- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies data selection for end-to-end autonomous driving and proposes CASA, a hierarchical framework that combines sample-level selection with cluster-level budget allocation. The method performs task-aware sample ranking within scene clusters and uses a shared-parameter scaling model to allocate the training budget across clusters. Experimental results demonstrate its effectiveness on NAVSIM with DiffusionDrive, with additional evaluations on WOD-E2E and TransFuser.
Critical strengths
- Well-motivated problem. The paper addresses an important problem in end-to-end autonomous driving by jointly considering the value of individual samples and the allocation of training data across different scene clusters.
- Effective method with good results. The proposed framework achieves promising performance across multiple training budgets, and the ablation studies provide evidence for the contributions of its individual components.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited experimental validation and generalization analysis. Although the paper includes cross-dataset and cross-method experiments, the evaluation still covers a limited range of model architectures and benchmarks. In particular, it would be valuable to evaluate CASA on more recent architectures, such as VLA models, and closed-loop benchmarks, such as CARLA, to assess whether the proposed data selection strategy generalizes to different model paradigms and more realistic interactive driving scenarios. Furthermore, the performance gains in some generalization experiments are relatively small. For example, the improvement over the strongest baseline on WOD-E2E at 1,311 training samples is only 0.0046 in RFS. Additional experiments would help establish the robustness and general applicability of the proposed method.
- Limited evaluation at larger data scales. The evaluated training budgets remain relatively small, with the main NAVSIM experiments considering up to 3,000 training samples. Although the results suggest that CASA can generalize beyond the budget range used to fit its scaling model, it remains unclear whether its advantages persist at substantially larger training scales. Given the large volume of data typically involved in end-to-end autonomous driving, evaluating the method with larger training subsets would provide stronger evidence of its scalability and practical effectiveness. So given the limited results, my initial recommendation is rejection.
Questions for authors
None.