- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Density-Aware Mamba-Transformer (DAMT), a hybrid Transformer-Mamba architecture for coarse-to-fine point cloud registration, aiming to address two limitations of existing methods:
- Transformer-based coarse matching suffers from quadratic computational complexity, while linear-complexity Mamba models struggle to capture the non-sequential geometric structures of unordered 3D point clouds.
- Local point density, as an intrinsic geometric cue, remains underexplored in existing registration frameworks despite its potential to alleviate matching ambiguities in sparse and repetitive regions.
To address these challenges, the authors introduce two main designs. First, DAMT employs a lightweight self-attention stage to establish an initial permutation-invariant global receptive field, together with a Global Norm Pooling (GNP) module inspired by Mamba3D. A bidirectional Mamba module is then used for efficient deep feature aggregation, reducing the reliance on computationally expensive attention layers.
Second, the authors propose a Density-Guided Attention Weighting (DGAW) mechanism that incorporates local point density as both a structural embedding and an auxiliary loss constraint, aiming to learn more discriminative features for point cloud matching.
Critical strengths
1. Favorable trade-off between registration accuracy and computational efficiency.
DAMT demonstrates strong registration performance across multiple benchmarks, including ModelNet/ModelLoNet, 3DMatch/3DLoMatch, and KITTI. Compared with the evaluated baselines, the proposed approach achieves competitive or superior registration accuracy while maintaining relatively low inference latency. These results suggest that the hybrid Transformer-Mamba architecture offers a promising trade-off between matching accuracy and computational efficiency.
2. A potentially useful geometric prior for feature matching.
Explicitly incorporating local point density into geometric feature learning is an interesting direction. The proposed DGAW mechanism complements conventional distance and angular embeddings with density-related information. The reported ablation results indicate that density-aware modeling contributes to the overall registration performance, particularly in challenging matching scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
1. Insufficient experimental evidence supporting the theoretical rationale for point density embedding.
In Appendix F.1, the authors provide two theoretical motivations for incorporating local point density: Breaking Geometric Ambiguity in Repetitive Structures and Implicit Delimitation of Structural Boundaries. While these arguments are intuitively appealing, their effectiveness is not sufficiently demonstrated by the current experiments.
-
Breaking Geometric Ambiguity in Repetitive Structures: The authors argue that local point density can distinguish geometrically similar regions. However, consider two repetitive planar patches in 3DMatch with similar local sampling densities. According to the proposed density formulation, these patches would receive nearly identical density values, leaving their geometric ambiguity unresolved. Conversely, two geometrically corresponding patches may have substantially different observed densities due to occlusion, missing regions, or incomplete sampling. In this case, density inconsistency could potentially suppress correct correspondences.
-
Implicit Delimitation of Structural Boundaries: I generally agree that local density variations may provide useful cues for identifying structural boundaries.
However, neither of these claims has been directly validated through experiments. I suggest that the authors conduct additional controlled experiments:
Breaking Geometric Ambiguity: Investigate whether the proposed method can produce a greater number of correct correspondences and a higher proportion of correct matches for local patch pairs with high geometric ambiguity.
Implicit Delimitation of Structural Boundaries: Investigate whether the proposed method can produce a greater number of correct correspondences and a higher proportion of correct matches for local patch pairs with high curvature.
Although the existing ablation studies demonstrate the overall effectiveness of density-related components, they do not directly validate these two specific theoretical claims. More targeted experiments would substantially strengthen the motivation and reliability of the proposed density prior.
2. Limited validation of the effectiveness of point density normalization.
The authors introduce range-normalized point density to compensate for variations in sampling density caused by sensor distance. However, the experimental evidence for its effectiveness under varying sensing distances remains limited.
The KITTI benchmark already exhibits relatively high registration recall for several existing methods without explicitly incorporating point density priors. Consequently, performance improvements on the standard KITTI setting alone may not be sufficient to demonstrate the advantages of the proposed normalization strategy, particularly under more challenging long-range conditions.
I suggest conducting additional experiments under larger spatial separations, such as KITTI-30m and KITTI-50m [1], to evaluate the effectiveness and robustness of density normalization. Comparisons among models without density guidance, with unnormalized density, and with normalized density would provide stronger evidence for the necessity of the proposed normalization strategy.
Summary
The proposed DAMT achieves advantages in both registration performance and computational efficiency compared with the evaluated methods. However, its methodological novelty is somewhat limited, and the claimed effectiveness of the point density prior lacks direct experimental validation. In addition, there are inconsistencies between the textual descriptions and figures. For rate improving, I believe the paper would be substantially strengthened by solving the weakness .
[1] Xiong, K., Xiang, H., Xu, Q., Wen, C., Shen, S., Li, J., & Wang, C. (2024). Mining and transferring feature-geometry coherence for unsupervised point cloud registration. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 37, 35468-35491.
Questions for authors
1. Inconsistency between the description and illustration of the Global Norm Pooling module.
In Section 3.2, the textual description and mathematical formulation of the GNP module do not appear to be fully consistent with its illustration in Figure 2.
In particular, the G-Norm operation is described as normalizing point features relative to their assigned anchor centers, followed by a learnable affine transformation. However, the operations presented in Figure 2 do not clearly correspond to this formulation.
I suggest that the authors carefully revise the GNP illustration and its corresponding description to ensure consistency among the textual explanations, and architectural diagram.
2. Important evidence supporting the main contributions should be emphasized in the main paper.
The primary contributions of DAMT lie in its computational efficiency and the incorporation of point density as a geometric prior. However, some of the most relevant supporting analyses are either placed in the appendix or insufficiently explored.
In particular, Table 8 (Scalability Test) provides valuable evidence for the computational advantages of the hybrid architecture as point cloud size increases. I recommend moving this experiment to the main paper, since scalability is one of the central motivations of the proposed method.
Similarly, the targeted density-related analyses suggested in Weakness 1 should be included in the main paper in my opinion. These experiments would directly support the claimed geometric benefits of point density embedding and make the methodological contributions more convincing.
2 comments
Thanks for the suggestion and rating improvement
Thanks for raising the rating and the clear framing. We agree that the density prior gives similar patches with different densities distinct descriptors during self-attention, reducing cross-view ambiguity at the cross-attention stage. We'll add this explanation to the revision.
Final Justification: improve the rating from 2 to 3
I thank the authors for their thoughtful response. Although the density prior is applied only in self-attention, this design alone does not establish on theoretical grounds that the prior can help the network recover true correspondences between patches sampled at different densities in the two views. In light of the experiments reported in the rebuttal, one possible explanation is that the density prior guides the network during self-attention to learn distinct features for geometrically similar superpoint patches with different local densities, thereby reducing ambiguity among the features from the two input views during cross-attention. Overall, the authors have fully addressed my concerns, and their results show that combining the density prior with the hybrid Transformer–Mamba architecture improves the trade-off between registration accuracy and computational efficiency. I encourage the authors to consider whether this explanation could clarify the role of the density prior in the revised paper. I have raised my rating to 3.