware benchmarks on NVIDIA A800 using the same protocol as Table 3 on H20, and measured vLLM under TP=1 and TP=2 for TTFT and batched throughput on Qwen3-8B (bf16):

SettingH20 (Table 3, HF) Prefill / TTFT (ms)A800 (1×GPU, HF) Prefill / TTFT (ms)A800 vLLM TP=1 TTFT (ms) / Thr. (req/s)A800 vLLM TP=2 TTFT (ms) / Thr. (req/s)
Full Text215.6 / 251.9173.6 / 229.0128.0 / 9.786.0 / 16.3
SKIM-Fix 25679.3 (2.72×) / 121.9 (2.07×)70.4 (2.47×) / 130.1 (1.76×)63.3 (2.02×) / 25.6 (2.64×)44.9 (1.91×) / 43.1 (2.64×)
SKIM-Fix 512117.3 (1.84×) / 159.1 (1.58×)98.7 (1.76×) / 155.1 (1.48×)81.9 (1.56×) / 17.7 (1.82×)54.7 (1.57×) / 30.1 (1.84×)
SKIM-Adaptive109.6 (1.97×) / 151.1 (1.67×)92.0 (1.89×) / 150.6 (1.52×)75.3 (1.70×) / 15.8 (1.63×)53.4 (1.61×) / 26.8 (1.64×)

Across H20 and A800, across HF and vLLM, and from TP=1 to TP=2, SKIM maintains consistent TTFT speedups and batched throughput gains.

Regarding one-time training cost, compared with LatentSkill on Qwen3-8B (normalized to H20 GPU-hours), SKIM takes ~260 GPU-h for pretraining/warm-up (Stages 1 and 2) and ~140 GPU-h for Stage 3 alignment, totaling ~400 GPU-h. By contrast, LatentSkill requires ~1,500 to 2,000+ GPU-h for hypernetwork pretraining (171k documents, 10 epochs) plus 432 GPU-h for Stage 3 fine-tuning (2 epochs), totaling ~2,000+ GPU-h ( ~5× higher than SKIM) while still trailing SKIM-Fix 256 on 5-dataset average accuracy in Table 2.

Q1: Hyperparameter Selection and Sensitivity

We agree that examining hyperparameter selection and sensitivity is crucial, and we would be glad to direct the reviewer to Appendix C (Table 7) and Appendix E (Sections E.1–E.4, Figures 7–9, and Table 9), where we provide a detailed analysis:

  • Selection criteria (Appendix C, Table 7): Learning rate, batch size, and projector depth follow standard soft-prompt compression conventions without tuning or selection on downstream test sets, and training stages stop purely based on training-loss thresholds.
  • Sensitivity findings (Appendix E): (1) Soft-token budget KK (Section E.2, Figure 7): Accuracy rises smoothly across K∈64,128,256,384,512K \in 64, 128, 256, 384, 512, and untrained intermediate budgets interpolate cleanly via prefix truncation. (2) Stage 3 LoRA rank rr (Section E.4, Figure 8): Performance is insensitive to rr, with r≥4r \ge 4 capturing most of the gain and r∈4,16,64r \in 4, 16, 64 performing similarly. (3) Offline calibration parameters τ,N\tau, N, and candidate sets (Sections E.1 & E.3, Figure 9 & Table 9): Threshold τ\tau smoothly controls the accuracy-token trade-off (τ=0.9\tau=0.9 nearly matches τ=1.0\tau=1.0 accuracy with clear token savings), question count stabilizes once N≥6N \ge 6, and denser candidate sets work without retraining.

Q2: Evaluation on Additional LLMs

Given our compute and time budget during the rebuttal period, we trained and evaluated a third model family, Gemma-3-12B-IT (paired with a Gemma-3-4B-IT compressor), against budget-matched LLMLingua-2:

Method (Gemma-3-12B-IT)BigCodeBenchCHAMPLogicBenchTheoremQAMacro Avg.
Naive40.7037.2261.8450.6047.59
Full Text51.4051.1280.2672.1663.74
LLMLingua-2 (256)41.2330.0461.5857.8347.67
SKIM-Fix (256)43.6035.8770.0059.5752.26
LLMLingua-2 (512)41.5834.0873.2961.9852.73
SKIM-Fix (512)46.2339.0173.4262.5255.29

SKIM-Fix outperforms LLMLingua-2 across all four datasets at both budgets (paired sign test p=4.5×10−5p = 4.5 \times 10^{-5} and p=0.014p = 0.014). Notably, SKIM-256 nearly matches LLMLingua-2 at 512 tokens using half the token budget.

Thank you again for your constructive review and questions. We hope these additional results address your concerns, and we are glad to discuss further.

Thank the authors for the rebuttal. They have addressed my concerns, and I keep my original positive score.

Thank you for reviewing our rebuttal. We are glad that our responses have addressed your concerns. We greatly appreciate your thoughtful feedback, which has helped us improve the revised manuscript.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Revisions

Dear Area Chairs and Reviewers,

Thank you very much for your time and constructive reviews, and we are especially grateful for the follow-up feedback confirming that our new experiments and clarifications have addressed the main concerns. For ease of reference, we briefly summarize our key clarifications, additional results, and blue-highlighted manuscript revisions below:

  1. Procedural Dependency Preservation & ToolQA Ablations (Reviewer 11ji, Reviewer zWt3): Marker retention across all 581 skills (App. P.1, Table 18) and trajectory error attribution over all ToolQA instances (App. P.2, Table 19) show that hard compressors (LLMLingua-2, DAC) drop conditionals or tool schemas and incur higher argument errors than using no skill, whereas SKIM lowers argument errors and achieves the highest clean trajectory rate. ToolQA stage ablations further confirm Stage 3 alignment prevents ReAct format collapse (App. P.2, Table 20).
  2. Additional Baselines & Third Model Family (Reviewer zWt3, Reviewer 31o1): SKIM-Fix outperforms DAC across both models and budgets (App. Q.1, Table 21) as well as ICAE and 500xCompressor on the BigCodeBench stress test (App. Q.2, Table 22). Evaluating a third model family, Gemma-3-12B-IT, confirms consistent gains, with SKIM-Fix 256 approaching LLMLingua-2 at 512 tokens (App. Q.3, Table 23).
  3. Adaptive Routing & Inference Clarifications (Reviewer S9db): SKIM-Adaptive outperforms label-free static rules at equal or lower token cost (App. R.1, Table 24). Replacing both the offline question generator and judge with Qwen3-32B leaves downstream accuracy virtually unchanged (App. R.2, Table 25). We also evaluated individual per-skill budgets (App. R.3, Table 26) and explicitly noted LoRA deactivation upon full-text fallback in Sec. 3.5.
  4. Hardware Scaling & Training Cost (Reviewer 31o1): Benchmarks on NVIDIA A800 with HF and vLLM (TP=1, 2) confirm consistent TTFT and throughput gains up to 2.64x (App. S.2, Table 28), while one-time training compute (~400 H20 GPU-hours) is ~5x lower than LatentSkill (App. S.3).
  5. Clarification on KV Prefix Caching in Agent Systems (Reviewer 11ji): Clarified that Full Text with prefix caching is not a substitute in modern agent harnesses, where skills are dynamically injected mid-context after varying environment states and multi-turn histories (invalidating shared prefix caches across users), while remaining compatible with SKIM when prefixes are static. On cached 2k to 8k histories, SKIM still delivers 2x to 3x faster prefill and 2.0x to 3.7x lower KV memory (Sec. 5.3, Table 10 & App. S.1, Table 27).

Thank you again for helping us strengthen our work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.