- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes VG-VLD, which combines variational latent dynamics learned from pooled offline skill data with a value- and distance-based evaluator to connect predefined skill policies.
Critical strengths
VG-VLD combines a shared latent dynamics model with a skill-conditioned evaluator to connect predefined policies using their existing offline data. This provides a practical mechanism for reusing skill policies without online fine-tuning.
Critical weaknesses
-
Given the pooled skill dataset, the paper does not establish why separate skill policies and a stitching module are preferable to goal-conditioned or hierarchical methods such as HIQL, GAS(ICML 2025), and AQM(ICML 2026).
-
Eq. (8) has the same form as HILP’s temporal-distance representation objective, yet HILP is not cited. The additional contribution beyond existing components needs clearer articulation. [HILP] Foundation Policies with Hilbert Representations, ICML 2024
-
Appendix D.8 describes executing sampled generated trajectories, whereas BiTrajDiff originally uses augmented data to train an offline RL policy. This change leaves unclear whether the performance gap reflects algorithmic superiority or the modified baseline implementation.
-
The paper does not investigate whether poor results arise from generation errors, trajectory selection, stopping criteria, or time-budget consumption. Its ablations examine VG-VLD components but do not explain the comparative performance gaps.
-
The statement that all baselines underperform No-Stitching on "bottom burner → light switch" is inconsistent with Table 2, where BiTrajDiff achieves higher AR and CSR-2.
-
Maze experiments use only PointMaze "stitch" datasets filtered to trajectories ending at three selected goals. Retained dataset sizes, state coverage, and inter-skill overlap are not reported, and sensitivity to data quantity and goal selection is not evaluated.
-
Experiments cover only state-vector PointMaze and Kitchen settings. Neither more complex locomotion dynamics, such as AntMaze, nor visual observations are evaluated, and extension to visual environments is not substantively discussed.
-
Despite its section title, “Conclusion and Limitations” identifies no concrete limitations concerning the predefined skill sequence, data coverage, baseline adaptations, or evaluation scope.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the concerns raised in the Weaknesses section.